The Free Press: Speaking Truth to Power Tue Feb 09 2010
Columns
Harvey Wasserman

Obama's stimulus money must NOT be wasted on nuke reactors
January 8, 2009

A nuke power bailout must NOT be part of the hundreds of billions of federal dollars about to pour out of Washington to revive our Bush-whacked economy.

If the huge Obama stimulus package we all know is coming includes money to build new reactors, the whole venture could turn to radioactive dust.

This is the last gasp both for American prosperity and atomic energy. Nuke promoters are lobbying frantically to get some of that cash for a dying business in which Wall Street would not invest even before the last crash.

In 2007 a national grassroots campaign, led in part by Nukefree.org, helped get a proposed $50 billion loan guarantee boondoggle removed from the Energy Bill. In 2008 a blank check was on its way just as Wall Street tanked.

Now, with renewables booming ahead, this may be the last gasp for a desperate industry. Cut off from Wall Street, hordes of nuke lobbyists will descend like radioactive locusts on this gargantuan stimulus package. They must be stopped.

Here are some basic realities:
  • No reactors put into construction in the next few years could produce usable power for at least a decade, probably more;
  • By contrast, large wind farms can be installed in less than a year, as can many other renewable and efficiency installations;
  • Every dollar spent on efficiency can save seven times the energy one spent on an atomic reactor can produce;
  • The numbers of jobs new reactor construction might create is a bare fraction of the number that could come with comparable Solartopian investments in renewables, efficiency and restored mass transit;
  • Atomic energy is now fifty-two years of proven economic failure. From the 1957 opening of the first commercial reactor at Shippingport, Pennsylvania, to the hugely over-budget fiasco of a French reactor now being built in Finland, the "Peaceful Atom" has never turned the corner to true social profitability;
  • The true cost of nuke-generated electricity is obscured by massive "stranded cost" write-offs provided at tax-payer and rate-payer expense during the de-regulation fiasco of the turn of the century that allowed utilities to scam away up to a $100 billion in hidden construction costs;
  • The French nuclear power industry is almost entirely subsidized by the French government, and generates electricity that is expensive, unreliable, unsafe, polluting, has no radioactive waste solution, and cannot compete in the open marketplace;
  • By terror or error, every atomic reactor is an unguardable, uninsurable agent of a potential apocalypse; the human and financial toll from a possible melt-down is incalculable….which is why, after a half-century, only the government is willing to insure them;
  • Through the mining, milling, enrichment, transportation and waste management demands of the nuclear fuel cycle, atomic power is a significant contributor to global warming;
  • Water has become a major issue in the reactor calculus, to the point that shortages and overheating threaten their continued operation. Reactors in France and Alabama, among other places, have been forced to shut when rivers used to cool them have exceeded 90 degrees Fahrenheit;
  • Funds set aside to decommission aging plants such as Vermont Yankee and Indian Point, near New York City, have been decimated by the Wall Street crash, raising serious question about how they will be disposed of when they shut, which may be soon;
  • Aging US reactors are plagued with the embrittlement of key interior metal components which threaten their continued safety;
  • After a half-century, no real solution has been found for managing the high-level radioactive wastes that come from nuke reactors. The proposed Yucca Mountain dump, now approaching $100 billion, is a non-starter, with sworn opposition from the President-elect and Senate Majority Leader, and with no real alternative in sight.
  • A wide range of studies dating back to the late 1960s and findings by Dr. John Gofman, former Health Director of the Atomic Energy Commission, link "routine" radioactive emissions from America's nuclear plants to serious impacts on human health.
For these and many more reasons, any stimulus money spent on nuclear plants would be a major negative to our economy, ecology and public health.

Recent talk of a "fourth generation" of atomic reactors is pure pie-in-the-sky speculation. There are no proven nuclear technologies that can compete with wind, solar, increased efficiencies or other Solartopian sources.

It is critical that any proposed funding for new reactor construction that might be slipped into the stimulus package be entirely eliminated.

This massive new investment about to be made in the future of our economy must not be corrupted to bail out the very worst of the 20th Century's failed technologies.

Renewables and efficiency work. If we fund them now, the payback will be exponential.

Various petitions are circulating from Physicians for Social Responsibility (PSR.org), the Sustainable Energy Network and others. Or just call and write the White House, Senate, Congress and local officials where reactors are proposed and demand a halt to this suicidal madness.

Let's kill this so-called nuclear revival once and for all, so we can finally win a world powered by truly green technologies that actually work.

--
Harvey Wasserman's SOLARTOPIA! OUR GREEN-POWERED EARTH is at http://www.harveywasserman.com. He edits http://NukeFree.org. This article was originally published by http://freepress.org.


Email this article to a friend




1240 Bryden Road Columbus, Ohio 43209 Ph/Fx 614.253.2571 Email truth@freepress.org
  

Click here to visit Harvey Wasserman's Solartopia.org.

Don't forget to check out articles from 2008 and 2009

Harvey Wasserman

"A quiet but HUGE no nukes triumph "
  December 23, 2009

"Curbing carbon's just the tip of our great green leap"
  December 13, 2009

"Now WE must earn Obama's Nobel"
  December 11, 2009

"Tonight Obama's escalation will be IMMEDIATELY opposed"
  December 1, 2009

"What's the carbon/health footprint of another senseless war?"
  November 30, 2009

"Still more fluff, lies and radiation from TMI and the new nuke media machine"
  November 24, 2009

"For Obama it's one (term) if by war, two if by peace"
  November 16, 2009

"The reactor relapse takes 3 hits to the head "
  November 12, 2009

"Hall of Fame benefit takes rock & roll to a new level"
  November 3, 2009

"Is this Tom Friedman's "Walter Cronkite Moment" on Afghanistan? "
  October 29, 2009

"Beware a Times/Pentagon "virtual coup" on Afghanistan"
  October 24, 2009

"Is the climate bill being fossil/nuked? "
  October 14, 2009

"That Nobel screams: "Out of Afghanistan & Go for Solartopia!""
  October 10, 2009

"Obama will also lose the Afghani Olympics"
  October 3, 2009

"Obama's LBJ moment"
  September 27, 2009

"Tom Friedman's idiocy atomique"
  September 22, 2009

"Will the Corporate Supremes now dance on democracy's corpse?"
  September 14, 2009

"Obama has fed his Green Jones to King CONG "
  September 6, 2009

"BonTaj Roulet blazes new ground raising green for Greens"
  September 3, 2009

"The clock is ticking ever faster for Leonard Peltier"
  August 11, 2009

"How Leonard Peltier could leave prison by August 18 "
  July 30, 2009

"Today we all stand before Leonard Peltier’s Parole Board"
  July 28, 2009

"Walter Cronkite, 3 Mile Island & "Lamar's Folly" in the Climate Bill"
  July 21, 2009

"Big Nuke's desperate radioactive hoax in impoverished Ohio"
  June 18, 2009

"The GOP’s 100-reactor/trillion-dollar energy plan goes radioactive"
  June 11, 2009

"The NYTimes finally reports the economic disaster of new nukes"
  May 29, 2009

"The 8 green steps to Solartopia"
  May 26, 2009

"Who will pay for America's Chernobyl roulette? "
  April 26, 2009

"How Chernobyl could happen here"
  April 21, 2009

"Yet another $50 billion for rust-bucket nukes?"
  April 10, 2009

"Cracking the corporate media's Iron Curtain around death at Three Mile Island"
  April 1, 2009

"Three Mile Island: 30th anniversary of the worst nuclear accident in US history"
  March 28, 2009

"People died at Three Mile Island "
  March 24, 2009

"France's nuke power poster child has a money melt-down"
  March 19, 2009

"Is this the end of the age of the automobile?"
  March 9, 2009

"Obama's excellent atomic omission"
  February 26, 2009

"Feds ignore jet crashes at operating reactors"
  February 20, 2009

"Was George Washington a gay pot smoker?"
  February 15, 2009

"Another spectacular $50 billion no nukes victory for the forces of Solartopia"
  February 12, 2009

"Why is that $50 billion radioactive antique toilet still in the stimulus bill?"
  February 9, 2009

"A $50 billion nuke debate at Democracy NOW!"
  February 6, 2009

"A $50 Billion nuke power bomb is dropping toward Obama’s stimulus package"
  January 31, 2009

"This President’s Day remember that George Washington raised hemp and probably smoked it"
  January 29, 2009

"A ten-point Solartopian starter agenda for the Age of Obama"
  January 19, 2009

"Obama's stimulus money must NOT be wasted on nuke reactors"
  January 8, 2009




Read Articles by Year:
2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000




All content © 1970-2009
The Columbus Free Press
Disclaimer