Departments
On the OSU medical clinic article
by Margaret Nuovo
January 4, 2011
Dear Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman:
I read with interest your article titled: "Ohio State's medical industrial complex under fire for unnecessary surgeries".
As a woman retired MD who specialized in Gynecology and Anatomic Pathology, and who has worked at OSUMC, I have special insight into the situation.
According to the NOW letter to Dr. Gee published in the Dec issue of The Other Paper:
"In view of the fact that best practices calls for pathological analysis by an expert (experienced in gynecologic pathology) to properly determine Pap smear and cervical biopsy diagnosis and OSUMC is capable of providing that expertise in the person of Dr. Gerard Nuovo, there is no good reason for giving Ohio women second class medical treatment and care. And there is no good reason for dismissing an expert who brings shortcomings to the attention of authorities."
Dr Gabbe, the CEO of OSUMC, replies to this letter from NOW with the following statement:
"In order to ensure that excellent medical care is
provided by our Department of Pathology, we have assembled a highly respected and
skilled group of cytopathologists to perform pathology services including the
identification of potential cervical disease."
The standard way a Pathology Department defines a "highly respected and skilled group of pathologists" is by their peer reviewed publications in the medical literature, as well as years of specialized practice. A Pathologist becomes highly respected and skilled by typically publishing from 20 to 50 such articles. This is a very simple way for the readers to determine if the Pathologist who reviewed their slides is considered highly skilled.
If one looks at public record documents of the current Pathologists at OSUMC who diagnose women's cervical and endometrial pathology, NOT ONE of these Pathologists has even ONE peer reviewed publication in HPV, cervical or endometrial pathology, as shown by the attached MEDLINE search. In comparison, note that Dr. Gerard Nuovo has 77 peer review papers in the area of HPV disease. He has two textbooks, as well as over 100 peer review papers in the area of cervical and endometrial pathology.
This information may help your readers more clearly see that the NOW legal division has a very solid foundation to make the claims they did, and serves as a word of caution to any woman when faced with the prospect of surgery of her cervix or uterus under these conditions.
Margaret Nuovo, MD
|
 |
Recent Ohio Articles
Video by Occupy the Oval November 20, 2011 OSU students
Building on Defeating Issue 2 November 10, 2011 Robert A. Letcher, PhD
Columbus Coalition for Responsive Government to file initiative petition to revise Columbus City Charter November 7, 2011 Jonathan Beard
Hangin' with Glenn Beck so you don't have to: More Ohio Right to Life escapades November 5, 2011 Marley greiner
Study touts Social Security successes October 29, 2011 Bruce Bostick
Animal killing in Ohio highights need for regulations! October 25, 2011 Bruce Bostick
Created Equal: Condom course is an outrage to Ohio taxpayers! October 22, 2011 Marley Greiner
Occupy Columbus Update October 19, 2011 Connie Everett
Draconian Issue 3 would harm every Ohioan because of its intended and unintended consequences October 11, 2011 Albert A. Gabel
The death of Jerry Doyle October 10, 2011 Bob Fitrakis
Consider Columbus Occupied October 10, 2011 Occupycolumbus,org
Concerned citizens and faculty ask state to investigate mismanagement of Wilberforce University October 5, 2011 Tom Over
Ohioans say no to voter suppression October 5, 2011 Bruce Bostick
Ohio State University becoming less public? August 25, 2011 Tom Over
Trumka helps launch Ohio repeal campaign July 22, 2011 Bruce Bostick
Just ban them! (at least in Columbus) July 21, 2011 Connie Everett
AFL-CIO leaders Trumpka, Burga to kick off campaign to win poll fight on SB 5 July 18, 2011 Bruce Bostick
Indie journalists arrested in Greenfield last year return for accountability: Felony wiretapping among charges levied July 12, 2011 Ademo Freeman
Letter to the Editor - Heartbeat bill must not be passed July 1, 2011 Shira Nahari
MILLION OHIOANS SAY NO TO ANTI-LABOR BILL! June 30, 2011 Bruce Bostick
Push for a million Ohioans against SB5 June 25, 2011 Bruce Bostick (USW/SOAR)
Whirlpool steals workers' guaranteed health care June 19, 2011 Bruce Bostick (USW/SOAR)
Tax breaks for ‘Big Shots’ will cost middle class Ohioans, says lawmaker: State Rep. Sykes requests cost-impact analysis of Kasich’s new tax give-away June 19, 2011 Rep. Vernon Sykes office
Columbus City officials hypocritical about public access TV June 11, 2011 Joe Sommer
The Ohio Estate Tax should not be repealed June 2, 2011 Albert A. Gabel
Correction to the lead Columbus Dispatch editorial Sunday May 15, 2011 May 10, 2011 Albert A. Gabel, Professor Emeritus, Ohio State University
May 5 Statehouse rally stands up to Kasich's budget May 9, 2011 Bob Studzinski
Summary of Governor Kasich’s damaging efforts May 6, 2011 Albert A. Gabel, Professor Emeritus, Ohio State University
SB5 Petition Events Saturday April 23 April 22, 2011
Women in Central Ohio who had a Gynecologic biopsy at OSUMC need to send their biopsies to an outside Gyn Pathology expert April 18, 2011 Sally A
Demand that Ohio investigate torture allegations April 17, 2011 Free Press staff
Central Ohio fights back against Senate Bill 5 April 13, 2011 Bob Studzinski (photos)
Ohio GOP sends a stealth death notice to public college teachers unions April 2, 2011 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Ohio Fight Back Drive announces at Town Hall meeting April 1, 2011 Bruce Bostick
Republicans pass anti-worker bill: Labor coalition build fight for justice! March 30, 2011 Bruce Bostick (USW/SOAR)
Photos from SB5 protest at Kasich's house in Westervile March 16, 2011 Free Press staff
Workers present their “State of the State” at huge protest March 13, 2011 Bruce Bostick
Corporate union busters draw first blood in Ohio March 3, 2011 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Huge labor rally at the Ohio Statehouse March 2, 2011 Democracy Now
Rev. Jesse Jackson in Columbus March 2, 2011 Jack Burgess
Little Egypt at the Statehouse February 20, 2011 Jack Burgess
Ohio workers flood capital--Demand defeat of anti-labor bill! February 20, 2011 Bruce Bostick
Will Ohio's Auditor David Yost uncover the No Child Left Behind scam? January 30, 2011 Bob Fitrakis
Kasich, Kasich, you can’t hide – we know you’re with the rich inside January 11, 2011 Bob Fitrakis
On the OSU medical clinic article January 4, 2011 Margaret Nuovo
Ohio State's medical industrial complex under fire for unnecessary surgeries January 3, 2011 Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman
Read Ohio Articles by Year: 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |