Departments
Arnebeck letter to Congress re Presidential Electoral Challenge
by Clifford O. Arnebeck, Jr.
January 6, 2005
Dear United States Senator or Member of Congress:
Today, you are being asked to certify the reported votes of the Electoral College even though the status of the Ohio electors is still the subject of the meritorious election contest. You are being asked to do so on the basis of one or more of the following three fallacies:
1) The faith-based neocon fallacy that vote counts do not have to be independently verified.
This new "con" holds that facts may be overcome by assertions of faith by those in power. Thus, the Bush campaign co-chair for Ohio and Secretary of State Kenneth Blackwell need not count 106,000 as yet uncounted Ohio ballots, because he has faith they would not make a difference in the reported 119,000 vote difference even thought these uncounted votes all are in areas of Ohio that demonstrated strong support for John Kerry, and because, as Secretary of State he has the power not to count them.
A corollary of this fallacy is that Ken Blackwell need not answer questions under oath. The answers to such questions might upset peoples' faith in the new "con."
2) The fallacy that Karl Rove is a nice guy/clean campaigner, and those who suspect otherwise with respect to this election which Bush was expected to lose, are conspiracy theorists.
Karl Rove fights hard for what he wants . . . a worthy quality. However, no one has accused him of being a stickler for cleanliness in his campaigns.
Yet, you are being asked to believe that fewer machines and longer lines in Afro-American precincts, the scandalously lower vote counts in Afro-American precincts, the confusion over precincts and ballots and counts and the disproportionate requirement that Afro-American voters vote provisionally all as unintentional glitches.
You are being asked to believe that the biggest glitch of all, that is Ohio and national vote counts which are realistically impossible in light of the exit poll results, is accidental
Those of Jewish faith and Afro-American ethnicity are being labeled as conspiracy theorists rather than people with a special insight based upon historical maltreatment in institutions like slavery and the Holocaust, for their belief that anybody intentionally directed all these glitches just at them.
3) The rule of power fallacy which exempts those in power from the rule of law and the rules of evidence.
This fallacy is based upon the double standard where rules applied to others do not apply to those in power. America, because it is the world's military superpower, may use
exit polls to verify or challenge the validity of elections in other countries, such as
the Ukraine, Mexico and others, but exit polling may not be used to challenge election results reported in the United States.
In the United States the party in power, that is, the Bush-Republican Party, may exempt itself from rules which apply to Democrats and those not in control of the Bush-Republican Party.
The rule of power fallacy is the most important of these three fallacies because it teaches Democrats like John Kerry, John Edwards and Terry McAuliffe that there is no point in challenging Bush Republicans based upon law or fact because Bush Republicans control the Congress, the Courts and the Presidency and will use that control to impose their will no matter what may be the facts or the law.
In my experience over the past four years in successfully litigating on behalf of the non-partisan Alliance for Democracy in partnership with Common Cause/Ohio as Chairman of its Legal Affairs Committee against the Ohio Chamber of Commerce and the Chamber of Commerce of the United States neither the candidates nor the party that have been targeted by the approximately $14 million of illegal corporate money have been involved as parties or public supporters of the litigation. In politics the targeted candidates and parties place a higher priority upon avoiding the appearance being sore losers than upon seeking the true facts and upholding the rule of law.
It does not surprise me, based upon my most recent election litigation experience, that John Kerry and the Democratic Party which appear to have been the intended victim of the most massive election fraud in history are not contesting this election.
In contrast to the intended victims of this fraud, you as a United States Senator, whether a member of the Democratic or Republican Party are called upon to judge this election not as a party but as a judge. You are bound by your oath to uphold the Constitution to judge this election independently and objectively with regard to the facts and the law.
Ohio voters who formally contest the November 2, 2004, contest the election not only for its irregularities, but also because the evidence shows that a majority of Ohio voters and a majority of American voters voted for John Kerry. We assert that the evidence for this meets, not only the clear and convincing standard of Ohio law for an election contest, but also the "beyond a reasonable doubt" standard of criminal law.
Ohio's Secretary of State has refused to answer questions under oath as to either the blatant irregularities or the results he has certified. He is stonewalling, on the apparent belief that Congress will simply proceed to count Ohio's electoral votes today, along with the votes of all the other states, and the matter will be over. He is looking to Congress to free him and others from responding to the overwhelming evidence that the Ohio election results he certified are fraudulent and that John Kerry won Ohio and therefore the presidency.
In the 2000 presidential election the U.S. Supreme Court took responsibility for stopping the verification and counting Florida votes for purposes of the certification of the Florida presidential electors. The Congress then took responsibility for accepting, without challenge, the unverified electoral votes of Florida.
A consortium of news organizations took the initiative to count all the Florida votes after the inauguration of George W. Bush. Thus, history now records the fact that Albert Gore actually won the Florida popular vote had all votes been properly counted.
Based upon the evidence, uncontroverted by any sworn testimony whatsoever, if the Ohio litigation challenging the Ohio presidential vote is allowed to proceed, it will promptly establish as a matter of fact that John Kerry won Ohio and Presidency.
All of the Ohio votes, whether cast or simply tabulated on computerized voting machines, can and should be promptly counted by independent companies whose tabulating equipment, personnel, procedures and software are fully transparent to both political parties and the independent nonpartisan groups that support an honest Ohio election.
For us to complete our non-partisan job of litigating the Ohio election result we need your help in challenging the electoral votes of every state, until due process in our litigation can be completed. If instead, you accept the reported electoral college votes today or limit your challenge only to the Ohio vote, it appears likely that the Ohio Supreme Court will dismiss our election challenge as moot because the challenged Ohio electors will today have been fully discharged by the completed act of Congress.
Because of the importance of this matter, history requires that the Ohio 2004 presidential election votes ultimately be accurately counted. If that happens after an inauguration, then, based upon the evidence at hand, history would record that, for a second time, George W. Bush would have been elected on the basis of an incorrect count of the votes that were actually cast and that, for a second time the Congress certified an inaccurate Presidential election result.
Sincerely yours,
Clifford O. Arnebeck, Jr.
Chairman of the Ohio Honest Election Campaign and Co-Chair of the Alliance for Democracy
Counsel of Record for the Contestors in Rev. Bill Moss et al. v. Bush et al., Supreme Court of Ohio, Case No. 04-2088
|
 |
Recent Election Issues Articles
An open letter to the Election Assistance Commission December 25, 2005 John Gideon, Executive Director of VotersUnite.Org and Information Manager for VoteTrustUSA.Org
Diebold hack proven in county test! December 17, 2005 Glenn Yeagley
Diebold Inc. in a tailspin after resignation of CEO and filing of a class action fraud lawsuit December 17, 2005 VelvetRevolution.us
Orr thinks machines make voting simpler, more secure December 17, 2005 Mario Bartoletti
Diebold "hack test" - Sec. State / Black Box Lawyer square off December 10, 2005 Black Box Voting
With new legislation, Ohio Republicans plan holiday burial for American Democracy December 6, 2005 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Important daily voting news December 4, 2005 John Gideon
Poll shock November 24, 2005 Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
Ohio's Diebold Debacle: New machines call election results into question November 24, 2005 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Diebold attempts to evade election transparency laws November 20, 2005 Matt Zimmerman
Supreme Court stabs another GOP knife into US democracy by upholding ex-felon vote ban November 16, 2005 Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman
Has American Democracy died an electronic death in Ohio 2005's referenda defeats? November 11, 2005 Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman
What John Kerry definitely said about 2004’s stolen election and why it's killing American democracy November 10, 2005 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Scrap the "secret" ballot - return to open voting November 5, 2005 Lynn Landes
Clarification of NEDA's withdrawal of Ohio exit poll paper November 5, 2005 Kathy Dopp
Clarification of NEDA's withdrawal of Ohio exit poll paper November 3, 2005 Kathy Dopp, National Election Data Archive
Watergate-style money laundering indictments stoke Ohio's stolen election fires October 28, 2005 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Powerful Government Accountability Office report confirms key 2004 stolen election findings October 26, 2005 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Did you erase your own vote? October 25, 2005 Warren Stewart, Director of Legislative Issues and Policy, www.VoteTrustUSA.org
Why can't the left face the Stolen Elections of 2004 & 2008? October 18, 2005 Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman
Carter/Baker Report can't face how the GOP stole America's 2004 election & is rigging 2008 September 20, 2005 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Two Steps Forward, One Step Back September 20, 2005 Warren Stewart, Director of Legislative Issues and Policy, VoteTrustUSA
FEMA Chief Brown Paid Millions in False Claims to Help Bush Win Fla. Votes September 19, 2005 Jason Leopold
Ohio recount lawsuit set for trial; election workers indicted September 4, 2005 Blair Bobier
Ohio Governor's ethics violations expose money trail to stolen 2004 election August 30, 2005 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Diebold's failure in California August 7, 2005 John Gideon, Information Manager, www.VotersUnite.Org and www.VoteTrustUSA.Org
Did the GOP steal another Ohio Election? August 5, 2005 Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman
Conyers-Kaptur seek special counsel for Noe probe August 4, 2005 John Conyers, Jr. and Marcy Kaptur
Dramatic new charges deepen link between Ohio's "Coingate," Voinovich mob connections, and the theft of the 2004 election July 29, 2005 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
None dare call it stolen - Ohio, the election, and America's servile press July 24, 2005 Mark Crispin Miller, summarized by Mary Anne Saucier, Columbus, Ohio
Civic Engagement and the Restoration of Community from a voter activist’s view July 19, 2005 Terri Zins
My report from Hocking County, July 5, 2005: An update on Sherole Eaton's unfolding Story July 7, 2005 Victoria Parks, Ohio Backbone Campaign
Handbook for Ohio Voter Activists, Version 2.0 July 7, 2005 Various activists
Direct testimony: Presented to Election Assessment Hearing July 4, 2005 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
Log Cabin Republicans in Ohio July 4, 2005 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
With a limp election theft report, Dems prove why they're unworthy June 28, 2005 Harvey Wasserman and Bob Fitrakis
Voting problems and uncounted votes in Lucas County, Ohio June 28, 2005 Justine Smith
The DNC 2004 Election Report: An indictment of incompetence June 25, 2005 Steven Rosenfeld and Bob Fitrakis
Corporate control of the election process June 22, 2005 John Gideon
Introduction: Did George W. Bush steal America's 2004 election? June 16, 2005 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
Voter Confidence Committee Calls For Rejection of CA Special Election June 16, 2005 Dave Berman
Activists from 25 states lobby for paper ballots on June 9 and 10 June 10, 2005 VoteTrustUSA.org
Fear of riffraff June 10, 2005 Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
Electoral Politics and the War: Lessons from 2004 and What the Anti-War Movement Should do in 2006 June 8, 2005 Kevin Zeese
Optical scan machines hacked in Florida June 2, 2005 Black Box Voting
Does ES&S really want to sell the Automark machines? May 28, 2005 John Gideon
Attack on election board whistleblower and leaked Blackwell threats re-fire Ohio's election theft scandal May 23, 2005 Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman
Franklin County, Ohio Election Procedures – April and May 2005 May 6, 2005 Paddy Shaffer
Carter Gets It – But Will His Electoral Commission? April 24, 2005 Kevin Zeese and Linda Schade
Voter Perceptions and Political Deceptions: Federal, Ohio and Knox April 24, 2005 Mike Swinford
Electoral reform groups call for James Baker's resignation from electoral reform commission April 17, 2005 Ilene Proctor
National Conference on Election Reform Opens with Civil Rights Panel April 13, 2005 Abigail Thorton
View from Another Planet April 13, 2005 Josh Mitteldorf
Democrats! Paper “Trails” Aren’t Good Enough. Count The Damn Ballots! April 12, 2005 Lynn Landes
Democrats, Paper ‘Trails’ Aren’t Good Enough; Count The Damn Ballots! April 1, 2005 Lynn Landes, Online Journal Contributing Writer
Scientific Analysis Suggests Presidential Vote Counts May Have Been Altered March 30, 2005 US Vote Counts
As Blackwell Says, Ohio’s in 2004 was a National Model March 24, 2005 Steve Rosenfeld, Bob Fitrakis, and Harvey Wasserman
Understanding the difference between paper ballots and paper audit trails March 20, 2005 Gary Beckwith
Save Our Democracy March 16, 2005 John Irwin
Republicans maneuvering to get Voting Rights Act killed March 10, 2005 Rev. Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.
Legal filing highlights Blackwell's hypocrisy in Ohio recount case March 7, 2005 Blair Bobier
Selma 40 Years Later March 6, 2005 Rev. Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.
Exit Poll Madness - Analyst Steve Freeman & Company Offer False Choice March 4, 2005 Lynn Landes
Libertarians To Testify in Ohio House: Modernize Ohio's Election Laws March 3, 2005 Robert Butler
The New Voting Rights Movement Begins Here Today March 2, 2005 Steven Rosenfeld
Voting in America February 28, 2005 Bob Babson
The Mighty Texas Strike Force February 28, 2005 Nick Mottern - Documentary News Service
Blackwell presidential election sanctions briefs February 22, 2005 Various individuals
Representative Conyers and others file amicus brief in Ohio Supreme Court February 17, 2005 Dena Graziano
Congresswoman Tubbs Jones Outraged at Blackwell's Failure to Appear During House Administration Hearing February 12, 2005 Office of Rep. Tubbs Jones
Ohio Attorney-General's attack on election protection attorneys draws mountain of documentation on state's stolen election, including new study on exit polls February 3, 2005 Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
Prominent Statisticians Refute 'Explanation' of 2004 U.S. Exit Poll Discrepancies in New Edison/Mitofsky Report and Urge Investigation of U.S. Presidential Election Results January 31, 2005 Bruce O'Dell
The last man to concede... January 29, 2005 Sheila Samples
Report on Washington DC, January 6, 2005 January 25, 2005 Avram Friedman
Arkansas in 2004: Did Bush Really Win? January 24, 2005 Max Standridge
New links January 23, 2005 Free Press staff
Voting Problems and Uncounted Votes in Lucas County, Ohio January 23, 2005 Justine Smith
Plan B: Parallel Elections & Signed Ballots January 20, 2005 Lynn Landes
Open Letter to Ohio Attorney General Jim Petro from Representative John Conyers, Jr. January 20, 2005 Representative John Conyers, Jr.
Open Letter to Warren Mitofsky and Larry Rosin from Representative John Conyers, Jr. January 20, 2005 Representative John Conyers, Jr.
Ohio's GOP Attorney General launches revenge attack on Election Protection legal team January 19, 2005 Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
What are they hiding in New Mexico? January 18, 2005 Warren Stewart, National Ballot Integrity Project
In the Shadow of Dr. King, counting the vote remains a civil rights issue January 17, 2005 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
Did the “Liberal Media” Get the 2004 Election All Wrong?
January 16, 2005 Gene C. Gerard
'COUNT EVERY VOTE. EVERY VOTE COUNTS' January 16, 2005 Mary Anne Saucier
Moss v. Bush moves on and movement continues January 13, 2005 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
Rally Continues Drive for Democracy January 9, 2005 Mark Huntress
Estimated vote count in Ohio January 8, 2005 Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.
January 6 Washington, D.C. rally report January 8, 2005 Nick Mottern
Together, we moved three mountains January 8, 2005 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
What the election challenge means January 8, 2005 David Swanson, ILCA
Progressive Democrats lead historic voting rights protest as Congress ratifies flawed 2004 Electoral College tally January 7, 2005 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
Arnebeck letter to Congress re Presidential Electoral Challenge January 6, 2005 Clifford O. Arnebeck, Jr.
Senator Barbara Boxer, D-CA and Representative Stephanie Tubbs Jones, D-OH contested the election January 6, 2005 Free Press staff
The "Crime of November 2": The human side of how Bush stole Ohio, and why Congress must investigate rather than ratify the Electoral College (Part Two of Two) January 5, 2005 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
Status Report of the House Judiciary Committee Democratic Staff January 5, 2005 U.S. Rep. John Conyers and staff
Seven key reasons why the vote must be challenged at the electoral college January 3, 2005 Rev. Jesse Jackson, Rainbow/PUSH Coalition
Ten preliminary reasons why the Bush vote does not compute, and why Congress must investigate rather than certify the Electoral College (Part One of Two) January 3, 2005 Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
Verified election contest petitions and documents in Ohio Supreme Court January 2, 2005 The undersigned
Distribution of voting machines by county in Ohio January 1, 2005 Andy Shifflette
Did We Bounce An Election? January 1, 2005 Warren Stewart, votersunite.org
Presidential election congressional hearing transcript January 1, 2005 Congresspeople Waters, Tubbs-Jones and Conyers and others
Read Election Issues Articles by Year: 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |