Departments
Sorry, No Foreign-Born Presidents
by Jimmy W. Hall
November 21, 2004
There is a movement afoot, originating on the left coast, to amend the United States' Constitution to allow foreign-born U.S. citizens to obtain the highest office in our land. Chiefly, the advent of Arnold Swarzzenegger's Governorship of California is the most recent spark that has again brought this issue to the public forefront. Still, I don't quite buy into it.
Our forefathers safe-guarded the Presidency with this provision for a reason, or several reasons. Certainly we are a nation that is in a large part indebted to emigrants and immigration. Americans born elsewhere have surely made the ultimate sacrifice for their grateful adopted nation. And yes, few or no families (apart from Native American Indians) cannot trace their ancestry beyond our borders; however, all of this is irrelevant to the issue at hand.
I have yet to see any viable argument or evidence which suggests that easing Presidential qualifications would be beneficial to our democratic republic. Have you? Be honest. Contrarily, even with the power of the vote to defeat foreign-born candidates, the office itself loses some of its uniqueness if we allow them to run for the Presidency or Vice Presidency. I'll explain.
Again, our Founding Fathers purposely made the office of President of the United States something special, and quintessentially American. The United States dramatically broke ties with its mother country and fought a bloody war to start anew, and one of the many functions of the new Presidency was that of being a figurehead, symbolic of this new independence. While the United States still welcomes qualified people from around the globe to join us, the facts is that we consider those citizens born as Americans to be extra special, worthy of higher stations in life.
From another angle, the birth requirement also acts as an extra level of protection or security for the nation. It assures that someone who has a special tie (birth) to the country will lead it. This helps to ensure loyalty, and disallows 95% of the world's population from ever fooling our electorate.
The clincher is my final line of reasoning. The simple truth is that most of the time a person's nation of birth remains extra-special to them, regardless of where life later leads them. What if someone born in another country were to ascend to the American Presidency, and the United States then somehow became at odds with that very nation? Do we want to put an American President in such a position? Ourselves? Could we rest assured of precisely where his or her loyalty would be then? Can anyone be trusted to attack their own birthland, if need be, in times of war? With relatives still living there? The answer is 'No.' Why place the national security and defense of the United States in such a position?
Don't misunderstand the gist of this column, please. I am in no way belittling American Citizens born elsewhere, but am rather celebrating the heritage of the majority of Americans which were born in this dear land we love. As such, I feel justified in jealously protecting the highest elected post in this wonderful land. Any reasonable requirements, such as those enacted by our forefathers, which further vett its holder can only be a good thing.
I say these things as a person who whole-heartedly supported Mr. Swarzzenegger's election as Governor of the state he truly loves, California. However, being one Governor of fifty is certainly different than being the sole President of the greatest nation in the history of the world. In the event of Austria being opposite of the United States in a future world war, I do not see Arnold as ever being willing to 'terminate' his native nation, even for the sake of his adopted one. Apart from war, smaller trade and treaty arrangements would, no doubt, present further frequent and routine problems...
|
 |
Recent National Issues Articles
Stay granted pending appeal December 27, 2004 Staughton Lynd
Divided we stand: The cleaving of America December 24, 2004 W. E. Guman
The Right, the Cross and the CIA: Immaculate Deception December 24, 2004 W. E. Guman
Degrees of Separation: Mass Murder Style December 23, 2004 Susan Bourland
Hispanic vote for GOP does not reflect long-term shift December 23, 2004 Ed Morales
Gonzales is poor choice for U.S. Attorney General December 23, 2004 Bernardo Ruiz
Tavis Smiley’s exit from NPR will be great loss for radio December 23, 2004 Leah Samuel
Basket brawl recreates gladiator-spectator relationship December 23, 2004 Salim Muwakkil
HRC releases World AIDS Day report card December 2, 2004 Human RIghts Campaign
The Impossible Will Take a Little While: Hope in a Time of Fear November 27, 2004 Paul Rogat Loeb
Attorney jailed, released pending appeal on privilege issue November 22, 2004 Martin Yant and Stacie DeVault
Subordinating nation's secular values to zealots' will November 21, 2004 Pierre Tristam
Sorry, No Foreign-Born Presidents November 21, 2004 Jimmy W. Hall
Flight Attendants, the Working Day and Labor Solidarity November 21, 2004 Seth Sandronsk
Attorney refuses to testify, jailed November 20, 2004 Martin Yant
Where Is Our National Conscience? November 20, 2004 Todd Huffman, M.D.
Beam me Up Scotty… October 25, 2004 James Bengel
Under Cheney, Halliburton Helped Saddam Hussein Siphon Billions from UN Oil-for-Food Program October 18, 2004 Jason Leopold
Disinformation and Depleted Uranium October 3, 2004 Tadit Anderson
The History of the CIA and the American Elections Coup September 28, 2004 Stephen Caruso
Unnoticed 1st Amendment Abuses September 14, 2004 Steve Gligorov J.D. and Metodija A. Koloski
How Dick Cheney Got Away With $35 Million Right Before the Govt Launched a Probe into Halliburton August 19, 2004 Jason Leopold
The Results of Ten Years of Prosecution of Corporate Crimes August 15, 2004 Rick Keefer
Greens cite reasons for a new, independent 9/11 probe July 31, 2004 Green Party, USA
Empty Platform, Empty Town July 31, 2004 Daniel Patrick Welch
Ralph Nader Sleeping with the Enemy? Let's Be Fair July 22, 2004 Joshua Frank
Missing Government Documents- Berger and Bush July 22, 2004 Stephen Crockett and Al Lawrence
ADC Update: Contact ADC if Approached by the FBI July 20, 2004 American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee
The isolation of Indiana, USA July 18, 2004 John Rouse
The Convention Speech A Child Longs To Hear July 14, 2004 Todd Huffman, M.D.
Waging War with Wal-Mart July 4, 2004 Author's name withdrawn at his request
Good for Business, Bad for the People June 29, 2004 Daniel Patrick Welch
Condi Rice salutes war president, It's not who you think June 29, 2004 Brian McKenna
Did Ashcroft 'behead' an innocent man in an Ohio election-terror scam? June 20, 2004 Harvey Wasserman and Bob Fitrakis
Ohio Muslims react to arrest of terror suspect June 16, 2004 Jad Humeidan
New documents suggest Enron’s Lay, Skilling, Washington lobbyist knew about company’s trading schemes in California June 14, 2004 Jason Leopold
Ronald Reagan's Hip-Hop Legacy June 14, 2004 Jimi Izrael
Impeach the SOB, Damn the Republicans-Full Speed Ahead! May 18, 2004 Daniel Patrick Welch
Labor Media May Be Our Best Hope Against the Corporate Version May 18, 2004 David Swanson
Energy advisors helped fund governor's campaign May 13, 2004 Jason Leopold
Schwarzenegger Pulls a Cheney; Aides Refuse to Identify People Who Helped Governor Draft Calif. Energy Plan May 2, 2004 Jason Leopold
Got Juice? California May Be Saddled With Severe Power Shortages This Summer April 15, 2004 Jason Leopold
Bush Was Warned of Possible Attack in U.S., Official Says April 10, 2004 CLG News
Faking Democracy - Americans Don't Vote, Machines Do, & Ballot Printers Can't Fix That April 7, 2004 Lynn Landes
When Good Men Don't Do Nothing March 30, 2004 Daniel Patrick Welch
9/11: It worked, didn't it? March 29, 2004 James R. Hanson
One quarter of every tax dollar you pay! $7 Trillion national debt driving interest expense to record highs March 24, 2004 Christopher Bifani
The strange collapse of building seven February 24, 2004 James R. Hanson
Read National Issues Articles by Year: 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |