Departments
Sen. Clinton wants troops in Iraq for at least 10 years
by David Swanson
June 13, 2007
On Monday, Ted Koppel offered a report / commentary on National Public Radio's "All Things Considered" which can be found online ( http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=10947954 ) with this headline: "A Duty to Mislead: Politics and the Iraq War," and this introductory text: "Democrats are telling voters that if they are elected, all U.S. troops will be pulled out of Iraq. But as Sen. Hillary Clinton privately told a senor military adviser, she knows there will be some troops there for decades. It's an example of how in some cases, politics can force dishonesty."
Well, someone is trying to force dishonesty. I'm not sure it's politics.
In the audio report, Koppel points out that in a recent debate Senator Hillary Clinton said that her first priority if elected would be to "bring our troops home." She did not say ALL our troops, Koppel points out, and she does not mean ALL our troops. She told the New York Times three months ago that some forces would have to remain. And Koppel adds that he spoke with someone from the Pentagon who briefs Clinton, and that she had told this person that if she is elected and reelected, she expects to have troops in Iraq at the end of her second term. Koppel notes that that's 10 years away. He adds that he thinks she's "right" and that the other Democratic candidates agree with her. When, oh when, he laments, will we get the truth instead of applause lines.
But let's back up a minute here. The question of how long U.S. troops remain in Iraq is not an immutable fact for Clinton and Koppel to get right, as scientists observing the natural world. It's a question to be determined by either the U.S. Congress or the U.S. President or both. Koppel, in fact, has no say in the matter, and I for one am profoundly uninterested in his opinion. Clinton's opinion, on the other hand, is of the highest importance. Koppel is to be applauded for exposing it to the light of day.
Koppel, it appears, however, did not learn his lesson in 2003 at that New Hampshire debate where Congressman Dennis Kucinich received such thunderous applause for taking Koppel to task. Koppel does not have the right to determine which candidates are "real" candidates or to put words in their mouths. Neither Kucinich nor former Senator Mike Gravel intends, if elected, to keep troops in Iraq for a year, much less a decade. In fact, these candidates are trying their hardest to fully end the occupation of Iraq prior to 2008. My distinct impression is that Republican candidate Ron Paul shares this position.
Some of the other Democratic candidates, as well, may not share the Clinton-Koppel position in favor of a decade or more of occupation. In fact, that may be exactly why Koppel has exposed Clinton's position and described it not as a position at all, but as an observation of facts that any serious candidate would recognize. The corporate media may be concerned that some of the other Democrats whom Disney (ABC) considers viable do not share Clinton's position. He is instructing them on what position to take if they want to be in the center of the stage and treated respectfully by the media.
Something is, indeed, trying to force dishonesty.
Each candidate needs to be asked, and the answer reported: Will they work now for the complete withdrawal of all troops, mercenaries, and contractors?
In fact, there are a lot of questions they should be asked: http://davidswanson.org/node/816
|
 |
Recent War Articles
Pentagon cover up: 15,000 or more US deaths in Iraq war? December 17, 2007 Mike Whitney
Iraq's million December 6, 2007 Robert C. Koehler
Talking with two who walk the walk November 29, 2007 David Swanson
Baghdad in middle America November 15, 2007 Robert C. Koehler
Understanding the next war money vote November 10, 2007 David Swanson
Jonesborough justice October 31, 2007 David Swanson
Ann Wright’s conscience: former colonel and diplomat against Iraq war October 29, 2007 Seth Sandronsky
Open letter to the government from an AWOL soldier October 21, 2007 James Circello, Iraq Veterans Against The War
Constitution, flag, and leaving Iraq October 7, 2007 David Swanson
Whistleblowers on tape September 30, 2007 David Swanson
Observing our government through Blackwater September 26, 2007 David Swanson
"Funding the war is killing the troops": interrupting the empire 30 seconds at a time September 26, 2007 Mike Ferner
We have nothing but fear itself September 24, 2007 David Swanson
Sanity in tiny nibbles September 21, 2007 Robert C. Koehler
Can we talk? Day one of IVAW's "Truth in Recruiting" campaign September 20, 2007 Mike Ferner
New day in the anti-war movement? September 19, 2007 Mike Ferner
Bush’s fake sheik whacked: the Surge and the Al Qaeda bunny September 18, 2007 Greg Palast
Iraq: the people's report September 11, 2007 Sue Udry
Questions for General Petraeus September 10, 2007 David Swanson
My son, back from Iraq, lives on tower on National Mall September 1, 2007 Mary Hanna
Creative destruction August 16, 2007 Robert C. Koehler
300 towns, cities, states oppose Iraq occupation August 1, 2007 David Swanson
Reparations July 30, 2007 David Swanson
Democrats as Leviathan: another step toward war with Iran July 23, 2007 Joshua Frank
We will sit in for impeachment July 5, 2007 David Swanson
Gorilla suit July 3, 2007 Robert C. Koehler
Peace movement comes to US Social Forum June 29, 2007 David Swanson
The hearts of all sane men June 21, 2007 Robert C. Koehler
Belief and doubt June 15, 2007 Robert C. Koehler
Sen. Clinton wants troops in Iraq for at least 10 years June 13, 2007 David Swanson
This is not a story about Cindy Sheehan June 5, 2007 Sunsara Taylor
The holy occupation of Iraq May 29, 2007 David Swanson
Why I voted "no" May 27, 2007 Sen. Barbara Boxer
For five years we've called it blood for oil May 16, 2007 David Swanson
Collateral genocide May 12, 2007 Mike Ferner
Please don’t throw me in that veto patch May 7, 2007 Mike Ferner
Anti-U.S. uproar sweeps Italy May 5, 2007 David Swanson
Knee-deep blood in the land of make-believe April 26, 2007 Carla Binion
Tax day protests and refusing to pay for war April 16, 2007 Ruth Benn
You can't hurt a troop by defunding a war April 12, 2007 David Swanson
Iraq veterans speak in Columbus, OH 3-17-07 April 11, 2007 Veterans
Iraq @ 4: It's Not About the Troops - Either Way March 26, 2007 David Caploe
Progressives stand strong against funding war March 23, 2007 David Swanson
No mo money for war March 16, 2007 David Swanson
Sacrificing our children on the altar of corporate greed March 15, 2007 David E. Washburn
Only nonviolence will end the war March 14, 2007 David Swanson
The war money can be stopped March 10, 2007 David Swanson
How will you end this war? March 10, 2007 Tina Richards
Congressman Obey says "Idiot Liberals" need to support war money March 9, 2007 David Swanson
Former Pentagon staff speaks out on crimes of Doug Feith, Dick Cheney, and planning of Iran War March 6, 2007 David Swanson
I'm more pro-troop than you are March 3, 2007 David Swanson
Only nonviolence will end the war February 28, 2007 David Swanson
Cindy Sheehan, George Will, and loving your enemies February 26, 2007 David Swanson
No, seriously, why did we invade Iraq? February 22, 2007 David E. Washburn
Lord knows we've suffered enough already: keep them out of Ohio! February 18, 2007 Mike Ferner
Murtha only intends to undo the escalation February 17, 2007 David Swanson
Shut up and stop the war February 14, 2007 David Swanson
100 Senators quietly vote: majority oppose escalation February 10, 2007 David Swanson
Dems change the gas and claim it's a new car February 9, 2007 David Swanson
A world that works for everybody February 7, 2007 Robert C. Koehler
D.C. demonstration January 30, 2007 John Conyers, Jr.
How we can end the occupation of Iraq January 23, 2007 David Swanson
Dear Mr. President: Send Even MORE Troops (and you go, too!) ...from Michael Moore January 22, 2007 Michael Moore
The Kucinich Plan for Iraq January 17, 2007 Dennis J. Kucinich
An Iraq jobs program? January 16, 2007 Seth Sandronsky
Waist deep in the big muddy January 12, 2007 Greg Palast
Out of Iraq and back to the American city January 11, 2007 Dennis J. Kucinich
If not now, when? January 10, 2007 Mike Ferner
Mr. President, surge this January 10, 2007 David Swanson
3,000 lights delivered to Rep. Marcy Kaptur January 5, 2007 Northwest Ohio Peace Coalition
3,000 lights for 3,000 killed in Iraq January 1, 2007 Peggy Daly-Masternak
Read War Articles by Year: 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |