DEPARTMENTS
ANTI-WAR
DEATH PENALTY
ELECTIONS
ENVIRONMENT
GLBT ISSUES
HEMP
INTERNATIONAL
NATIONAL
REVIEWS
|
Departments War Obama scraps Iraq withdrawal What are we to think? That may be sad news, but what could we have done differently? Surely it would have been worse to elect a president who did not promise to withdraw, right? But there's a broader framework for this withdrawal or lack thereof, namely the SOFA (Status of Forces Agreement), the unconstitutional treaty that Bush and Maliki drew up without consulting the U.S. Senate. I was reminded of this on Tuesday when Obama and Karzai talked about a forthcoming document from the two of them and repeatedly expressed their eternal devotion to a long occupation. The unconstitutional Iraq treaty (UIT) requires complete withdrawal from Iraq by the end of next year, and withdrawal from all Iraqi cities, villages, and localities by last summer. Obama's latest announcement doesn't alter the lack of compliance with the latter requirement. Nor does it guarantee noncompliance with the former. But it illustrates something else, something that some of us have been screaming since the UIT was allowed to stand, something that pretty well guarantees that the US occupation of Iraq will never end. Imagine if Congress funded, defunded, oversaw, and regulated the military and wars as required by our Constitution. Imagine if the president COULDN'T simply tell Congress that troops would be staying in Iraq longer than planned, but had to ask for the necessary funding first. Here's the lesson for this teachable moment: Persuading presidents to end wars only looks good until they change their mind. Cutting off the funding actually forces wars to end. When the US peace movement refused to challenge the UIT, it left Bush's successor and his successors free to ignore it, revise it, or replace it. Congress has been removed from the equation. If Obama decides to inform Congress that the occupation of Iraq will go on into 2012, Congress' response will be as muted as when the Director of National Intelligence informed Congress that killing Americans was now legal. And what can Congress say? It had no role in ratifying the UIT in the first place. And the peace movement is in large part on the same path with Afghanistan, working to pass a toothless, non-binding timetable for possible redeployment of troops to another nation. Congress sees itself as advisors whose role it is to persuade the president that he wants to cease the activity that most advances presidential power. And activists share that perspective. But what happens if the president becomes unpersuaded about ending both of these wars? What in the world are we supposed to do then? We have an alternative to painting ourselves into this corner. The alternative is to build a movement of war opponents (and advocates for spending on human needs and/or tax cuts) that can pressure the House of Representatives to cut off the funding for the wars. Of course, this isn't easy. It's much harder than collecting signatures on a toothless resolution. And it's dramatically harder than watching the president create an unconstitutional treaty (something Bush was forced into primarily by the people of Iraq) and then stepping aside to celebrate. But there is no stronger message that could be used to persuade a president than a growing caucus of congress members denying him the money. And once a majority is reached in the caucus of war defunders, then the war simply has to end, whether the president is persuaded of anything or not. So, the lesson to be learned from Obama scrapping his current plan for an Iraq withdrawal is not that we should phone the White House and complain. It's not that we need 20 more cosponsors of the nonbinding timetable for Afghanistan. The lesson is that we must tell members of the House of Representatives that they can vote against war funding or we will vote against them. Not a new lesson, I realize, but the Constitution is always less read than talked about. -- David Swanson is the author of the new book Daybreak: Undoing the Imperial Presidency and Forming a More Perfect Union by Seven Stories Press. You can order it and find out when tour will be in your town: David Swanson Book |
|
Believe in violence and be saved Be the peace you want to see on Earth Whitewashing defeat: Obama's indecisiveness defines his presidency Pearl Harbor: A successful war lie A hollow bomber jacket WikiLeaks: Demystifying “Diplomacy” "Die for a Tie" -- How the Korean War began U.S. wars are bankrupting the world Peddling war to children Open letter to Congress on Veteran's Day 2010 One place to cut spending: Kidnapping and torture Deaths revealed by Wikileaks are tip of an iceberg Creating a new courage Then they came for me Poll: Most Americans Don't Want War with Iran The criminality of nuclear deterrence today: International law as anchoring ground The Nazi virus Farewell to arms: Jenny, Iraq and the next war Drone warfare on trial Petrodollar warfare: Dollars, euros and the upcoming Iranian oil bourse The book the Pentagon burned U.S. Vietnam Veteran returns to his war Obama-Men: Innocents Abroad; Politicos at Home Inspector General criticism doesn't faze FBI raids on midwestern anti-war activists The war is lost: Another perspective on the Afghanistan war Holy war The indefensible drones: A ground zero reflection Implications of a pointless war A speech for endless war Let's fact check the AP's fact checking on Obama's speech Veterans for Peace President Mike Ferner responds to President Obama's rebranded occupation of Iraq Peace movement pushes for end to war on Iraq Blackwater vs. Pinkwater: The wife of Erik Prince picks a fight with CODEPINK Last of the combat troops leaving Iraq? – Only in your dreams Gen. Petraeus goes to media war The next war State of denial: After the big Leak, spinning for war The crematorium of empires The war drones on The peace movement's progress Unanimous conformity in the Senate Senator Carl Levin Fiddling With War While Detroit Burns Obama Misses the Afghan Exit Ramp From great man to great screwup: Behind the McChrystal uproar Obama and Insubordination: Is He Truman or Mr. Milquetoast? The wonders of the American way of war The one thing we can agree on is peace Stopping Orwell's nightmare Fear, war, greed, disaster, and journalism The learning curve of peace Karazai’s Washington visit: the war awaiting Kandahar McChrystal: Beheadings of our allies simply to be expected Obama scraps Iraq withdrawal Dear Fiscal Conservative War Supporter Ending wars: The Flexible waiverable timetable approach I won't vote for you if you vote to escalate war You say you want a revolution... Globalization and the US wars in Afghanistan and Iraq The world still can't wait, says activist against US wars in Afghanistan and Iraq Reflections on an anniversary Antiwar activity sees surge for 7th anniversary of Iraq War invasion Rachel Corrie: Justice delayed is justice denied War in a box Cost of war is budgetary "Elephant in the Room" War politics: numb and number Blocking war funding just got easier Don't call it a Read War Articles by Year: |
FREE PRESS EMAIL UPDATE
Donate to the Free Press Election Protection Fund to help us investigate and monitor election fraud in this year's election.
FOLLOW US ON
twitter
facebook
SEARCH THE FREEPRESS
1021 E. Broad St. Columbus, OH 43205 | 614.253.2571 | truth@freepress.org
All content © 1970-2012 The Columbus Free Press
Disclaimer