Departments
Basket brawl recreates gladiator-spectator relationship
by Salim Muwakkil
December 23, 2004
Was the melee between NBA players and fans a racial brawl?
The Nov. 19 game between the Indiana Pacers and the Detroit Pistons resulted in nine players being banned for more than 140 games.
All of the players involved were black and most of the fans they confronted were white.
Initially race was a silent issue. But as pundits of every stripe have weighed in on this incident, discussions of race have become increasingly prominent.
The narrative that is emerging goes something like this: Most professional basketball players are poor black youths from urban America who are socialized in a culture that lacks social graces. They earn exorbitant salaries, live pampered lifestyles and lack the appropriate gratitude for their -- largely unearned -- good fortune.
What's more, these black athletes are performing for predominantly white fans who are affluent enough to afford the high cost of NBA tickets. It's a tricky arrangement.
But that developing narrative is a bit one sided, and the lack of symmetry was evident in the players’ penalties. Ron Artest expressed his regret for the incident and complained that NBA Commissioner David Stern penalized him too severely. (Artest received a 72-game suspension and is out for the rest of the season.) Stern acknowledged he was particularly hard on Artest. “I did not strike from my mind that Ron Artest had been suspended on previous conditions for loss of self-control,” he said.
The NBA Players Association said Artest's punishment is too severe and has hinted it will challenge Stern’s sweeping authority as commissioner. Not only does Stern determine the penalties, he also has the final word on any appeal.
But those organizational and logistical concerns only skirt the edges of the true crisis.
The separation of gladiator and spectator traditionally is one of class. In more current times, the separation is more of a cultural gap with increasingly prominent racial overtones.
NBA officials once doubted if whites would even pay to watch black athletes.
The dominance of African-American players in the NBA has revolutionized the game and, for the most part, the difference has been fortuitous for league officials. The black players’ explosive athleticism and stylistic flourishes have helped Nielsen ratings and have increased revenue of most pro sports franchises.
But those cultural differences have rougher aspects. The hip-hop sensibilities that shape the behavior of the younger NBA players certainly fuel exciting athletic exploits, but they also inspire other, less desirable team qualities.
The intolerance for disrespect ("dissing"), the "bling-bling" ostentation, the celebratory ego-flexing -- these attitudes also are part of the hip-hop package. But fans increasingly are rejecting that aspect of the game.
“League and club executives decided to marry the NBA to hip-hop, and clearly didn't know what they were getting into,” wrote Washington Post sports columnist Michael Wilbon. He argues that by hyping the hip-hop connection, NBA officials share some blame for widening the gap between fans and players.
It was a gamble. An emphasis on hip-hop sensibilities might have provided just the spurt of profitability the sport needed. But if the league and its marketers created it, then blaming the players for following through is the ultimate dis.
Salim Muwakkil is senior editor of the Chicago-based In These Times magazine (www.inthesetimes.com), and a contributing writer to the Chicago Tribune. He can be reached at pmproj@progressive.org. © Salim Muwakkil
|
 |
Recent National Issues Articles
Stay granted pending appeal December 27, 2004 Staughton Lynd
Divided we stand: The cleaving of America December 24, 2004 W. E. Guman
The Right, the Cross and the CIA: Immaculate Deception December 24, 2004 W. E. Guman
Degrees of Separation: Mass Murder Style December 23, 2004 Susan Bourland
Hispanic vote for GOP does not reflect long-term shift December 23, 2004 Ed Morales
Gonzales is poor choice for U.S. Attorney General December 23, 2004 Bernardo Ruiz
Tavis Smiley’s exit from NPR will be great loss for radio December 23, 2004 Leah Samuel
Basket brawl recreates gladiator-spectator relationship December 23, 2004 Salim Muwakkil
HRC releases World AIDS Day report card December 2, 2004 Human RIghts Campaign
The Impossible Will Take a Little While: Hope in a Time of Fear November 27, 2004 Paul Rogat Loeb
Attorney jailed, released pending appeal on privilege issue November 22, 2004 Martin Yant and Stacie DeVault
Subordinating nation's secular values to zealots' will November 21, 2004 Pierre Tristam
Sorry, No Foreign-Born Presidents November 21, 2004 Jimmy W. Hall
Flight Attendants, the Working Day and Labor Solidarity November 21, 2004 Seth Sandronsk
Attorney refuses to testify, jailed November 20, 2004 Martin Yant
Where Is Our National Conscience? November 20, 2004 Todd Huffman, M.D.
Beam me Up Scotty… October 25, 2004 James Bengel
Under Cheney, Halliburton Helped Saddam Hussein Siphon Billions from UN Oil-for-Food Program October 18, 2004 Jason Leopold
Disinformation and Depleted Uranium October 3, 2004 Tadit Anderson
The History of the CIA and the American Elections Coup September 28, 2004 Stephen Caruso
Unnoticed 1st Amendment Abuses September 14, 2004 Steve Gligorov J.D. and Metodija A. Koloski
How Dick Cheney Got Away With $35 Million Right Before the Govt Launched a Probe into Halliburton August 19, 2004 Jason Leopold
The Results of Ten Years of Prosecution of Corporate Crimes August 15, 2004 Rick Keefer
Greens cite reasons for a new, independent 9/11 probe July 31, 2004 Green Party, USA
Empty Platform, Empty Town July 31, 2004 Daniel Patrick Welch
Ralph Nader Sleeping with the Enemy? Let's Be Fair July 22, 2004 Joshua Frank
Missing Government Documents- Berger and Bush July 22, 2004 Stephen Crockett and Al Lawrence
ADC Update: Contact ADC if Approached by the FBI July 20, 2004 American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee
The isolation of Indiana, USA July 18, 2004 John Rouse
The Convention Speech A Child Longs To Hear July 14, 2004 Todd Huffman, M.D.
Waging War with Wal-Mart July 4, 2004 Author's name withdrawn at his request
Good for Business, Bad for the People June 29, 2004 Daniel Patrick Welch
Condi Rice salutes war president, It's not who you think June 29, 2004 Brian McKenna
Did Ashcroft 'behead' an innocent man in an Ohio election-terror scam? June 20, 2004 Harvey Wasserman and Bob Fitrakis
Ohio Muslims react to arrest of terror suspect June 16, 2004 Jad Humeidan
New documents suggest Enron’s Lay, Skilling, Washington lobbyist knew about company’s trading schemes in California June 14, 2004 Jason Leopold
Ronald Reagan's Hip-Hop Legacy June 14, 2004 Jimi Izrael
Impeach the SOB, Damn the Republicans-Full Speed Ahead! May 18, 2004 Daniel Patrick Welch
Labor Media May Be Our Best Hope Against the Corporate Version May 18, 2004 David Swanson
Energy advisors helped fund governor's campaign May 13, 2004 Jason Leopold
Schwarzenegger Pulls a Cheney; Aides Refuse to Identify People Who Helped Governor Draft Calif. Energy Plan May 2, 2004 Jason Leopold
Got Juice? California May Be Saddled With Severe Power Shortages This Summer April 15, 2004 Jason Leopold
Bush Was Warned of Possible Attack in U.S., Official Says April 10, 2004 CLG News
Faking Democracy - Americans Don't Vote, Machines Do, & Ballot Printers Can't Fix That April 7, 2004 Lynn Landes
When Good Men Don't Do Nothing March 30, 2004 Daniel Patrick Welch
9/11: It worked, didn't it? March 29, 2004 James R. Hanson
One quarter of every tax dollar you pay! $7 Trillion national debt driving interest expense to record highs March 24, 2004 Christopher Bifani
The strange collapse of building seven February 24, 2004 James R. Hanson
Read National Issues Articles by Year: 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |