Sat May 25 2013
Departments
National Issues

Teach our children well
by Todd Huffman, M.D.
November 20, 2005

In early January, US District Judge John Jones III is expected to deliver his decision in a lawsuit filed by eleven parents, with the help of the ACLU, against the school board of Dover, a sleepy Pennsylvania town outside the capital, Harrisburg. His decision could establish the basis for how American public school students are taught the origins of life for years to come.

A majority of members of the Dover school board last year voted to mandate a brief disclaimer before pupils are taught about evolution: “Because Darwin’s theory is a theory, it is still being tested as new evidence is being discovered. The theory is not a fact. Gaps in the theory exist for which there is no evidence.” The decision of these eight members, each an advocate of the idea of “intelligent design” (ID) and each voted out of office in November, unleashed a firestorm of controversy that quickly spread across the country. And no matter how the judge decides the flames are sure to grow.

The Dover parents sued the school board for mandating the teaching of a religious doctrine, and are challenging the promotion of ID in public schools as unconstitutional according to the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. Judge Jones may be able to lightly sidestep the broader issue of whether ID can be taught in schools by ruling that as the Dover board’s disclaimer did not overtly mention the Bible or a divinity, it did not violate the constitution.

Advocates of ID argue that they simply want public schools to give students a more balanced view of evolution. President Bush agrees; in August 2005 he endorsed teaching intelligent design alongside evolution: “Both sides ought to be properly taught, so people can understand what the debate is about”.

But within the scientific world, there is remarkably little debate. The debate to which the president refers lies almost entirely within the shape-shifting world of American culture. And to the detriment of more pressing national issues more numerous to count, it is there where the debate will have to be settled.

Emerging after 1987, after the Supreme Court declared the teaching of creationism in public schools unconstitutional in Edwards v. Aguillard, and championed by the Discovery Institute, a Seattle-based think-tank, intelligent design offers an alternative explanation for the evolution of life. Intelligent design invokes a complex designer to explain biological diversity, insisting that life in all its complexity could not have arisen without the help of an intelligent and guiding hand.

Intelligent design therefore implies that “God did it”, though advocates are careful not to mention the divine in name. Supporters are quick to point out that ID is not a form of creationism, as is often claimed by its detractors. Creationism applies to the view that life began on Earth sometime around 6000 years ago, and was completed in its present form over six literal days. Supporters of ID accept that the earth is billions of years old. While acknowledging that species can change, they argue that an entirely undirected process of natural selection simply cannot account for the extraordinary complexity and diversity of life on our planet.

As a theological idea, ID is exciting. How wondrous to think of nature as divinely inspired, guided and updated. To study nature is therefore to study the mind of God. Who among us believing in the divine could with certainty refute this as possibility?

Nevertheless, while the belief that natural selection is shaped by the active management of an intelligent and heavenly hand is a perfectly legitimate statement of faith, it is only an idea. ID is not a scientific theory, for there are no set of facts that would disprove it. It cannot even be called a hypothesis since it cannot be tested. It is and can only remain exclusively a matter of faith.

And yet supporters continue to present ID as a scientific theory, a legitimate rival of Darwinian evolution. These anti-Darwinists seized upon Justice Antonin Scalia’s dissent in the 1987 case: “Christian fundamentalists”, he said, “are quite entitled, as a secular matter, to have whatever scientific evidence there may be against evolution presented in their schools”. That implication, that “gaps” exist in our modern scientific understanding of evolution and such gaps are easily plugged by God’s fingers, lies at the heart of the ID movement, which has as its motto “Teach the controversy”.

Through the tactic of demanding that public high school students be taught “the scientific strengths and weaknesses of evolutionary theory”, supporters of ID foster what is in fact an illusion that evolution is a controversial theory among scientists. It is not. Evolution is widely regarded as one of the most powerful and best supported theories in all of science. It is, as declared by the National Academy of Sciences, “the central unifying concept of biology”.

After the President’s comments in August, the White House felt it necessary to issue a clarification. Presidential science advisor John Marburg told the NY Times that ID “is not a scientific concept”, and that “evolution is the cornerstone of modern biology”. Though it clearly clashes with the religious beliefs that many people hold, evolution is an elegant theory that has stood the test of time.

Evolution postulates that complex life arises from simple life. Despite more than a century of looking, no one has found any geological evidence proving otherwise, no evidence that the further one went back in time, the more complex life was, or that unrelated species appeared as if from nowhere. Science accepts evolution by natural selection as the logical conclusion of 150 years of countless experiments, observations, and geological discoveries.

Evolution is evident not only in the fossil record but also in the letters of the genetic code shared in varying degrees by all species. In my field of medicine, evolution is at work everyday, when bacteria become more resistant to antibiotics, when cancer cells develop immunity to chemotherapeutic agents, and when viruses mutate to become stronger or more contagious. Look no further than avian flu for an example of evolution at work.

Much confusion among the public lies with the use of the word “theory”. Critics of evolution constantly repeat that evolution is “a theory, not a fact”. In common everyday language, “theory” is often synonymous with “hunch”, or “educated guess”. But in science we say theory to mean a strong, evidenced-based explanation that brings together many facts and observations in order to make testable predictions. That doesn’t mean that scientific theories are unassailable, but to qualify as theories they must be testable by further research and the study of evidence. The idea of intelligent design is untestable, and as such is not a scientific theory.

Alternative theories should, and in fact often do get equal time in science classrooms and research laboratories around the world every day. Teaching a theory does not force a student to accept it as truth. Teaching a theory protects the student from ignorance, educating him should he aspire to devise ways to test its validity. Science, in fact, hopes that he does, for that is precisely how mankind increases its knowledge of the natural world.

Science begins not with faith, but with observation then experimentation and reasoning. Science is not whatever someone claims it to be. It is not based on anyone’s beliefs or authority. Its tools will never prove or disprove God’s existence. For that matter, science cannot even disprove the idea of intelligent design. Science is, and only is, an explanation that best fits the data we currently have.

The theory of evolution explains life on earth as it exists, with all its wonders, quirks and tragedies. Are there gaps? Few, but yes. But there are gaps in science everywhere. Are we to fill them all with God? The idea of intelligent design reminds me of a cartoon I once saw, in which a mathematician, struggling to complete a proof, fills in the gap with the words “and then a miracle occurs”.

Not only is ID poor science, it is poor theology. It reduces God to a magic word to use whenever we are stymied by a lack of information. It renders God as being everything we cannot explain. If we do not understand a natural process, it must be God’s work.

A majority of men and women in the sciences – be they educators, researchers, or physicians – believe in a divinity. Belief in evolution can be entirely compatible with belief in God. After all, the mechanisms of creation described in Genesis 1 and 2 are left unspecified. Isn’t it possible to believe that God could make life any way he wanted to? Who’s to say that evolution isn’t the method an omnipotent God has intelligently designed to implement his elegant plan for creation?

If supporters of ID were fighting to include teaching the idea of intelligent design in comparative religion or social sciences classrooms, few would resist. Such classrooms are an excellent venue for exploring alternative versions of the origins of life. But science and faith cannot be taught alongside each other. They are different modes of knowing, different sources of wisdom. Science and faith are not in competition. Let us not teach our children that they are.




Recent National Issues Articles

Rumsfeld admits to "ghosting" detainee
  December 30, 2005
  David Swanson

A man without a country
  December 28, 2005
  David Swanson

Impeach the Liar-in-Chief
  December 26, 2005
  Stephen Crockett and Al Lawrence

Bush wiretaps threaten national security
  December 25, 2005
  Stephen Crockett

Which Christmas is the 'War Against Christmas' against?
  December 25, 2005
  Robert Lockwood Mills

Rainbow PUSH Wall Street Project plans economic summit in New York City
  December 22, 2005
  Rainbow PUSH

Fear of the devil
  December 22, 2005
  Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services

It's time to impeach Bush for these blatant violations of the law
  December 22, 2005
  Andy Ostroy

December 3 in the USA: a partial report
  December 22, 2005
  Ted Glick

Bush spews more irresponsible rhetoric as senate Extends Patriot Act for Six Months
  December 22, 2005
  Andy Ostroy

The Constitution in Crisis report
  December 22, 2005
  Edward Chu

Privatize Me...Corporatize Me.... Blackwaterize Me...
  December 20, 2005
  Jason Miller

USA Patriot Act defeated: Libertarians celebrate victory
  December 19, 2005
  Libertarian Party of Ohio

The solution we aren't considering
  December 19, 2005
  David Swanson

Panic attack
  December 15, 2005
  Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services

Eugene McCarthy, prophet with honor
  December 12, 2005
  Robert Lockwood Mills

The iron fist of Jesus
  December 12, 2005
  Jason Miller

Progressive primary challenge to Hilary aunched
  December 6, 2005
  David Swanson

An invitation to a tea party
  December 6, 2005
  Lucinda Marshall

Precarious lives
  December 3, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Criminal trial related to California energy crisis may start soon
  December 3, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Hey board members, leave our kids alone!
  December 3, 2005
  Jason Miller

A Congressman for impeachment
  November 30, 2005
  David Swanson

Friday night Congress: what was that?
  November 23, 2005
  David Swanson

Teach our children well
  November 20, 2005
  Todd Huffman, M.D.

Greenhouse School secures major art donation
  November 18, 2005
  Dan Welch

Parental guidance suggested
  November 16, 2005
  Mike Ferner

Our mothers (and Thomas Paine) warned us about people like the disciples of Strauss
  November 13, 2005
  Jason Miller

Despite his demeanor, Rove's still a Target
  November 13, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Armistice Day 2005
  November 11, 2005
  Stephen Edward Seadler

The Bush-Cheney ethics refresher course
  November 7, 2005
  David Swanson

Vice President lied as White House sought to defuse leak inquiry
  November 7, 2005
  Jason Leopold

53% of Americans support impeachment; ImpeachPAC announced!
  November 5, 2005
  David Swanson

I can't wait
  November 3, 2005
  David Swanson

Nothing to Lose
  November 2, 2005
  Daniel Patrick Welch

The real Rosa Parks
  October 31, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

How has it come to this?
  October 30, 2005
  Jim Oberg

Bush's wheels falling off
  October 30, 2005
  Reverend Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.

Miers, White House surrender to ultraconservatives
  October 27, 2005
  Josh Glasstetter

Prosecutor secures indictment in CIA outing case, lawyers say
  October 27, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Hard conversations about the big easy
  October 24, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Coalition of 75 groups demand end to Pentagon's youth database
  October 19, 2005
  Mike Ferner

Vice President's role in outing of CIA agent under examination, sources close to prosecutor say
  October 19, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Hard questions about the big easy
  October 19, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Times reporter entangled in leak case had unusual relationship with military, Iraqi group
  October 19, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Try and catch the wind
  October 17, 2005
  Daniel Patrick Welch

More from the stormfront gulf central
  October 16, 2005
  David Lewis

A deep look at corruption culture
  October 16, 2005
  Stephen Crockett and Al  Lawrence

Dems Go After Bennett, Salem Radio Network, FCC
  October 9, 2005
  David Swanson

Bill Bennett’s comments emerge from an ideology that is classic white supremacy, Rev. Jesse Jackson says
  October 5, 2005
  Rev. Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.

Why the nomination of Harriet has to be looked at below the radar
  October 5, 2005
  Cynthia L. Butler, an Attorney licensed in PA, NJ, DC, CA

In support of weakness on national security
  October 3, 2005
  David Swanson

Bill Frist, The Former 2008 Presidential Candidate
  September 27, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Winds of change blow through DC, Bush flees
  September 26, 2005
  Bob Fitrakis

More New Orleans stories
  September 25, 2005
  David Lewis

From the stormfront: experiencing Rita in New Orleans
  September 25, 2005
  David Lewis

The GOP’s fiscal policies turned a natural disaster into a man-made catastrophe
  September 23, 2005
  Jason Leopold

The Devil in the Details: Carter-Baker, California, and the Integrity of American Elections
  September 22, 2005
  Warren Stewart, Director of Legislative Issues and Policy, VoteTrustUSA

Hurricane Katrina-Our Experiences
  September 21, 2005
  Larry Bradshaw, Lorrie Beth Slonsky

A Fraction of Democracy
  September 20, 2005
  Greg Coleridge

Bring back New Orleans: the politics of disaster
  September 20, 2005
  David Lewis, Photos by Aaron Geiser

Rev. Jackson Recommends a 21st Century Marshall Plan That Reinvests in the Gulf Coast
  September 20, 2005
  Rev. Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.

Division of funeral corp. charged with desecrating corpses hired to collect deceased victims of hurricane Katrina
  September 19, 2005
  Jason Leopold

FEMA Chief Brown paid millions in false claims to help Bush win Fla. votes
  September 15, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Indefinite Detention
  September 9, 2005
  Daniel Sturm

Seems like more people died than prospered under Pres Bush’s leadership
  September 8, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Politics, timing and the so-called terrorist Nuradin Abdi: the mall bomber who wasn't
  September 7, 2005
  Bob Fitrakis

Paul Allen's other yacht
  September 4, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Katrina: A tragedy made worse
  September 4, 2005
  Rev. Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.

The President’s priorities: state of marriage took precedence over state of Louisiana
  September 3, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Notes from inside New Orleans
  September 3, 2005
  Jordan Flaherty

Rev. Jackson Makes Second Rescue Mission into New Orleans
  September 2, 2005
  Rainbow/PUSH Coalition

Bush Strafes New Orleans, Where's Huey Long?
  September 2, 2005
  Greg Palast

911 in New Orleans
  September 2, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Global Warming and Widespread Blackouts Are Just as Deadly as Terrorism
  September 1, 2005
  Jason Leopold

The mothers are coming!
  August 30, 2005
  Sheila Samples

Update from Leonard Peltier
  August 16, 2005
  Leonard Peltier

Leonard has been transferred to USP Lewisburg
  August 16, 2005
  Michael Eckhardt

Against Discouragement
  August 15, 2005
  Howard Zinn

Open Letter to Cindy Sheehan, Crawford, Texas
  August 11, 2005
  Ralph Nader

Regarding the 40th Anniversary of the Voting Rights Act of 1965
  August 4, 2005
  Sabrina Williams

Lawyers, guns and money: Just put down that lawsuit, pardner, and no one gets hurt
  August 1, 2005
  Greg Palast

Forgotten Victims of America’s Plutocracy
  August 1, 2005
  Jason Miller

Spine, spine everywhere a spine
  July 29, 2005
  Rady Ananda

Speaking truth to Roberts
  July 28, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Business as usual with Judge Roberts; straight corporate, with Pepto-Bismol chaser
  July 21, 2005
  Alexander Cockburn and Jeffrey St Clair

The Record of Judge John Roberts
  July 20, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

The Enemy of Our Enemy May Still Be the Enemy of Democracy
  July 13, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Mr. Rove and the Access of Evil: Tell Us Your "Source," Judy
  July 13, 2005
  Greg Palast

The Economy Turned the Corner and Is Headed in the Wrong Direction
  July 8, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

July 4th Declaration of Impeachment
  July 4, 2005
  Mike Ferner, Veterans for Peace

They Died for Their Country
  July 1, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Energy adviser who solicited Enron to help write national energy policy to be named Chair of FERC
  July 1, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Big Food Strikes Back; Ag industry aims to strip local control of food supplies
  June 26, 2005
  Britt Bailey and Brian Tokar

The fantastical world of Studley McMuffin
  June 25, 2005
  Sheila Samples

Counter-Recruitment: Preventing the Military from Getting More Youth for their Wars: An Interview with Counter-Recruitment Activist Clint Coppernoll
  June 25, 2005
  Kevin Zeese

A matter of education...
  June 23, 2005
  Sheila Samples

Violations of Civil Liberties are an American Tradition
  June 17, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

Rumsfeld: Beyond the Point of No Return
  June 13, 2005
  Gerald Rellick

Peltier hearing to address Lakota Nation soverignty
  June 11, 2005
  Russ Redner and Barry Bachrach

Extraordinarily rancid justices
  June 10, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Former Army Sec, Enron VP, Thomas White Wants Gov't Funding For New Energy Project
  June 8, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Imposing minority views
  June 8, 2005
  Stephen Crockett

When is Someone Going to Toss Rumsfeld into a Cage?
  June 8, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Republicans: The Anti-Christian, Christian Party
  June 8, 2005
  Stephen Crockett

Watergate Proves That Even Presidents Will Break Laws To Achieve Goals
  June 1, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Oral Histories of the 1970 Kent State Shootings
  May 22, 2005
  Candi Clevenger, Communications Manager, OhioLINK

Blurb: End the filibuster -- in 2015
  May 20, 2005
  Paul Loeb

The Beginning Of The End Of The Age Of Reason
  May 16, 2005
  Todd Huffman, M.D.

Nuking Democracy
  May 14, 2005
  Paul Loeb

Conscientious Objection on Trial: The Court Martial of Keith Benderman
  May 10, 2005
  Kevin B. Zeese

Barnum on Steroids
  May 9, 2005
  Jason Miller

Mother’s Day Without Mom
  May 7, 2005
  Phil Tajitsu Nash

An Open Letter to Howard Dean
  May 5, 2005
  Dennis J. Kucinich

Appeals Court Nominee Janice Rogers Brown Merits the Filibuster
  May 3, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

Activists Spur Historic Call to Exit Iraq
  April 24, 2005
  William Rivers Pitt

John Bolton & the Battle for Reality
  April 24, 2005
  Robert Parry

Videos expose false arrests at 2004 Republican Convention protests in New York
  April 24, 2005
  Peter Daniels

Wal-Mart's Free Market Fallacy
  April 24, 2005
  Jonathan Tasini

Howard Dean Becomes Leader of the Other Pro-War Party; Dean on Iraq: “We're There and We Can't Get Out”
  April 24, 2005
  Kevin Zeese

You have to pick your team
  April 20, 2005
  Sonya Vetra Tinsley, as told to Paul Rogat Loeb

What They Should Fight For
  April 20, 2005
  David Swanson

Vigilante Republicans
  April 13, 2005
  Steven Rosenfeld

Congresswoman Cynthia Mckinney Urges Reform of Voting Process at Historic Conference
  April 12, 2005
  Anna Thompson

Abortion and Schiavo -- The stories we tell
  April 5, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

How and Why We're Working to Block the Bankruptcy Bill
  April 1, 2005
  David Swanson

Statement on the Passing of Terri Schiavo
  March 31, 2005
  Reverend Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.

Veterans for peace call for Congressional action to impeach George W. Bush and Richard Cheney
  March 30, 2005
  Veterans For Peace

Zealot and Proud of It
  March 27, 2005
  Jason Miller

Non Volunteers, Non-Recruiters, And A Non War
  March 19, 2005
  Eric Straatsma

Meet Your New FCC Chairman: Kevin Martin
  March 17, 2005
  David Bailey

E.P.A. Nominee Supports Testing of Chemicals on Human Subjects
  March 11, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

A luncheon break with Michael Jackson
  March 11, 2005
  Robert Lockwood Mills

Gannongate and Asian Pacific America
  March 9, 2005
  Phil Tajitsu Nash

I'd rather not say good-bye, Dan
  March 9, 2005
  Greg Palast

Free Trade and Frivolous Lawsuits
  March 7, 2005
  Cyril Mychalejko

Experiencing Hunter, Experiencing Death: A Eulogy
  February 28, 2005
  Tom Luffman

The inevitability trap
  February 18, 2005
  K.C. Golden

Bush’s Judicial Nominations are Hardly Mainstream
  February 17, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

Senators Clinton and Boxer, Representative Tubbs Jones and others unveil major election reform bill
  February 17, 2005
  Offices of Sen. Clinton and Rep. Tubb Jones

The difference between bi-partisanship and non-partisanship
  February 15, 2005
  Robert Lockwood Mills

Bush & the Rise of 'Managed-Democracy'
  February 13, 2005
  Robert Parry

Yesterday's Gallup Poll Showing Bush Approval At 57% Had 9% More Republicans Than Democrats
  February 12, 2005
  Steve Soto

J20 Through my eyes
  February 11, 2005
  Ryan Mishler

Bush's Budget: The War on Working People Continues
  February 11, 2005
  International Action Center staff

Bush’s Budget is at Odds With His Rhetoric
  February 11, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

Direct Action For Peace?
  February 7, 2005
  Bill Scheurer

State of the Union speech falls short, says Rev. Jesse Jackson
  February 3, 2005
  Rev. Jesse Jackson, Rainbow/PUSH Coalition

The Black Perspective
  February 3, 2005
  Judith Powell

Save American Democracy: Curb Corporate Power
  January 29, 2005
  Stephen Crockett

Who's Paying for all this Freedom?
  January 29, 2005
  Darryl Cramer

Yes, there is a crisis in Social Security
  January 29, 2005
  Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.

Agitation Time
  January 25, 2005
  Ted Glick

The 10 Worst Corporations of 2004
  January 25, 2005
  Russell Mokhiber and Robert Weissman

They Doth Protest Too Little
  January 24, 2005
  Chris Colin

Thousands take to the streets to oppose the inauguration of George W. Bush
  January 24, 2005
  troopsoutnow.org

A Warm Oasis in a Snow Storm; The Progressive Democrat Summit in Washington
  January 24, 2005
  Cynthia L. Butler, Esq.

The Politics of SpongeBob
  January 23, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

Mis-Defining Terrorism
  January 20, 2005
  John Janney

Marines stretching movement
  January 19, 2005
  Mike Ferner

Bush’s Mythical Mandate and Social Security Piratization
  January 19, 2005
   Stephen Crockett and Al Lawrence

Happy Birthday Martin Luther King, Jr.
  January 16, 2005
  Chuck Zlatkin

Bush’s Choice for Energy Secretary Was One of Texas’ Top Five Worst Polluters
  January 16, 2005
  Jason Leopold

Bush, God, Fox, and the International Criminal Court
  January 13, 2005
  David Swanson

The real reason Bush wants to privatize Social Security
  January 12, 2005
  Robert Lockwood Mills

CBS' cowardice and conflicts behind purge
  January 11, 2005
  Greg Palast

Bring them home -- Sooner rather than later
  January 1, 2005
  Sheila Samples




Read National Issues Articles by Year:
2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000



FREE PRESS EMAIL UPDATE


Donate to the Free Press Election Protection Fund to help us investigate and monitor election fraud in this year's election.


Donate to The Free Press The Free Press Store

FOLLOW US ON
twitter
facebook


SEARCH THE FREEPRESS




1021 E. Broad St. Columbus, OH 43205 | 614.253.2571 | truth@freepress.org
All content © 1970-2012 The Columbus Free Press
Disclaimer