Fri Feb 10 2012
Departments
War

Death in U.S. custody
by William Fisher
February 26, 2006

A major human rights advocacy group is charging that of the 98 detainees who have died in U.S. custody in Iraq and Afghanistan since August 2002, 34 are suspected or confirmed homicides, another 11 suggest that death was a result of physical abuse or harsh conditions, but only 12 deaths have resulted in punishment of any kind for any U.S. official.

In close to half the deaths surveyed in a new report by Human Rights First, the cause of death remains officially undetermined or unannounced. Overall, eight people in U.S. custody were tortured to death.

The report, entitled “Command’s Responsibility”, says that of the 34 homicide cases so far identified by the military, investigators recommended criminal charges in fewer than two thirds, and charges were actually brought (based on decisions made by command) in less than half.

While the CIA has been implicated in several deaths, no CIA agent has faced a criminal charge, the report says, adding, “Among the worst cases -- detainees tortured to death – only half have resulted in punishment and the harshest sentence for anyone involved in a torture-related death has been five months in jail.”

Among the report’s other findings: Commanders have failed to report deaths of detainees in the custody of their command, reported the deaths only after a period of days and sometimes weeks, or actively interfered in efforts to pursue investigations; investigators have failed to interview key witnesses, collect useable evidence, or maintain evidence that could be used for any subsequent prosecution; record keeping has been inadequate, further undermining chances for effective investigation or appropriate prosecution; overlapping criminal and administrative investigations have compromised chances for accountability; overbroad classification of information and other investigation restrictions have left CIA and Special Forces essentially immune from accountability; agencies have failed to disclose critical information, including the cause or circumstance of death, in close to half the cases examined; effective punishment has been too little and too late.

Charging that there is an “accountability gap”, HRF says closing it will require “a zero-tolerance approach to commanders who fail to take steps to provide clear guidance, and who allow unlawful conduct to persist on their watch.”

The report recommends that the President, as Commander-in-Chief, “move immediately to fully implement the ban on cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment (known as the McCain Amendment) passed overwhelmingly by the U.S. Congress and signed into law on December 30, 2005”.

It also demands that “the President, the U.S. military, and relevant intelligence agencies should take immediate steps to make clear that all acts of torture and abuse are taken seriously – not from the moment a crime becomes public, but from the moment the United States sends troops and agents into the field”.

Congress, the report suggests, “should at long last establish an independent, bipartisan    commission to review the scope of U.S. detention and interrogation operations worldwide in the ‘war on terror’. Such a commission could investigate and identify the systemic causes of failures that lead to torture, abuse, and wrongful death, and chart a detailed and specific path going forward to make sure those mistakes never happen again. The proposal for a commission has been endorsed by a wide range of distinguished Americans from Republican and Democratic members of Congress to former presidents to leaders in the U.S. military. Human Rights First urges Congress to act without further delay.”

Deborah Pearlstein, Director of HRF’s U.S. Law and Security Program, said the Pentagon’s detention policies have repeatedly been criticized by military lawyers and health officials, but their objections have largely been ignored.

Most recently, it was revealed that one of the Pentagon's top civilian lawyers repeatedly challenged the Bush administration's policy on the coercive interrogation of terror suspects, arguing that such practices violated the law, verged on torture and could ultimately expose senior officials to prosecution.

Mora's campaign underscores how contrary views were often brushed aside in administration debates on the subject.

"Even if one wanted to authorize the U.S. military to conduct coercive interrogations, as was the case in Guantánamo, how could one do so without profoundly altering its core values and character?" Mr. Mora asked the Pentagon's chief lawyer, William J. Haynes II, in a 22-page memorandum.

The Pentagon has declined to comment on specific assertions in Mr. Mora's memorandum.

"Detainee operations and interrogation policies have been scrutinized under a microscope, from all different angles," a spokesperson said. "It was found that it was not a Department of Defense policy to encourage or condone torture."

The HRF report notes that “It is difficult to assess the systemic adequacy of punishment when so few have been punished, and when the deliberations of juries and commanders are largely unknown. Nonetheless, two patterns clearly emerge and are documented in Command’s Responsibility: (1) because of investigative and evidentiary failures, accountability for wrongdoing has been limited at best, and almost non-existent for command; and (2) commanders have played a key role in undermining chances for full accountability.”

It adds, “In dozens of cases documented in the report, grossly inadequate reporting, investigation, and follow-through have left no one at all responsible for homicides and other unexplained deaths. Commanders have failed both to provide troops clear guidance, and to take crimes seriously by insisting on vigorous investigations. And command responsibility itself – the law that requires commanders to be held liable for the unlawful acts of their subordinates about which they knew or should have known – has been all but forgotten.”

Which reminds me that “Command Responsibility” is supposed to begin with the Commander-in-Chief.           Please click on the link below. THE WORLD ACCORDING TO BILL FISHER


Recent War Articles

Rules of engagement
  December 16, 2006
  Robert C. Koehler

If they vote for war, occupy 'em!
  December 15, 2006
  Mike Ferner

The Baker Boys: stay half the course. Iraq Study Group or Saudi Protection League?
  December 8, 2006
  Greg Palast

Permanent bases and temporary presidents
  December 8, 2006
  David Swanson

Found: Saddam's weapon of mass destruction
  December 6, 2006
  Greg Palast

Honesty in Iraq
  December 6, 2006
  David Swanson

Malachi burns himself alive for peace: More links
  November 19, 2006
  Mari Jo Muser

To the victors belongs impunity: of incorrigible transgressors, tacit complicity, and Lady Justice’s conspicuous absence
  November 15, 2006
  Jason Miller

The plan Bush is looking for
  November 5, 2006
  David Swanson

Oneonta
  November 1, 2006
  David Swanson

Rumsfeld and Saddam: partners in crimes against humanity
  October 26, 2006
  David Swanson

A few corpses past 'whatever'
  October 19, 2006
  Robert C. Koehler

Breaking the silence of the night  
  October 19, 2006
  Ron Kovic

Let humanity's mutiny begin!
  August 14, 2006
  Mike Ferner

So Osama walks into this bar, see?
  August 14, 2006
  Greg Palast

AWOL Sergeant to turn himself in today resisting illegal Iraq war
  August 11, 2006
  David Swanson

The best thing in the world for big oil
  August 4, 2006
  Bobby Kennedy and Palast

Pentagon calling up military reservists who are ill
  July 16, 2006
  Gene C. Gerard

Wounded to the soul
  July 16, 2006
  Robert C. Koehler

Class action for wounded Iraq war veterans and family members
  July 8, 2006
  nowaybush.info

Command rape
  July 7, 2006
  David Swanson

Hadji girl
  July 5, 2006
  Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services

First commissioned officer to refuse deployment to unlawful Iraq war officially charged by U.S. Army
  July 5, 2006
  Friends and family of Lt. Ehren Watada

Despite it being the worst military blunder in U.S history, the GOP sees Iraq war as campaign opportunity. Am I missing something?
  June 26, 2006
  The Ostroy Report

Rove outlines Busheviks' Iraq strategy to win midterms: lie again about Dems being weak on terrorism
  June 14, 2006
  The Ostroy Report

Unreported: The Zarqawi invitation
  June 11, 2006
  Greg Palast

Let's stay in Iraq until it's peaceful or we're sane, whichever comes first
  June 6, 2006
  David Swanson

More -- lots more
  June 6, 2006
  Mike Ferner

Why the ‘War Resisters Support Campaign’ in Canada is important to the U.S. anti-war movement
  June 6, 2006
  Virginia Rodino

Corporate Media symptom number 13: Play along, get along.
  June 6, 2006
  Tim Copeland

Gold Star mother urges Americans to sign the voters pledge no more pro-war candidates, no more wars of choice
  May 27, 2006
  Tia Steele

43,000 reasons not to attack Iran
  May 25, 2006
  David Swanson

Cindy Sheehan's new book: Dear President Bush
  May 15, 2006
  David Swanson

Atheists for Peace
  May 7, 2006
  David Swanson

Lobbying Hitler's legislature for peace
  May 5, 2006
  David Swanson

The war looks different from inside Congress
  April 27, 2006
  David Swanson

Congressional hearing on Iraq planned
  April 25, 2006
  David Swanson

State Department memo: '16 Words' were false
  April 19, 2006
  Jason Leopold

America’s "noble" cause: preserving its right to murder, exploit, torture, and impoverish with impunity
  April 10, 2006
  Jason Miller

Bush's "New Kind of Democracy" for Iraq
  March 30, 2006
  The Ostroy Report

Justice -- not war -- in the Philippines protests Iraq war at military recruitment center
  March 24, 2006
  Network in Solidarity with the People of the Philippines

Columbus, Ohio March 18th protest footage
  March 21, 2006
  Columbus IMC

Homeland dreamland
  March 17, 2006
  David Swanson

War protesters gather for anniversary
  March 16, 2006
  Jessica Kitchin

Antiwar activists arrested at House Appropriations Committee meeting
  March 10, 2006
  Mike Ferner and Jeff Leys

Three years on
  March 6, 2006
  Tom Huffman

Get this: U.S. troops believe in Bush's Iraq fiasco as much as Cindy Sheehan
  March 1, 2006
  The Ostroy Report

Torture, and a little matter of genocide
  March 1, 2006
   Jason Miller

Death in U.S. custody
  February 26, 2006
  William Fisher

There are lives in the balance
  February 24, 2006
  Mike Ferner

Winter of our discontent: 34-day fast  February 15 to March 20 at U.S. Capitol to end the Iraq war
  February 14, 2006
  Mike Ferner

How you -- yes you -- can end the war
  February 14, 2006
  David Swanson

Hole in the future
  February 3, 2006
  Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services

Phony UN airplanes to provoke war
  February 2, 2006
  David Swanson

Prosecutor probing Niger forgeries, possible conspiracy in CIA leak
  January 28, 2006
  Jason Leopold

Today in Iraq for perspective, commentary and news
  January 10, 2006
  Kevin Zeese   

Active-duty military support for Bush and the Iraq war dropping
  January 6, 2006
  Kevin B. Zeese

Greed and gall: asking Iraq to pay for its occupation
  January 4, 2006
  David Swanson

Top ten anti-war news stories of 2005 and the underreported stories of the year
  January 2, 2006
  Kevin Zeese




Read War Articles by Year:
2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000



FREE PRESS EMAIL UPDATE


Donate to The Free Press The Free Press Store

FOLLOW US ON
twitter
facebook


SEARCH THE FREEPRESS




1021 E. Broad St. Columbus, OH 43205 | 614.253.2571 | truth@freepress.org
All content © 1970-2012 The Columbus Free Press
Disclaimer