Departments
Cost of war is budgetary "Elephant in the Room"
by John Marty, State Senator and DFL Candidate for Governor of Minnesota
March 4, 2010
In challenging times like ours, it is important to step back and look at
the big picture. In the Senate we wrestle with painful choices to
balance the state budget. Some factors affecting the budget are outside
of our control, some we can control, and others fall somewhere
in-between. While most legislative work addresses things we have direct
control over, we should at least understand other factors influencing
the resources available.
The cost of the Iraq and Afghan wars is the budgetary "elephant in the
room." It's enormous and it's right in front of us, yet we don't talk
about it as we face our economic woes. We don't need to get into
arguments about the wars to consider the burden war places on our economy.
President Dwight Eisenhower, one of our nation's greatest military
leaders, late in life, expressed deep concern about what he called "the
military industrial complex." Eisenhower stated, "Every gun that is
made, every warship launched, every rocket fired, signifies in the final
sense a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold
and are not clothed."
During World War II, people were told that the war would require blood,
toil, tears, and sweat -- real sacrifice, not just for soldiers
overseas, but also for the people back home.
In contrast, for the current Iraq and Afghan wars, people were told they
wouldn't have to sacrifice at all; taxes would be cut, not raised.
President Bush told people after 9/11 that the patriotic thing to do was
to "go shopping." Perhaps that was due to delusional ideology, or
perhaps it was a trigger-happy leader who recognized that if people
understood the true cost, the war would be unjustifiable.
What this means for Minnesota's economy is clear. In addition to the
incredible sacrifices made by so many military families, Minnesota's
share of the cost of the wars now exceeds $5 billion for every two-year
state budget cycle. Think of the investments that could be made in our
communities if the federal government invested that money in the states
instead of in the war. We could have avoided the layoffs of teachers and
police and firefighters and health care workers. Think of the
investments in living wage jobs, the investments in nursing homes for
seniors, the investments in early childhood and helping at-risk kids
succeed, the investments in public infrastructure.
Minnesotans working to build a better future face growing setbacks:
Young people on the "six year plan" to get a two year college degree
because they work two jobs to pay tuition. Parents struggle to find a
safe place for their young kids during the workday because of cuts in
sliding-fee child care. Employers unable to hire older workers because
their pre-existing conditions would send the employer's insurance
premiums through the roof. People with disabilities face shrinking state
programs that once covered them.
Those setbacks occur because states are unable to help people get a fair
shake due to budget problems. It is time to press Washington to change
its priorities away from war and into facing human needs in our communities.
The military budgets of all other nations of the world combined, barely
exceeds the $693 billion the U.S. will spend on the military this year.
And the $693 billion doesn't include the $42 billion for Homeland
Security, nor the undisclosed budget for the National Intelligence Program.
Based on population, Minnesota's share of total military spending,
including the two wars, is almost $12 billion every year. That's
two-thirds as large as our entire state general fund budget of roughly
$17 billion/year. Imagine what we could accomplish if we cut our
military spending by half. The savings would balance the state budget
and make huge investments in education and community development.
President Eisenhower said, "I hate war, as only a soldier who has lived
it can, as one who has seen its brutality, its futility, its stupidity."
He was clear in his message: "This world in arms is not spending money
alone. It is spending the sweat of its laborers, the genius of its
scientists, the hope of its children."
Sixty years later, we can see that the endless war has a real cost here
at home. For the first time in our history, we are losing ground: High
school students today have a lower graduation rate than their parents'
generation. Fewer young adults have access to health care than their
parents have. Today's workers will be less likely to have a decent
pension than their parents enjoy. Eisenhower warned us. In spending
money on war, we are truly taking away the hope of our children.
If we care about our future, ignoring the economic cost of war is just
as foolish as ignoring the human cost.
___________________________________________________________________________
Senator John Marty is a Democratic Candidate for Governor in Minnesota.
Please visit his website at
John Marty
After Downing Street
|
 |
Recent War Articles
Believe in violence and be saved December 24, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Be the peace you want to see on Earth December 24, 2010 David Swanson
Whitewashing defeat: Obama's indecisiveness defines his presidency December 22, 2010 Ramzy Baroud
Pearl Harbor: A successful war lie December 8, 2010 David Swanson
A hollow bomber jacket December 6, 2010 Norman Solomon
WikiLeaks: Demystifying “Diplomacy” November 29, 2010 Norman Solomon
"Die for a Tie" -- How the Korean War began November 26, 2010 David Swanson
U.S. wars are bankrupting the world November 20, 2010 David Swanson
Peddling war to children November 18, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Open letter to Congress on Veteran's Day 2010 November 11, 2010 United for Peace and Justice Afghanistan Working Group
One place to cut spending: Kidnapping and torture November 8, 2010 David Swanson
Deaths revealed by Wikileaks are tip of an iceberg October 24, 2010 Nicolas Davies
Creating a new courage October 24, 2010 Jerica Arents
Then they came for me October 18, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Poll: Most Americans Don't Want War with Iran October 13, 2010 Monique Coppola, Public News Service - VA
The criminality of nuclear deterrence today: International law as anchoring ground October 7, 2010 Professor Francis A. Boyle
The Nazi virus October 7, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Farewell to arms: Jenny, Iraq and the next war October 6, 2010 Ramzy Baroud
Drone warfare on trial October 2, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Petrodollar warfare: Dollars, euros and the upcoming Iranian oil bourse October 2, 2010 by William R. Clark (Friday August 05 2005)
The book the Pentagon burned October 2, 2010 David Swanson
U.S. Vietnam Veteran returns to his war October 2, 2010 Richard S. Ehrlich
Obama-Men: Innocents Abroad; Politicos at Home October 1, 2010 Ray McGovern
Inspector General criticism doesn't faze FBI raids on midwestern anti-war activists September 26, 2010 Coleen Rowley, War Is A Crime.org
The war is lost: Another perspective on the Afghanistan war September 23, 2010 Frank Brodhead
Holy war September 19, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
The indefensible drones: A ground zero reflection September 11, 2010 Kathy Kelly, WarIsACrime.org
Implications of a pointless war September 10, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
A speech for endless war September 2, 2010 Norman Solomon
Let's fact check the AP's fact checking on Obama's speech September 2, 2010 David Swanson
Veterans for Peace President Mike Ferner responds to President Obama's rebranded occupation of Iraq August 31, 2010 Mike Ferner
Peace movement pushes for end to war on Iraq August 30, 2010 David Swanson
Blackwater vs. Pinkwater: The wife of Erik Prince picks a fight with CODEPINK August 25, 2010 Medea Benjamin
Last of the combat troops leaving Iraq? – Only in your dreams August 21, 2010 Bill Noxid
Gen. Petraeus goes to media war August 16, 2010 Norman Solomon
The next war August 5, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
State of denial: After the big Leak, spinning for war July 27, 2010 Norman Solomon
The crematorium of empires July 18, 2010 David Swanson, War Is A Crime.org
The war drones on July 8, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
The peace movement's progress July 5, 2010 David Swanson
Unanimous conformity in the Senate July 1, 2010 Norman Solomon
Senator Carl Levin Fiddling With War While Detroit Burns June 30, 2010 Medea Benjamin, WarIsACrime.org
Obama Misses the Afghan Exit Ramp June 25, 2010 Ray McGovern
From great man to great screwup: Behind the McChrystal uproar June 24, 2010 Norman Solomon
Obama and Insubordination: Is He Truman or Mr. Milquetoast? June 24, 2010 Ray McGovern
The wonders of the American way of war June 1, 2010 David Swanson
The one thing we can agree on is peace May 27, 2010 David Swanson
Stopping Orwell's nightmare May 27, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Fear, war, greed, disaster, and journalism May 25, 2010 David Swanson, WarIsACrime.org
The learning curve of peace May 21, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Karazai’s Washington visit: the war awaiting Kandahar May 20, 2010 Ramzy Baroud
McChrystal: Beheadings of our allies simply to be expected May 16, 2010 David Swanson
Obama scraps Iraq withdrawal May 13, 2010 David Swanson
Dear Fiscal Conservative War Supporter May 5, 2010 David Swanson
Ending wars: The Flexible waiverable timetable approach April 21, 2010 David Swanson
I won't vote for you if you vote to escalate war April 21, 2010 David Swanson
You say you want a revolution... April 2, 2010 Tom Over
Globalization and the US wars in Afghanistan and Iraq March 31, 2010 Tom Over
The world still can't wait, says activist against US wars in Afghanistan and Iraq March 30, 2010 Tom Over
Reflections on an anniversary March 26, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Antiwar activity sees surge for 7th anniversary of Iraq War invasion March 20, 2010 PJEP
Rachel Corrie: Justice delayed is justice denied March 16, 2010 Mahmoud El-Yousseph
War in a box March 11, 2010 Norman Solomon
Cost of war is budgetary "Elephant in the Room" March 4, 2010 John Marty, State Senator and DFL Candidate for Governor of Minnesota
War politics: numb and number February 27, 2010 Norman Solomon
Blocking war funding just got easier February 2, 2010 David Swanson
Don't call it a February 2, 2010 Norman Solomon
Read War Articles by Year: 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |