Departments
Rules of engagement
by Robert C. Koehler
December 16, 2006
What illegitimate secrets lie hidden behind the word "classified"?
"The government is stalling us," Marguerite Hiken of the Military Law Task Force told me. "They're going to be embarrassed and they're scared to death of war crimes charges."
Could it be that some high-level secrets are that tawdry? Could it be that war is waged - not fought, but set into motion - by, well . . . cowards, who feel themselves entitled to protection from the consequences of their decisions? If so, I'm in favor of an anti-smoking-style campaign that deglamorizes militarism by showing the wizards behind the curtain in full CYA scramble.
For that reason, I'll be interested to see how the lawsuit that Hiken's organization recently filed against the U.S. Defense Department plays out. The Task Force, which is part of the National Lawyers Guild, has a simple question for the DoD, the answer to which it was unable to get through a Freedom of Information Act request: What were the rules of engagement for soldiers at Fallujah, the Cincinnati-sized city leveled in Operation Phantom Fury two years ago, and in the shooting of Giuliana Sgrena, the Italian journalist who had written about Fallujah, whose car was riddled by bullets at a U.S. checkpoint in Iraq?
In other words, what acts are off-limits in this war? What casualty-limiting moral restraints are put on soldiers - or maybe I mean not taken away from them - as they are sent into battle? And why is this classified? Why is this a secret?
God knows, the answer seems apparent simply by looking at the results. But then again, only a small percentage of Americans are doing that, at least more than cursorily. Every American excess - a rape here, a wounded prisoner's brains blown out there - is isolated and contained. It's an aberration. We may be losing to the insurgents, whoever they are, but we're still the good guys.
Not only is this not the case, I submit, but it is crucial that the sustaining mythology of the notion be detonated with the truth, so that future ideologues don't have access to it when they try to launch the nation's next war of choice and profit - and so that, as we debate the future of George Bush's war, we know what "stay the course" actually means.
What the Military Law Task Force, which assists GIs with legal and other problems - and thus is on the front lines of the post-traumatic stress disorder churned up by this war - wants to know is whether the orders U.S. soldiers were given violated international law. And what the public needs to know is whether those orders turn the stomach.
Here are the voices of eyewitnesses:
"Something scatters across my hand, simultaneous with the crashing of a bullet through the ambulance, some plastic part dislodged, flying through the window," according to British anti-war activist Jo Wilding's account on rememberfallujah.org.
"We stop, turn off the siren, keep the blue light flashing, wait, eyes on the silhouettes of men in U.S. Marine uniforms on the corners of the buildings. Several shots come. We duck, get as low as possible and I can see tiny red lights whipping past the window, past my head. Some, it's hard to tell, are hitting the ambulance. . . . I'm outraged. We're trying to get to a woman who's giving birth without any medical attention, without electricity, in a city under siege, in a clearly marked ambulance, and you're shooting at us. How dare you?"
"A man named Khalil, who asked not to use his last name for fear of reprisals," wrote journalist Dahr Jamail, "said he had witnessed the shooting of civilians who were waving white flags while they tried to escape the city.
"'I watched them roll over wounded people in the street with tanks,' said Kassem Mohammed Ahmed, a resident of Fallujah. 'This happened so many times.'"
As far as I know, the civilian death toll from our two assaults on Fallujah in 2004 is unknown, but is well into the thousands. Journalist Sgrena wrote at the time that one problem with identifying the dead was that "many of the bodies were unrecognizable because they were so carbonized that the use of napalm was suspected." (The use of several napalm-like substances, including white phosphorous, was eventually confirmed.)
Sgrena was kidnapped by insurgents in early 2005 but released unharmed. However, as she, her driver and Italian intelligence agent Nicola Calipari drove slowly past a U.S. checkpoint following her release, U.S. soldiers opened fire, killing agent Calipari and wounding the others. There was an investigation, which concluded, inscrutably, that the shooting was justified.
Why was this shooting justified? What were the rules of engagement? Are journalists armed with independent pens considered legitimate targets? If such information is classified, it's only because the decision makers know how wrong they are and fear the wrath of a betrayed nation.
---
Robert Koehler, an award-winning, Chicago-based journalist, is an editor at Tribune Media Services and nationally syndicated writer. You can respond to this column at bkoehler@tribune.com or visit his Web site at commonwonders.com.
© 2006 Tribune Media Services, Inc.
|
 |
Recent War Articles
Rules of engagement December 16, 2006 Robert C. Koehler
If they vote for war, occupy 'em! December 15, 2006 Mike Ferner
The Baker Boys: stay half the course. Iraq Study Group or Saudi Protection League? December 8, 2006 Greg Palast
Permanent bases and temporary presidents December 8, 2006 David Swanson
Found: Saddam's weapon of mass destruction December 6, 2006 Greg Palast
Honesty in Iraq December 6, 2006 David Swanson
Malachi burns himself alive for peace: More links November 19, 2006 Mari Jo Muser
To the victors belongs impunity: of incorrigible transgressors, tacit complicity, and Lady Justice’s conspicuous absence November 15, 2006 Jason Miller
The plan Bush is looking for November 5, 2006 David Swanson
Oneonta November 1, 2006 David Swanson
Rumsfeld and Saddam: partners in crimes against humanity October 26, 2006 David Swanson
A few corpses past 'whatever' October 19, 2006 Robert C. Koehler
Breaking the silence of the night October 19, 2006 Ron Kovic
Let humanity's mutiny begin! August 14, 2006 Mike Ferner
So Osama walks into this bar, see? August 14, 2006 Greg Palast
AWOL Sergeant to turn himself in today resisting illegal Iraq war August 11, 2006 David Swanson
The best thing in the world for big oil August 4, 2006 Bobby Kennedy and Palast
Pentagon calling up military reservists who are ill July 16, 2006 Gene C. Gerard
Wounded to the soul July 16, 2006 Robert C. Koehler
Class action for wounded Iraq war veterans and family members July 8, 2006 nowaybush.info
Command rape July 7, 2006 David Swanson
Hadji girl July 5, 2006 Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
First commissioned officer to refuse deployment to unlawful Iraq war officially charged by U.S. Army July 5, 2006 Friends and family of Lt. Ehren Watada
Despite it being the worst military blunder in U.S history, the GOP sees Iraq war as campaign opportunity. Am I missing something? June 26, 2006 The Ostroy Report
Rove outlines Busheviks' Iraq strategy to win midterms: lie again about Dems being weak on terrorism June 14, 2006 The Ostroy Report
Unreported: The Zarqawi invitation June 11, 2006 Greg Palast
Let's stay in Iraq until it's peaceful or we're sane, whichever comes first June 6, 2006 David Swanson
More -- lots more June 6, 2006 Mike Ferner
Why the ‘War Resisters Support Campaign’ in Canada is important to the U.S. anti-war movement June 6, 2006 Virginia Rodino
Corporate Media symptom number 13: Play along, get along. June 6, 2006 Tim Copeland
Gold Star mother urges Americans to sign the voters pledge no more pro-war candidates, no more wars of choice May 27, 2006 Tia Steele
43,000 reasons not to attack Iran May 25, 2006 David Swanson
Cindy Sheehan's new book: Dear President Bush May 15, 2006 David Swanson
Atheists for Peace May 7, 2006 David Swanson
Lobbying Hitler's legislature for peace May 5, 2006 David Swanson
The war looks different from inside Congress April 27, 2006 David Swanson
Congressional hearing on Iraq planned April 25, 2006 David Swanson
State Department memo: '16 Words' were false April 19, 2006 Jason Leopold
America’s "noble" cause: preserving its right to murder, exploit, torture, and impoverish with impunity April 10, 2006 Jason Miller
Bush's "New Kind of Democracy" for Iraq March 30, 2006 The Ostroy Report
Justice -- not war -- in the Philippines protests Iraq war at military recruitment center March 24, 2006 Network in Solidarity with the People of the Philippines
Columbus, Ohio March 18th protest footage March 21, 2006 Columbus IMC
Homeland dreamland March 17, 2006 David Swanson
War protesters gather for anniversary March 16, 2006 Jessica Kitchin
Antiwar activists arrested at House Appropriations Committee meeting March 10, 2006 Mike Ferner and Jeff Leys
Three years on March 6, 2006 Tom Huffman
Get this: U.S. troops believe in Bush's Iraq fiasco as much as Cindy Sheehan March 1, 2006 The Ostroy Report
Torture, and a little matter of genocide March 1, 2006 Jason Miller
Death in U.S. custody February 26, 2006 William Fisher
There are lives in the balance February 24, 2006 Mike Ferner
Winter of our discontent: 34-day fast February 15 to March 20 at U.S. Capitol to end the Iraq war February 14, 2006 Mike Ferner
How you -- yes you -- can end the war February 14, 2006 David Swanson
Hole in the future February 3, 2006 Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
Phony UN airplanes to provoke war February 2, 2006 David Swanson
Prosecutor probing Niger forgeries, possible conspiracy in CIA leak January 28, 2006 Jason Leopold
Today in Iraq for perspective, commentary and news January 10, 2006 Kevin Zeese
Active-duty military support for Bush and the Iraq war dropping January 6, 2006 Kevin B. Zeese
Greed and gall: asking Iraq to pay for its occupation January 4, 2006 David Swanson
Top ten anti-war news stories of 2005 and the underreported stories of the year January 2, 2006 Kevin Zeese
Read War Articles by Year: 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |