Departments
Hacking the vote in Miami County
by Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
December 25, 2004
On Election Night, when 100% of the precincts in Miami County had reported, only 31,620 votes had been counted. George W. Bush was reported to have won Miami County with 20,807 votes (65.80%) to 10,724 votes (33.92%) for John F. Kerry. These numbers did seem low. In 2000 there had been 42,841 ballots cast. Bush had won Miami County with 26,037 votes (60.78%) to 15,584 votes (36.38%) for Al Gore.
Somehow the final total came in later that night at 50,235 votes cast, giving Bush a margin of 16,000 votes, exactly – 33,039 to 17,039. Moreover, as has been widely reported, even with the addition of 18,615 new votes, Bush's percentage was almost unchanged (65.80% to 65.77%), and Kerry's percentage was exactly the same (33.92%). This led some observers to believe that the optical scanner had been programmed to come out that way, to provide the desired 16,000-vote plurality.
Miami County is also noteworthy because of the increase in Bush’s point spread. Bush beat Gore by 60.78% to 36.38% in Miami County, a margin of 24.40%, for a plurality 10,453 votes. While Kerry did receive more votes than Gore, his percentage of the vote was much lower. This time, Bush was reported to have won Miami County by a margin of 31.85%. Coupled with an increase in turnout, then reported at 17.26%, Bush increased his margin from 10,453 votes to 16,000, winning 7,002 of 7,394 new voters.
Now the 1,609 provisional ballots have been examined, 1,542 of them have been counted, and the results have been certified. Bush now claims victory in Miami County with 34,005 votes (65.68%) to 17,611 votes (34.01%) for Kerry. Officially there were 51,777 votes counted for president, an increase of 20.86% over the 2000 presidential vote total.
This represents an astonishing increase in voter turnout. The population of Miami County is reported to have grown from 98,868 to 100,230 since the 2000 census, an increase of only 1.38%. The number of registered voters has risen from 66,765 in 2000 to 72,169 in 2004, an increase of 8.09%.
How did the Republicans do it? To answer this question I have compared, on a precinct by precinct basis, the presidential vote totals for 2004 with those of 2000. Since turnout was key to Bush’s impressive margin in Miami County, I have organized the data according to voter turnout.
First a disclaimer: When Diane Miley of the Miami County Board of Elections faxed me the election results, she made the following disclaimer on the cover sheet: “Please note that the 11/7/00 turnout report is not included. Our predecessors made a programming error which didn’t permit a complete report.”
Therefore, while I can calculate voter turnout for 2004 as total ballots cast divided by the number of registered voters, I cannot do the same for 2000. When comparing turnout in the two elections I can only compare the votes counted for president.
MIAMI COUNTY PRECINCTS WITH HIGHEST TURNOUT, 2004 ELECTION
Registered Votes Percent
Voters Cast Turnout Bush Kerry Bush Gore
CONCORD SOUTH WEST 689 679 98.55 520 157 378 132
CONCORD SOUTH 698 658 94.27 468 182 300 151
TIPP CITY F 622 550 88.42 360 184 249 166
TROY 3-G 848 732 86.32 496 231 184 96
TIPP CITY E 1195 979 81.92 754 221 581 205
TROY 4-F 604 490 81.13 395 94 122 42
MONROE EAST CENTRAL 935 757 80.96 508 247 426 275
TROY 2-D 650 524 80.62 306 216 306 288
PIQUA 5-B 1155 929 80.43 652 273 528 216
MONROE SOUTH EAST 1175 943 80.26 682 252 598 224
MONROE SOUTH 693 555 80.09 379 175 362 167
It is my professional opinion that these numbers are fraudulent, and that this election has been hacked. There simply was not a 98.55% turnout in Concord South West precinct or anywhere else in Ohio. Nor was there a 94.27% turnout in Concord South precinct. I do not believe that Bush won 111 of 129 new voters in Tipp City Precinct F, or 173 of 189 new voters in Tipp City Precinct E, or 273 of 325 new voters in Troy Precinct 4-F, or that voter turnout increased by 194.58% in Troy Precinct 4-F, or that voter turnout increased by 152.78% in Troy Precinct 3-G, or that Bush increased his margin by 110 votes among 54 new voters in Monroe East Central Precinct, or that 72 Democrats who voted in the 2000 election chose not to vote in 2004 in Troy Precinct 2-D while all the Republicans did. To further illustrate my point I have included the other three precincts with 80% turnout, all of which show modest increases for both candidates, as would be expected.
MIAMI COUNTY PRECINCTS WITH LOWEST TURNOUT
Registered Votes Percent
Voters Cast Turnout Bush Kerry Bush Gore
PIQUA 1-B/D 1095 545 49.77 270 270 164 220
PIQUA 3-A 1277 681 53.33 391 282 198 200
PIQUA 1-A 692 387 55.92 193 188 97 126
CONCORD SOUTH EAST 1199 678 56.55 502 171 572 206
TROY 4-A 796 477 59.92 278 194 202 164
TROY 4-B/D 881 520 59.02 256 258 178 211
PIQUA 5-A 757 456 60.24 231 220 175 192
TROY 4-E 711 429 60.34 217 203 148 195
It is my professional opinion that the reported results for the first four of these precincts are fraudulent also. I do not believe that (excluding third-party candidates in order to make my point clearly), John Kerry ran 7.3% behind Al Gore in Piqua Precinct 1-B/D, 8.35% behind Al Gore in Piqua Precinct 3-A, or 7.2% behind Al Gore in Piqua Precinct 1-A, nor do I believe the reported turnout of 49.77%, 53.33%, and 55.92% in a county said to have averaged 72.23% county wide, nor do I believe that turnout in these precincts, compared to the 2000 election, increased by 34.24%, 66.50%, and 63.25%, respectively, in a county that experienced only a 1.38% increase in population. Nor do I believe the reported turnout of 56.55% in Concord South East Precinct, which is no doubt contiguous to Concord South West and Concord South precincts, with their reported turnouts of 98.55% and 94.27%. I challenge the extremely high reported turnout in the Bush precincts and the very low reported turnout in the Kerry precinct. It is not my experience that Democrats don’t like to vote. I am skeptical of the results reported for the next four precincts also, where, in the aggregate, Bush gained 279 votes among 392 new voters, where Kerry ran behind Gore by 3.7%, 4.0%, 3.5%, and 8.5%, respectively.
OTHER MIAMI COUNTY PRECINCTS WITH LARGEST INCREASE IN TURNOUT
Vote Count Percent
2000 2004 Increase Bush Kerry Bush Gore
TROY 2-F 192 321 67.19 407 227 282 146
PIQUA 5-C 380 580 52.63 375 205 214 159
TROY 2-E 435 634 45.75 407 227 282 146
BETHEL SOUTH CENTRAL 708 999 41.10 666 327 412 274
TIPP CITY G 536 708 32.09 478 229 332 186
TROY 1-D 538 704 30.86 459 243 344 185
TROY 3-E 515 672 30.49 406 265 296 208
PIQUA 2-B/C 403 523 29.78 278 243 167 219
PIQUA 4-B/C 334 431 29.04 238 193 173 154
WEST MILTON C 557 718 28.90 465 248 351 193
PIQUA 1-C/E 367 472 28.61 261 210 150 197
CONCORD NORTH 283 363 28.27 239 121 197 79
NEWBERRY WEST 478 612 28.03 428 183 337 131
PIQUA 3-D/E 364 464 27.47 273 186 185 166
It is my professional opinion that the reported results for many of these precincts are fraudulent also. I do not believe that voter turnout increased by 67.19% in Troy Precinct 2-F, 52.63% in Piqua Precinct 5-C, 45.75% in Troy Precinct 2-E, and 41.10% in Bethel South Central Precinct, in a county with 1.38% population growth. Nor do I believe that Bush won 254 of 307 new voters in Bethel South Central Precinct, 146 of 189 new voters in Tipp City Precinct G, 111 of 135 new voters in Piqua Precinct 2-B/C, 111 of 124 new voters in Piqua Precinct 1-C/E, or 88 of 108 new voters in Piqua Precinct 3-D/E. The reported results for the other six precincts could well be true, but only if voter turnout really did increase by 28.03% to 30.86%.
|
 |
Recent Election Issues Articles
Ohio's official non-recount ends amidst new evidence of fraud, theft and judicial contempt mirrored in New Mexico December 31, 2004 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
Impossible Phantom Votes in New Mexico
December 30, 2004 Warren Stewart
The 2004 Presidential Election: Who Won The Popular Vote? An Examination of the Comparative Validity of Exit Poll and Vote Count Data December 29, 2004 Jonathan D. Simon, J.D. and Ron P. Baiman, Ph.D.
Ohio GOP election officials ducking notices of deposition as Kerry enters stolen vote fray December 28, 2004 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
Another third rate burglary December 25, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Hacking the vote in Miami County December 25, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Update from the Ohio Frontlines December 24, 2004 Cynthia L. Butler, Esq.
Lawsuit Before the Ohio Supreme Court December 24, 2004 Summarized by Mary Anne Saucier, Columbus, Ohio
Kerry votes switched to Bush and ballots pre-punched for Bush December 24, 2004 Dr. Werner Lange
Uncounted votes in Cuyahoga County December 24, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Provisional ballots in Cuyahoga County December 24, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Uncounted votes in Summit County December 24, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Uncounted votes in Hamilton County December 24, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Default settings in Mahoning County December 23, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Ohio electoral fight becomes 'biggest deal since Selma' as GOP stonewalls December 22, 2004 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
Observations from an election observer December 22, 2004 M.J. Willow
TV Networks Officially Refuse to Release Exit Poll Raw Data; Mainstream media finally displays true colors December 22, 2004 Gary Beckwith
Election results in Southwestern Ohio December 21, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Voting Rights Groups 'Block' Talk of Machine-Free Elections December 20, 2004 Lynn Landes
Statistics from Warren County December 20, 2004 Clint Cooper
The greatest story never told December 20, 2004 Robert Lockwood Mills
The United States of Ukraine?: Exit Polls Leave Little Doubt that in a Free and Fair Election John Kerry Would Have Won both the Electoral College and the Popular Vote December 19, 2004 Ron Baiman
Certifiable election results December 19, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Sinclair Broadcasting's Long History of Journalistic and Corporate Deception December 19, 2004 Jason Leopold
Ohio vote count battles escalate amidst new evidence of potential criminal activity December 18, 2004 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
American democracy hangs by a thread in Ohio December 15, 2004 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
Startling new revelations highlight rare Congressional hearings on Ohio vote December 13, 2004 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
New Ohio voter transcripts December 12, 2004 Free Press staff
The One-Two Punch of Racism: Whitewashing the Voter Fraud Issue December 10, 2004 Greg Moses
Rigging the vote in Lucas County
December 10, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Uncounted votes in Montgomery County December 10, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Why history demands an Ohio revote December 10, 2004 Harvey Wasserman & Bob Fitrakis
Ohio election fraud uproar blasting to new level December 7, 2004 Steve Rosenfeld, Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman
Dirty work at the Philly polls December 3, 2004 Margie Burns
Voter Suppression: STEALING VOTES IN OHIO URBAN AREAS (full documentation) December 3, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
In Ohio 2004, it's the People versus the Party of Hate & Terror and the Party of Duck and Run...but will the Democrats now stand and fight? December 1, 2004 Harvey Wasserman & Bob Fitrakis
Warren County, Ohio: most successful voter registration drive in American political history, or stuffing the ballot box December 1, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Jesse Jackson demands Ohio presidential recount, blasts GOP election officials, and says Kerry supports the process November 29, 2004 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Kerry Supports Ohio Vote Investigation, Jackson says November 28, 2004 Steven Rosenfeld
Hope for the Homestretch November 28, 2004 Paul Rogat Loeb
Favoritism in the suburbs November 27, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
New Ohio voter transcripts feed floodtide of doubt about Republican election manipulation November 25, 2004 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Election officials gave wrong information about provisional ballots - revealed in affidavit. November 25, 2004 Neil F. Schoenwetter, Jr.
US tells Ukraine to recount votes on fradulent election! November 25, 2004 Dr. J. Alva Scruggs
Not counting the votes November 24, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Stealing votes in Columbus November 23, 2004 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Making every vote count November 23, 2004 Christopher T. Hicks
How a Republican election supervisor manipulated the 2004 central Ohio vote, in black and white November 23, 2004 Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman
More Ohio voter suppression testimony prompts upcoming legal filing for statewide recount November 20, 2004 Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman
Ohio Presidential Results to be Challenged November 20, 2004 Steven Rosenfeld
Franklin County, Ohio voting machine assignments, and other information November 20, 2004 Free Press staff
Coalition's Support of Voting Machines Causes Confusion
November 20, 2004 Lynn Landes
Hearings on Ohio voting put 2004 election in doubt November 18, 2004 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Closing the Circle: The Corporatization of Elections November 17, 2004 Greg Coleridge
Subordinating nation's secular values to zealots' will November 12, 2004 Pierre Tristam
The Public Hearings and Rally About Election Fraud in Columbus, OH this weekend, Sat. 11/13-Please pass widely! November 12, 2004 Dr. Lora Chamberlain
Slip-sliding away in Columbus November 11, 2004 Carolyn M. Sherman
Green and Libertarian Presidential Candidates to Demand Ohio Recount November 11, 2004 Blair Bobier and Stephen Gordon
An End To Mourning November 9, 2004 Todd Huffman, M.D.
November 3rd action November 6, 2004 Mark Huntress
The Bible, The Constitution, and the James Carville Experiment November 5, 2004 Tom Luffman
Basic report from Columbus November 5, 2004 Ray Beckerman
Waiting to vote November 5, 2004 James K. Galbraith
Confessions of a political Know-Nothing in the wake of the 2004 elections November 4, 2004 Mark Anderson
Let the spin begin November 4, 2004 Free Press staff
Back Stabbers Cost Kerry in Ohio! November 4, 2004 Tom Luffman
The Last Battle November 4, 2004 Sheila Samples
Republican America! Republican Forever! November 3, 2004 Am Johal
Is there inner-city election suppression in Franklin County, Ohio? November 2, 2004 Bob Fitrakis
Michael Moore in Columbus November 1, 2004 Tom Luffman
No love in the Heartland: Kerry gets mocked in Pa. school election November 1, 2004 Jamie Pietras
Ten reasons for Greens to vote for Kerry November 1, 2004 Don St.Clair
Twelve ways Bush is now stealing the Ohio vote October 27, 2004 Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman
GW Bush Before the Iraq War
October 24, 2004 Larry S. Rolirad
MISOGYNY October 24, 2004 David Podvin
Foreign Policy Forecast: If Bush Wins | If Kerry Wins October 18, 2004 Muqtedar Khan
Hope for the homestretch October 15, 2004 Paul Rogat Loeb
FactCheck.org says Cheney got it wrong October 8, 2004 Jason Leopold
Do the Hokey Pokey October 6, 2004 Philip J. Rappa
Hope for the homestretch October 2, 2004 Paul Rogat Loeb
Addressing Republican issues with John Kerry October 1, 2004 Free Press staff
Gallup Polls- Conditioning for Vote Rigging? September 28, 2004 Stephen Crockett and Al Lawrence
Too Many Cameras and Not Enough Truth: John Kerry Dodges the Press September 14, 2004 Joshua Frank
Nader 2000 Leaders United To Defeat Bush September 14, 2004 Nader 2000 Leaders United To Defeat Bush
Shut up and color: the politics of bullying September 7, 2004 Paul Rogat Loeb
Kerry, Nader and the Greens need to kill the circular firing squad August 15, 2004 Harvey Wasserman & Bob Fitrakis
Don’t Believe the Hype; Terrorist Warnings Just Another Way Bush Will Steal Election August 9, 2004 Jason Leopold
President of Greater Stark County AFL-CIO speaks out on Bush’s visit in Canton, Ohio August 1, 2004 Dan Sciury
I'll Follow Kucinich to Kerry, Sorry Ralph July 28, 2004 David Swanson
Badnarik Doubles in Recent National Poll July 28, 2004 Libertarian Party
‘A green world is possible’ planned in New York City during the Republican National Convention July 28, 2004 Green Party
An open letter to progressives: vote Kerry and Cobb July 24, 2004 Eleven prominent progressives
A street fighting man? How Kucinich can win April 21, 2004 Josh Frank
Scary, Scary John Kerry March 25, 2004 Josh Frank
With all deliberate stupidity: US self-isolation makes Iraq a virtual non-issue in the elections so far March 22, 2004 Daniel Patrick Welch
To support or not to support; the Nader question March 16, 2004 Josh Frank
Halliburton, VP Cheney's Former Company Faces Second Criminal Probe In Four Years February 24, 2004 Jason Leopold
The Lone Ranger of Righteousness February 23, 2004 Paul Rogat Loeb
The Wrong Side of History February 22, 2004 Daniel Patrick Welch
High Noon in America January 26, 2004 Philip J. Rappa
The Truth is Out: Kucinich is the choice of progressives January 15, 2004 via Daniel P. Welch
Dean and Kucinich January 13, 2004 Paul Rogat Loeb
Bush Should Be Facing 'A Long, Hard Slog' On The Campaign Trail, But Dems Too Busy Fighting With Each Other January 12, 2004 Jason Leopold
Read Election Issues Articles by Year: 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |