Fri Feb 10 2012

Departments
Letters to the Editor/
Free Press Forum

Coleman is No Hog
by Howard Tolley, Jr.
April 14, 2002

Readers "On the Same Page" in Cincinnati are discussing William Gaines A Lesson Before Dying in a community wide effort to improve racial understanding. The author will visit during the week Cincinnatišs notorious serial killer, Alton Coleman, has an April 26 execution date.

Gaines' novel tells the story of a black southerner sentenced to death by an all white jury for a killing committed by two other men. In closing argument to the jury, defense counsel characterized his client as a "hog." Gaines poignantly describes the death row inmate's struggle to recover his humanity and to face execution with dignity.

As a black defendant, Alton Coleman faced similar racial bias in Hamilton Countyšs criminal justice system. The prosecutors used nine of their twelve peremptory challenges to exclude prospective black jurors, and only two African Americans were included on the trial panel.

Alton Coleman is a madman, not a hog; Ohio should not execute him like a wild animal. Coleman and codefendant Debra Brown went on a multi-state killing spree that resulted in a series of indescribably bloody murders. Even if such evil killers were sane, no other government in Western Civilization would execute for those crimes.

Psychiatrists have identified ample evidence of Colemanšs mental illness following head injuries suffered in a childhood accident as well as physical and sexual abuse. Coleman refused to cooperate with trial counsel, and none of that mitigating evidence was presented to the sentencing juries. As a result, in one Cincinnati case an appeals court ordered a new trial.

In a second appeal raising the same issue, his death penalty was upheld and the execution date set, even though Debra Brown has confessed that she, not Coleman, was solely responsible for that murder.

Unlike Ohiošs Governor Robert Taft, Russian President Vladimir Putin has opposed popular appeals that his government reinstitute capital punishment. Since 1999 this statešs chief executive has approved three executions, despite compelling evidence of mental illness in the cases of Wilford Berry and J.D. Scott, and substantial doubts about the actual guilt of John Byrd.

All the worldšs liberal democracies except the U.S. refuse to dehumanize murderers and bar the execution of even the most vicious killers. When will Ohiošs governor, lawmakers and voters heed the powerful objections to capital punishment voiced by the American Bar Association, mental health professionals, most of the major religious denominations, and compelling witnesses like Sister Helen Prejean and William Gaines?

Howard Tolley, Jr.
Professor of Political Science
University of Cincinnati

Recent Letters to the Editor/
Free Press Forum Articles

Money, Politics and an Upper Middle Class Suburban High School
December 30, 2002
Bethany Bowers

City Green
December 27, 2002
Gregory Gross

Thoughts on the question of war with Iraq
December 16, 2002
Tom Harker

The Axis of Deceit
December 8, 2002
Prashant

Answers to your questions
November 25, 2002
Andy Hawk

Reflections after the rally for peace
November 10, 2002
MJ Willow

Oh dear father
November 10, 2002
Mike Cheeseman

A Critique of the Columbus Activist Community
November 4, 2002
Tim Lemmon

Iraq Again
October 13, 2002
D. McKinsey, HIllard

Dysart Woods
May 6, 2002
Chad Kister

Another Execution -- 'The Chimes, Capital University'
April 22, 2002
Jack S. Byrom