Sat May 25 2013
Departments
War

White House Said In Jan It Used Info From Iraqi Exiles In Pres State of the Union Speech
by Jason Leopold
July 28, 2003

Last weekend, Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz explained that the United States at times relied on "murky" intelligence in trying to link Iraq to the al-Qaeda terrorist group, but the war against Iraq was justified despite the fact that the White House is now being dogged by questions about the accuracy of its prewar intelligence.  

"The nature of terrorism intelligence is intrinsically murky," Wolfowitz said on "Meet the Press. "If you wait until the terrorism picture is clear, you're going to wait until after something terrible has happened."    

But the reasons behind the murky intelligence used by the White House to build a case for war against Iraq may have more to do with the people who provided the Pentagon and the White House with its information on Iraq's alleged weapons of mass destruction than the difficulties the intelligence community already faces in trying to obtain reliable intelligence from a variety of sources.  

"Having concluded that international inspectors are unlikely to find tangible and irrefutable evidence that Iraq is hiding weapons of mass destruction, the Bush administration is preparing its own assessment that will rely heavily on evidence from Iraqi defectors, according to senior administration officials," The New York Times reported Jan. 23.  

In addition, Bush administration officials said Jan. 23 some of the intelligence information provided by the Iraqi defectors would likely be included in the president's State of the Union address, which may explain why the White House has come under fire for failing to paint an accurate picture of the Iraqi threat-it is well-known among intelligence experts that much of the information provided by Iraqi defectors is unreliable.

"The White House asked administration intelligence analysts . to use the information from the defectors as part of a "bill of particulars" that the administration hopes will convince skeptical allies and the American public that Iraq's behavior warrants military action, the officials said," The Times reported. "In addition, they said, it may be incorporated into President Bush's State of the Union address on Jan. 28."

Many of the defectors were encouraged to speak to intelligence officials by Ahmad Chalabi, head of the Iraqi National Congress, an exile group with close ties to the White House. There continue to be deep divisions in Washington over the value of information from defectors associated with Chalabi's group.

"The Pentagon's Defense Intelligence Agency has been the most receptive to the defectors intelligence, saying that defectors are critical to penetrating Iraq's deceptive practices. The CIA has often been dismissive of the defectors and questioned their credibility, according to administration officials," the Times reported.

As lawmakers in Washington begin investigations into the accuracy of pre-war intelligence, they should question whether the White House and the Pentagon used dubious information from Iraqi defectors to help sway public opinion in supporting the war and whether some of that information was included in Bush's State of the Union address in January.  

Five days before President's Bush's State of the Union Speech Jan. 28, Wolfowitz spoke to the Council of Foreign Relations in New York and credited Iraqi defectors with providing the Pentagon and other U.S. "intelligence agencies" much of the information on Iraq's secret weapons programs that has long been dismissed by military personnel in Iraq as unreliable.  

Wolfowitz said in his Jan. 23, presentation to the Council of Foreign Relations that it was Iraqi defectors who told the CIA and the Pentagon about mobile trailers in Iraq that were allegedly used to produce biological weapons.  

"We know about that capability from defectors and other sources," Wolfowitz said during his speech, which can be found at http://www.defenselink.mil/news/Jan2003/t01232003_t0123cfr.html "For a great body of what we need to know, we are very dependent on traditional methods of intelligence - that is to say, human beings who are either deliberately or inadvertently communicating to us."

  Secretary of State Colin Powell in his February presentation to the United Nations where he was trying to win support for war, pointed to the trailers as evidence of Iraq's secret weapons program.

When the trailers were found in May, President Bush, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld and National Security Adviser Condoleeza Rice were quick to point out that the trailers were used to produce lethal chemical weapons, even though no traces of any chemical weapons were found inside the trailers.

But the State Department in a June 2 classified memorandum disputed the conclusion that the trailers were used to cook up deadly weapons. United Nations weapons inspectors said that the trailers were likely used to produce hydrogen for weather balloons.

Prior to the war in March, Wolfowitz said some of the most valuable information it received came from Adnan Ihsan Saeed al-Haideri, a contractor who escaped Iraq in the summer of 2001. He told American officials that chemical and biological weapons laboratories were hidden beneath hospitals and inside presidential palaces and he provided documents to back up some of his other assertions about Iraq's weapons programs.

In December and January, the White House highlighted Haideri's claims against Iraq in a report called "Iraq; A Decade of Deception and Defiance" and in a fact sheet on Iraq posted on the White Houses web site. But when U.S. forces searched the hospitals and presidential palaces where Haideri said weapons were hidden they found nothing, not even evidence that weapons had ever been there.




Recent War Articles

US to release 140 detainees from Guantanamo
  December 7, 2003
  Bill Mandel

Bush II Foreign Policy: Naked Recklessness or is it Treason?
  November 7, 2003
  Bob Zimmerman

Protesters Want U.S. Out of Iraq
  October 26, 2003
  William Hughes

Corporations Are the Only Victors in Iraq
  September 15, 2003
  Devin Nordberg

Dems Scrap Plans To Look Into Claims White House Manipulated Intel On Iraqi Threat
  September 14, 2003
  Jason Leopold

A question almost unthinkable
  August 9, 2003
  James R. Hanson

Wolfowitz: Iraq Was Not Involved In 9-11 Terrorist Attacks, No Ties To Al-Qaeda
  August 6, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Hope out of Quagmire: New peace movement opportunities
  July 30, 2003
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Kucinich: U.S. Troops Out!
  July 29, 2003
  Kucinich Campaign

White House Said In Jan It Used Info From Iraqi Exiles In Pres State of the Union Speech
  July 28, 2003
  Jason Leopold

CIA Probe Finds Secret Pentagon Group Manipulated Intelligence on Iraqi Threat
  July 25, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Letter from Peggy Gish, CPT Iraq
  July 25, 2003
  Peggy Gish

16 questions for Bush
  July 21, 2003
  Free Press Staff

Is the Bush Doctrine Tenable?
  July 16, 2003
  Jesse Lee

Wolfowitz Committee Instructed White House To Use Iraq/Uranium Ref In Pres Speech
  July 16, 2003
  Jason Leopold

'The Road to Hell Is Paved With Good Intentions'
  July 15, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Trickle Down Lying; The Gamble Failed and it's Time for the Bush Regime to Pay, Starting with Cheney's Impeachment
  July 15, 2003
  Rob Kall

Tenet Fell on His Sword for 9-11 Too
  July 12, 2003
  Allan P. Duncan

Like Iraq, CIA Also Exaggerated Soviet Nuclear Threat During Cold War
  June 30, 2003
  Jason Leopold

CIA Intelligence Reports Seven Months Before 9-11 Said Iraq Posed No Threat To U.S., Containment Was Working
  June 28, 2003
  Jason Leopold

CPT Report from Iraq
  June 26, 2003
  Gene Stoltzfus

Wolfowitz Sought To Undermine Blix So US Could Launch Preemptive Strike Against Iraq in 02
  June 25, 2003
  Jason Leopold

CPT Iraq Team reports from Iraq
  June 20, 2003
  Peggy Gish

Anti-war music
  June 17, 2003
  Various Artists

White House Silenced Experts Who Questioned Iraq Intel Info Six Months Before War
  June 12, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Powell Denies Intelligence Failure In Buildup To War, But Evidence Doesn't Hold Up
  June 10, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Was Always Based On Shaky Evidence And Wrong Intelligence Info
  June 3, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Wolfowitz Admits Iraq War Planned Two Days After 9-11
  June 2, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Nuking Iraq
  May 28, 2003
  William Thomas

Rover Lost in Paradise
  May 28, 2003
  P. Thomas Harker

Despite Thin Intelligence Reports, US Plans To Overthrow Iranian Regime
  May 28, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Defense Dept Secretly Tapped Halliburton Unit To Operate Iraq's Oil Industry In November
  May 14, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Cheney’s Old Company Continues To Break Law’s While Profiting From Terror
  May 9, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Michael Moore Was Right
  April 20, 2003
  The Concerned Rev

Other Hearts
  April 18, 2003
  Kathy Kelly

War Fact Sheet
  April 18, 2003
  BulletinBoardforPeace.org

A contemporary chronology of Iraq
  April 15, 2003
  Link

Company Chosen By Pentagon To Extinguish Iraqi Oil Well Fires Has History Of Supporting Terrorist Regimes
  April 15, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Rad Times Email Update 6
  April 14, 2003
  Rad Times

Iraq URL list
  April 7, 2003
  Rad Times

How to Lose a War in Ten Days
  April 1, 2003
  Larry Fairbanks

Rummy's Failed War Plan And The Casualties That May Result
  March 31, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Transgendered anti-war protester verbally, physically abused by police
  March 28, 2003
  Robyn Walters

Ohio Muslims open dialogue with FBI
  March 27, 2003
  Jad Humeidan

Women's Organizations Worldwide Urge General Assembly to "Unite for Peace"
  March 27, 2003
  Sarah Widmer

The Reality of War Sinks In With Casualties of U.S. and British Soldiers
  March 25, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Statement to the Troops
  March 24, 2003
  Veterans of the United States armed forces

This War Is Illegal
  March 23, 2003
  Robin Miller

Message from Baghdad
  March 22, 2003
  Jeff Guntzel of Iraq Peace Team

Vets To Top US Military Commanders: Remember Nuremberg
  March 20, 2003
  Veterans for Peace

A plea to Laura Bush to assume the Presidency
  March 19, 2003
  Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman

Christian Peacemakers report from the Middle East
  March 19, 2003
  Peggy Gish

Why I had to leave the cabinet
  March 19, 2003
  Robin Cook

No Support for War
  March 19, 2003
  James "Guin" McGuinness

Forgery of evidence against Iraq will become easier, tonight
  March 19, 2003
  Leonardo Rodrigo

Even As Bombs Drop, Hypocrisy Prevails
  March 19, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Letters to Americans from Iraqi High School Students
  March 19, 2003
  Transmitted by Iraq Peace Team

INTERNATIONAL LAW: A duty to disobey all unlawful orders
  March 17, 2003
   Dr. Lawrence Mosqueda

Diplomacy and no first use of nukes urged in Iraq crisis
  March 17, 2003
  Paul Kawika Martin

Howard Dean's statement on the President's decision to send U.S. Military troops into war against Iraq
  March 17, 2003
  Howard Dean, M.D.

Letter from Michael Moore to George W. Bush
  March 17, 2003
  Michael Moore

Pres Bush Reminds World of Iraq’s Crimes Against Humanity That His Father Failed To Punish
  March 16, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Global Crisis: Grave Danger -- and Great Opportunity
  March 13, 2003
  John McConnell -- The Man Who Started Earth Day

Rumsfeld, Bush  Sr. Refused To Back 1989 UN Resolution To Investigate Iraq For Human Rights Abuses
  March 13, 2003
  Jason Leopold

What Can the World Do if the US Attacks Iraq?
  March 10, 2003
  Jeremy Brecher

U.S. Could Launch Attack Against North Korea While Troops Fight In Iraq, Rumsfeld Says
  March 10, 2003
  Jason Leopold

With War Looming, Iraqi Oil Imports May Be Strained; Time To Open Up ANWR, GOP Says
  March 9, 2003
  Jason Leopold

George W. Bush Must Answer to the People
  March 7, 2003
  www.votetoimpeach.org

Bush Sr. Said In 1996 That War With Iraq `Would Turn Entire Arab World Against Us’
  March 6, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Bush and America's willing executioners would be guilty at Nuremberg
  March 4, 2003
  Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman

For Six Years, Right-Wing Think Tank Has Been Hell-Bent For War
  February 27, 2003
  Jason Leopold

Dennis Kucinich on CNN's Crossfire
  February 22, 2003
  Dennis Kucinich

Questions about who set the oil well fires in Kuwait
  February 21, 2003
  American Gulf War Veterans Association

Words of Wisdom From An Armor Master
  February 20, 2003
  SFC Red Thomas, USA(Ret), Armor Master Gunner,Mesa, AZ

U.S. Bombings
  January 26, 2003
  Free Press Staff

Iraq attack will usher in New World Oil Order
  January 26, 2003
  Michael Renner, Sr. Researcher, Worldwatch Institute

LEAKED WHITE HOUSE TRANSCRIPT: BUSH, CHENEY, ETC.
  January 14, 2003
  Lee Waters




Read War Articles by Year:
2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000



FREE PRESS EMAIL UPDATE


Donate to the Free Press Election Protection Fund to help us investigate and monitor election fraud in this year's election.


Donate to The Free Press The Free Press Store

FOLLOW US ON
twitter
facebook


SEARCH THE FREEPRESS




1021 E. Broad St. Columbus, OH 43205 | 614.253.2571 | truth@freepress.org
All content © 1970-2012 The Columbus Free Press
Disclaimer