The Free Press: Speaking Truth to Power Fri Dec 05 2008
Departments
War in Iraq

Reparations
by David Swanson
July 30, 2007

When a Member of Congress wants to push an agenda forward, even one supported by very few other Congress Members, he or she will introduce or sign onto a bill and urge others to do the same.  Almost every Congress Member is willing to do this sort of thing, often on very controversial issues.  But when a Member of Congress wants to oppose an agenda without explaining why, he or she will tell you "I can't sign onto that because we don't have the votes."  In addition to the inconsistency, another problem with this excuse is that there are many examples of Congress finding the necessary votes as a result of a small group of Congress Members pushing an agenda forward.

"In January of 1989," Congressman John Conyers writes on his website, "I first introduced the bill H.R. 40, Commission to Study Reparation Proposals for African Americans Act. I have re-introduced HR 40 every Congress since 1989, and will continue to do so until it's passed into law."  This is the appropriate position and behavior for Conyers or any other Congress Member to take on this or any other important matter of social justice.  One day, Conyers and others may succeed.  And by putting their names on a bill, they make clear to citizens which other congress members are failing to take the same position.

On the question of impeaching Vice President Dick Cheney, however, Conyers takes a very different tack.  He has published a book documenting the crimes of Cheney and Bush, but when it comes to supporting a bill, Conyers offers the "we don't have the votes" excuse.

This would be aggravating enough on its own.  The aggravation is added to when some badly confused individuals denounce those lobbying Conyers on this issue (or at least those doing so who are white) precisely on the grounds that Conyers supports reparations for slavery.  Of course he does!  Conyers supports single-payer health care.  Conyers supports the right to organize a union.  Conyers supports all sorts of good things.  But none of those things qualify him to take the wrong position on impeachment and not be criticized or protested for it.

Of those who protested Conyers at his office last week, most if not every single individual – including the white ones – support reparations for slavery.  I've publicly supported and written about that project for years.  For years I had a big link on my website to an activist campaign for reparations.  In January 2005, I wrote an obituary for James Forman [ http://davidswanson.org/node/242 ] in which I said:

"In 1969 he carried impoliteness so far as to disrupt a service at Riverside Church in New York to demand that white churches pay $500 million in reparations to African-Americans. If the movement for reparations ever succeeds, Forman may be honored as one of its pioneers. Until then, he's known - where he's known at all - as someone who pushed for a change that has not yet come (and must therefore be ridiculed or attacked). We forget how many things he pushed for that are now taken for granted."

My point was not just that efforts like those made by John Conyers year after year may someday cease to be mocked and instead be honored.  The larger point I was making was that Forman was willing to challenge even his allies when they were wrong, and to do so in ways that were deemed impolite and inappropriate.  Why go to a liberal bunch of pro-integration church-goers, some of whom were no doubt funding and participating in important work, and disrupt their religious service to propose a project for which everyone knew we did not "have the votes"?  The answer, of course, is that justice is more important than decorum, damaged lives more significant than hurt feelings. 

In April 2007 I gave a speech in Portland, Maine, [ http://davidswanson.org/node/803 ] in which I said: "I spoke earlier today … at Faneuil Hall, where men like Wendell Phillips led a movement to abolish slavery, something the wise and knowing of that day said could not be done. Those abolitionists made their movement a fight for freedom of the press. And make no mistake: our struggle is the same."

The struggle for the impeachment of Cheney and Bush is not in opposition to the struggle for justice from slavery.  It is inspired and informed by the anti-slavery movement.  Reparations for the horrors of slavery must come, no matter how many years later. 

So too, must reparation for the crimes of today.  We have killed nearly a million Iraqis, driven another 2 million from their homes, and caused yet another 2 million to flee their country all together.  We have severely damaged the lives of every resident of that nation.  At the same time, we have abandoned the people of New Orleans, many to their deaths.  And, worldwide, our nation's policies are leading the exacerbation of global warming, resulting already in hundreds of thousands of deaths. 

  The time for reparations for today's crimes will come.  Those crimes include the use of slave labor in the construction of the US embassy in Baghdad.  Now is the time to end those crimes, to put a stop to the suffering they are causing.   

There is an urgent moral demand to put a halt to the destruction.  Then the cleanup can begin.  And it must include the establishment of new standards for future behavior, a whole new direction for our nation based on setting right our past abuses.  The abuses we set straight must include the slaughter of the Native Americans, and must above all include slavery.


Email this article to a friend




1240 Bryden Road Columbus, Ohio 43209 Ph/Fx 614.253.2571 Email truth@freepress.org
  

Don't forget to check out articles from 2007 and 2008

War in Iraq

"Pentagon cover up: 15,000 or more US deaths in Iraq war?"
  December 17, 2007
  Mike Whitney

"Iraq's million"
  December 6, 2007
  Robert C. Koehler

"Talking with two who walk the walk"
  November 29, 2007
  David Swanson

"Baghdad in middle America"
  November 15, 2007
  Robert C. Koehler

"Understanding the next war money vote"
  November 10, 2007
  David Swanson

"Jonesborough justice"
  October 31, 2007
  David Swanson

"Ann Wright’s conscience: former colonel and diplomat against Iraq war"
  October 29, 2007
  Seth Sandronsky

"Open letter to the government from an AWOL soldier"
  October 21, 2007
  James Circello, Iraq Veterans Against The War

"Constitution, flag, and leaving Iraq"
  October 7, 2007
  David Swanson

"Whistleblowers on tape"
  September 30, 2007
  David Swanson

"Observing our government through Blackwater"
  September 26, 2007
  David Swanson

""Funding the war is killing the troops": interrupting the empire 30 seconds at a time"
  September 26, 2007
  Mike Ferner

"We have nothing but fear itself"
  September 24, 2007
  David Swanson

"Sanity in tiny nibbles"
  September 21, 2007
  Robert C. Koehler

"Can we talk? Day one of IVAW's "Truth in Recruiting" campaign"
  September 20, 2007
  Mike Ferner

"New day in the anti-war movement?"
  September 19, 2007
  Mike Ferner

"Bush’s fake sheik whacked: the Surge and the Al Qaeda bunny"
  September 18, 2007
  Greg Palast

"Iraq: the people's report"
  September 11, 2007
  Sue Udry

"Questions for General Petraeus"
  September 10, 2007
  David Swanson

"My son, back from Iraq, lives on tower on National Mall"
  September 1, 2007
  Mary Hanna

"Creative destruction"
  August 16, 2007
  Robert C. Koehler

"300 towns, cities, states oppose Iraq occupation"
  August 1, 2007
  David Swanson

"Reparations"
  July 30, 2007
  David Swanson

"Democrats as Leviathan: another step toward war with Iran"
  July 23, 2007
  Joshua Frank

"We will sit in for impeachment"
  July 5, 2007
  David Swanson

"Gorilla suit"
  July 3, 2007
  Robert C. Koehler

"Peace movement comes to US Social Forum"
  June 29, 2007
  David Swanson

"The hearts of all sane men"
  June 21, 2007
  Robert C. Koehler

"Belief and doubt"
  June 15, 2007
  Robert C. Koehler

"Sen. Clinton wants troops in Iraq for at least 10 years"
  June 13, 2007
  David Swanson

"This is not a story about Cindy Sheehan"
  June 5, 2007
  Sunsara Taylor

"The holy occupation of Iraq"
  May 29, 2007
  David Swanson

"Why I voted "no""
  May 27, 2007
  Sen. Barbara Boxer

"For five years we've called it blood for oil"
  May 16, 2007
  David Swanson

"Collateral genocide"
  May 12, 2007
  Mike Ferner

"Please don’t throw me in that veto patch"
  May 7, 2007
  Mike Ferner

"Anti-U.S. uproar sweeps Italy"
  May 5, 2007
  David Swanson

"Knee-deep blood in the land of make-believe"
  April 26, 2007
  Carla Binion

"Tax day protests and refusing to pay for war"
  April 16, 2007
  Ruth Benn

"You can't hurt a troop by defunding a war"
  April 12, 2007
  David Swanson

"Iraq veterans speak in Columbus, OH 3-17-07"
  April 11, 2007
  Veterans

"Iraq @ 4: It's Not About the Troops - Either Way "
  March 26, 2007
  David Caploe

"Progressives stand strong against funding war"
  March 23, 2007
  David Swanson

"No mo money for war"
  March 16, 2007
  David Swanson

"Sacrificing our children on the altar of corporate greed"
  March 15, 2007
  David E. Washburn

"Only nonviolence will end the war"
  March 14, 2007
  David Swanson

"The war money can be stopped"
  March 10, 2007
  David Swanson

"How will you end this war?"
  March 10, 2007
  Tina Richards

"Congressman Obey says "Idiot Liberals" need to support war money"
  March 9, 2007
  David Swanson

"Former Pentagon staff speaks out on crimes of Doug Feith, Dick Cheney, and planning of Iran War"
  March 6, 2007
  David Swanson

"I'm more pro-troop than you are"
  March 3, 2007
  David Swanson

"Only nonviolence will end the war"
  February 28, 2007
  David Swanson

"Cindy Sheehan, George Will, and loving your enemies"
  February 26, 2007
  David Swanson

"No, seriously, why did we invade Iraq?"
  February 22, 2007
  David E. Washburn

"Lord knows we've suffered enough already: keep them out of Ohio!"
  February 18, 2007
  Mike Ferner

"Murtha only intends to undo the escalation"
  February 17, 2007
  David Swanson

"Shut up and stop the war"
  February 14, 2007
  David Swanson

"100 Senators quietly vote: majority oppose escalation"
  February 10, 2007
  David Swanson

"Dems change the gas and claim it's a new car"
  February 9, 2007
  David Swanson

"A world that works for everybody"
  February 7, 2007
  Robert C. Koehler

"D.C. demonstration"
  January 30, 2007
  John Conyers, Jr.

"How we can end the occupation of Iraq"
  January 23, 2007
  David Swanson

"Dear Mr. President: Send Even MORE Troops (and you go, too!) ...from Michael Moore"
  January 22, 2007
  Michael Moore

"The Kucinich Plan for Iraq"
  January 17, 2007
  Dennis J. Kucinich

"An Iraq jobs program?"
  January 16, 2007
  Seth Sandronsky

"Waist deep in the big muddy"
  January 12, 2007
  Greg Palast

"Out of Iraq and back to the American city"
  January 11, 2007
  Dennis J. Kucinich

"If not now, when?"
  January 10, 2007
  Mike Ferner

"Mr. President, surge this"
  January 10, 2007
  David Swanson

"3,000 lights delivered to Rep. Marcy Kaptur"
  January 5, 2007
  Northwest Ohio Peace Coalition

"3,000 lights for 3,000 killed in Iraq"
  January 1, 2007
  Peggy Daly-Masternak




Read Articles by Year:
2007 2006 2005 2004
2003 2002 2001 2000




All content © 1970-2008
The Columbus Free Press
Disclaimer