Departments
Regarding the electoral college
by Mark Rustad
November 12, 2012
I saw the article that made it to nationofchange.org. I used to think that the electoral college should be abolished as well. After having served as an election judge in Minnesota through several cycles, I see one major drawback to using the direct popular vote. In a really close election, does anyone want to consider what a nationwide recount would look like? Seriously, I think that is a huge and real potential problem.
Instead, I would like to see the electors to come out of each congressional district. That would limit the scope of recounts and make them manageable. So, what to do with the other two electors per state? Well, the states could decide to award them based on popular vote in the state. That would seem best. Of course in a state like North Dakota, it would essentially still be winner-take-all, but that is a natural outcome of only having one congressional district.
The most distorting thing in our current system is that it is winner-take-all for entire states. That is what should be abolished! Electing the electors out of the congressional districts would make the process much closer to the popular vote and, like the popular vote, require candidates to campaign far more broadly. That would be good for everyone.
Please think more about a possible recount scenario in the case of a direct popular vote. I think it really is a problem that needs to be avoided, while bringing our system closer to that ideal.
|
 |
Recent Letters to the Editor/ Free Press Forum Articles
Animal Rights Laws December 6, 2012 Vivian Stevenson
Lost military veteran December 2, 2012 Peter Macdonald Sgt USMC Semper Fi
The NAACP commemorates World AIDS Day December 2, 2012 Roslyn M. Brock
Defunding Planned Parenthood November 24, 2012 Paige Piper
Regarding the electoral college November 12, 2012 Mark Rustad
Thank you, Bob! November 8, 2012 Mary Ellen Azzi
ELECTIONS HAVE CONSEQUENCES: CHEATING FAILS, BUT DOES REALITY WIN? November 8, 2012 William Boardman
Letter to a friend who urges me not to vote for either major presidential candidate October 28, 2012 Bob Sheak
2004 and 2012: Reflection and premonition: Then and now October 27, 2012 Doug Todd
Birth control mandate in Affordable Care Act October 11, 2012 Acacia Cook
Whatever happened to the solar panels? August 6, 2012 Christopher Bifani
About the Colorado movie theater shooting July 21, 2012 Joe Bialek
Affordable Care Act important for women's health July 5, 2012 Catie A. Lehman
Support birth control mandate June 15, 2012 Brittany Craig
The JP Morgan Chase investment debacle May 29, 2012 Joe Bialek
Kent State May 3, 2012 Joe Bialek
Gerrymandering creates undemocratic districts angers My Mom at the same time April 8, 2012 Robert Letcher
Irony accompanied Obama on his trip to Columbus April 8, 2012 Robert Letcher
How to get gas prices to drop like a rock April 8, 2012
Young women and healthcare coverage March 30, 2012 Kelly Novak
Rush Limbaugh's comments about Sandra Fluke March 11, 2012 Joe Bialek
School lunches and our economy January 26, 2012 Bruce Bostick
The Keystone XL Pipeline would be an environmental disaster January 16, 2012 Albert A. Gabel
Occupy and big unions January 10, 2012 Bruce Bostick
Midnight in Paris January 6, 2012 Christine R.
Read Letters to the Editor/ Free Press Forum Articles by Year: 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |