 |
Wed Aug 20 2008 | |||||||||
|
||||||||||
|
Departments National Issues Shushing the big money by Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services June 26, 2006 In the old monarchies of Europe, the resident populace were known as subjects. Here in the New World, where mankind started over, we're citizens, a word that pulses with self-governing power. This is pretty scary, and there's plenty of pressure on us not to take this role literally. Democracy is dangerous, after all. It's always a threat to those in power. This is why its expansion over the last 230 years - through abolitionism, trade unionism, women's suffrage, the civil rights movement - has never come without struggle and controversy. But where democracy is healthy, this is what citizens do: expand the terrain. Welcome to Humboldt County, Calif., a largely rural county 250 miles north of San Francisco where democracy is healthy indeed, and where, thanks to a citizens' initiative called Measure T, which passed at the beginning of the month with 55 percent of the vote, local governance has asserted itself in the face of the threat of Big Money disguised as just another neighbor exercising his right to free speech. Measure T took on the weird concept known as "corporate personhood," a legal fiction bequeathed to us from the robber-baron era of the late 19th century, in which corporations managed to gain legal standing as "persons," with inherent rights that can't be abridged by law, just as human beings have, rather than mere court-granted privileges. This abomination is democracy's equivalent of "Attack of the Killer Robots." When business conglomerates (unlike any other organized group) have constitutionally guaranteed rights and protections, their interests will swamp ours. For instance, of the first 150 cases heard by the Supreme Court involving the 14th Amendment, which requires states to provide equal protection under the law to all persons within their jurisdiction, and for which the Civil War was fought, only 15 cases concerned former slaves; the other 135 were about the rights of business entities. As Thom Hartmann has noted, "Unlike you and me, when large corporations 'speak' they can use a billion-dollar bullhorn." This is the sort of deafening noise that began raining down on Humboldt County recently. Twice in the last seven years, large, out-of-state corporations attempted to trample local rule by throwing money around and posing as "players" in local politics. In 1999, Wal-Mart poured $250,000 into an effort to change the city of Eureka's zoning laws so it could plunk down one of its giant retail boxes on 30 acres of waterfront. Then in 2004, MAXXAM Inc., a Texas-based forest products company, launched a recall campaign against local District Attorney Paul Gallegos, who had the temerity to try to enforce environmental regulations on the company's operations in the county. MAXXAM spent $300,000 to get him out of office. Both assaults on local rule were unsuccessful, but residents were appalled that the shenanigans were possible at all. And on June 6, following a heated campaign spearheaded by an organization appropriately called Democracy Unlimited of Humboldt County, with the enthusiastic participation of the local Green and Democratic parties as well as area labor unions, voters across the political spectrum passed Measure T, which prohibits non-local corporations from spending so much as a penny to influence a local election. The penalties on companies that play unwarranted politics range from fines (10 times the amount of money inappropriately contributed, to be paid to Humboldt County) to revocation of their charter to do business in California. "This is bigger than a legal challenge - it's broader and deeper," said David Cobb of Democracy Unlimited (who was also the Green Party presidential candidate in 2004). "We're talking about a culture shift. We're challenging people to ask who rules this country - unaccountable corporations or we the people?" Now that's patriotism - of the proud, defiant, "don't tread on me" variety. And where citizen involvement is noisy and vibrant, elections will be about issues of substance and consequence, not about, as it so often seems, as little as possible. Measure T reads in part (under "Findings and General Purpose"): "In a Democratic Republic all legitimate political power is held by the people, and government exercises just power only with the consent of the governed. The people create their government for their protection and benefit, and retain their right to alter their government whenever they deem the public good requires it. "Only natural persons (human beings, in other words) possess civil and political rights." Cobb told me he thinks Measure T is only the third U.S. law that has ever challenged corporate personhood, and the first to deal with campaign financing and to result from a citizens' initiative. So far, he said, organizers have heard from about a dozen communities since the election, wanting to know how they stood up to Big Money. He is hopeful there will be more. (The organization can be reached via www.duhc.org.) The influence of corporate money is so pervasive, most of us are probably surprised it can be challenged at all. Well, it can be. And Measure T may be a beachhead in a long campaign to bring corporate power down to its appropriate political size. --- Robert Koehler, an award-winning, Chicago-based journalist, is an editor at Tribune Media Services and nationally syndicated writer. You can respond to this column at bkoehler@tribune.com or visit his Web site at commonwonders.com. © 2006 Tribune Media Services, Inc. Email this article to a friend |
Don't forget to check out articles from 2007 and 2008
"The ethics of Palestinian resistance"
December 31, 2006
David Swanson
"And the Empire Mourned . . . Dissecting the Big Lie"
December 30, 2006
Jason Miller
"A 'vast carelessness' - the president's and ours"
December 30, 2006
Peter Schrag, Sacramento Bee
"Gerald Ford’s historic mistake"
December 30, 2006
Stephen Crockett
"New year's utopianism needed fast"
December 27, 2006
David Swanson
"Obama scores as exotic who says nothing"
December 27, 2006
Froma Harrop
"Ignorant armies"
December 24, 2006
Robert C. Koehler
"The GOP, butterflies' wings and the withering of empire: could your climax be the decider? If you don't try, you'll never know"
December 22, 2006
James Heddle
"Announcement of candidacy for President of the United States"
December 18, 2006
Dennis Kucinich
"Call me Ebenezer, but Christmas as we know it needs to go....."
December 17, 2006
Jason Miller
"Intolerable questions: the search for the heart of New Orleans, part II"
December 12, 2006
Tom Luffman
"Dear Mr. O’Reilly, THIS is culture: the search for the heart of New Orleans, part III"
December 12, 2006
Tom Luffman
"Hillary Clinton and my Visa bill"
December 12, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"The Tin Man Challenge: Overcoming technology without Heart "
December 11, 2006
Paul Lamb
"Bread, bread, everywhere, yet not a morsel to eat"
December 11, 2006
Jason Miller
"O come let us adore them: treasuring our American values of greed, self-interest, and enlightened oppression"
December 6, 2006
Ragnar Redbeard, III
"Blood fatigue"
November 30, 2006
Robert C. Koehler
"Blind obedience to the canons of capitalism: of sick societies, American Dalits, and a nation of Lady Macbeths "
November 26, 2006
Jason Miller
"The peace majority"
November 22, 2006
Robert C. Koehler
"U.S. v. Bush"
November 22, 2006
David Swanson
"Milton lost: can we regain paradise?"
November 22, 2006
Jason Miller
"Progressive caucus rising: this election was no victory for centrists"
November 10, 2006
Nick Burt and Joel Bleifuss
"Rumsfield replacement (Robert Gates) was director of voting company"
November 9, 2006
Bev Harris
"Is there meth in Ted Haggard's heaven?"
November 5, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"The politics of hope"
October 24, 2006
Todd Huffman
"Corrode your conformity: Big Brother doesn't practice fraternal love"
October 22, 2006
Jason Miller
"Grassroots matching grants: my five minutes as a donor"
October 19, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"The trek down to N’Orleans: home to hotel in a couple of bounds: the search for the heart of New Orleans, part I"
October 18, 2006
Tom Luffman
"Peace Activists Arrested on Grounds of U.S. Capitol"
October 18, 2006
David Swanson
"Foley's meltdown - the seductions of clicking"
October 15, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"Naked and afraid"
October 11, 2006
Robert C. Koehler
"Piercing the simulacrum: Of faux democracy, petty tyrants, and painful realities"
October 10, 2006
Jason Miller
"The genius of John Nichols"
October 9, 2006
David Swanson
"The arrogant, the misguided, and the cowards"
October 4, 2006
Sean Penn
"Mommy, what's waterboarding?"
September 30, 2006
David Swanson
"Nuclear winter, global warming, or impeachment"
September 23, 2006
David Swanson
"Here's why it's personal"
September 20, 2006
Cynthia L. Butler, Esq.
"Reclaiming Omelas"
September 20, 2006
Robert C. Koehler
"The brilliantly profitable timing of the Alaska oil pipeline shutdown"
September 17, 2006
Greg Palast
"My city, our president and exploiting 9/11"
September 15, 2006
MediaBloodhound
"Palast charged with journalism in the first degree"
September 11, 2006
Greg Palast
"9-11 compromise - the mini-series"
September 10, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"The fugitive girl act"
August 29, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"The year the levees broke"
August 29, 2006
Greg Palast
"Semper why?"
August 24, 2006
Robert C. Koehler
"The smell of fear"
August 17, 2006
Robert C. Koehler
"Cynthia McKinney's election night remarks"
August 15, 2006
Congresswoman Cynthia McKinney
"Bush versus the Constitution"
August 15, 2006
David Swanson
"The Lamont victory -- next steps for citizens"
August 10, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"Bush heir cut: Awards tax break to son of an Astor"
August 1, 2006
Greg Palast
"Where were you when they took your rights away?"
July 29, 2006
David Swanson
"Chicago City Council passes living wage bill"
July 26, 2006
Free Press staff
"Conservatives and conscience"
July 22, 2006
David Swanson
"They don't call it the "White" House for nothing"
July 22, 2006
Greg Palast
"Kansas Attorney General is Bush’s kind of guy"
July 16, 2006
Gene C. Gerard
"Containing the military industrial complex"
July 16, 2006
David Swanson
"Kinks among us: contemplations on pride and democracy"
July 16, 2006
Rady Ananda
"Republican Congressman says Bush should be removed from office"
July 13, 2006
David Swanson
"It's time Democrats aggressively play the terrorism card"
July 10, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"Cindy Sheehan to move Camp to National Mall"
July 7, 2006
David Swanson
"Joe Lieberman's loyalties"
July 7, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"So much for "We'll Get bin Laden Dead or Alive""
July 5, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"The Supreme Court issues a stinging blow to Bush. Score one for the little guy."
July 1, 2006
The Ostoy Report
"Has this country gone completely insane?"
July 1, 2006
Mike Ferner
"A line in the sand: why the Busby/Bilbray election and their voting machine "sleepovers" matter (or should) to the entire nation"
June 27, 2006
Brad Friedman
"Bush at the tipping point: a lawless and incompetent leadership"
June 26, 2006
Ralph Nader
"Shushing the big money"
June 26, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"The startling contrast betweeen Dems and Repugs this fall"
June 18, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"The strange case of San Diego's: lazy independents, self-destructive Minutemen, and closet Libertarian, voters"
June 14, 2006
Ron Baiman
"Support the troops"
June 13, 2006
Sheila Samples
"Gathering to demand the truth about 9/11"
June 11, 2006
Mike Ferner
"Building green websites"
June 11, 2006
Phil Tajitsu Nash
"Nine state Democratic parties back impeachment: Whose table is it, Nancy?"
June 11, 2006
David Swanson
"Photo essay: Poverty and homelessness in San Francisco"
June 10, 2006
Free Press staff
"Safe passage on the Earth"
June 9, 2006
David Swanson
"Why John Kerry is going to have it tougher the second time around"
June 6, 2006
Cynthia L. Butler, Esq.
"Eleven excellent reasons not to join the military"
June 6, 2006
David Swanson
"Another Swiss cheese Gore denial that leaves the door wide open for 2008. Who's he kidding?"
June 6, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"Bush pal says gay marriage is nothing more than a political issue for the Prez"
June 6, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"American capitalism and the moral poverty of nations"
June 6, 2006
Jason Miller
"Twenty-fifth anniversary of first reported case of AIDS a time to recommit to the fight"
June 5, 2006
Brad Luna and Jay Smith Brown
"Uproar downwind"
June 2, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"Last Call"
June 2, 2006
Alan Woods
"FTC and credit reporting reform -- or the next wave of multi-district national class actions"
May 29, 2006
Cynthia L. Butler, Esq.
"Lay convicted, Bush walks (and Ahnold gets Lay'd)"
May 28, 2006
Greg Palast, Special For Truthout
"Used the phone lately? Worried?"
May 28, 2006
William Fisher
"Enron's good fight"
May 27, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"So, how WOULD a Patriot Act?"
May 25, 2006
David Swanson
"Shadow America"
May 25, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"When Ahnold Got Lay'd…and California got Screwed"
May 25, 2006
Greg Palast
"Blocking justice"
May 15, 2006
William Fisher
"Fighting back in the language war and winning elections"
May 15, 2006
Kirk Muse
"Immigration: Myths and Reality"
May 15, 2006
Reverend Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.
"Let's raise gas taxes and lower income taxes"
May 15, 2006
Lester R. Brown
"Bush beats out Nixon: Least liked President ever"
May 15, 2006
David Swanson
"The spies who shag us: The Times and USA Today have Missed the Bigger Story -- Again"
May 14, 2006
Greg Palast
"Divine strake"
May 11, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"Divine strake"
May 11, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"RNC attack on John Conyers demands action from Democrats"
May 8, 2006
David Swanson
"Act now, pray later"
May 7, 2006
Frank Scott
"Impeach Cheney first"
May 5, 2006
David Swanson
"Crossing the border"
May 5, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"The Bush administration and Wall Street – Two peas in a pod"
May 2, 2006
Robert Lockwood Mills
"The "New Totalitarianism" now defines a desperate neo-con end game"
May 1, 2006
Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman
"Rove's status as "Official A" spells indictment"
April 28, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"The FEMA gap"
April 27, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"Have a Koch and a smile: free markets and property rights Trump humanity and the environment!"
April 27, 2006
Jason Miller
"We are the deciders"
April 25, 2006
Sheila Samples
"Out of the shadows -- the Seattle immigration march"
April 14, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"The beloved Cynthia McKinney: a White ex-cop speaks out about a Georgia Congresswoman"
April 14, 2006
Michael C. Ruppert
"An interview with fifteen term Congressman Andy Jacobs"
April 14, 2006
Kevin Zeese
"A Message from Dennis Kucinich"
April 14, 2006
Dennis Kucinich
"Democracy be damned - Republicans need another war"
April 14, 2006
Thom Hartmann
"Loser nation"
April 14, 2006
Greg Palast
"Censure movement catching fire"
April 10, 2006
Stephen Crockett
"Gangster government: a leaky president afoul of 'Little Rico'"
April 10, 2006
Greg Palast
"The real problem with Bush's leak"
April 10, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"Public energy is misdirected"
April 7, 2006
David Swanson
"An interview with Norman Birnbaum"
April 7, 2006
Kevin Zeese
"What’s really scary about the “new religious right” and their politics"
March 29, 2006
Marj Creech
"Fitzgerald will seek new White House indictments"
March 29, 2006
Jason Leopold
"Housing cuts for the poor, tax cuts for the rich"
March 27, 2006
Gene C. Gerard
"The definition of insanity"
March 23, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"House leader not home when peace knocks"
March 23, 2006
Mike Ferner
"Just a Thought"
March 23, 2006
Uke Man
"Americans call Bush "Incompetent, Idiot, Liar""
March 20, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"Most Democratic senators fail as presidential candidates"
March 19, 2006
Stephen Crockett and Al Lawrence
"The age of anxiety redux"
March 19, 2006
William Fisher
"National Lawyers Guild calls for the impeachment of South Dokota Governor Michael Rounds for signing anti-abortion legislation"
March 19, 2006
Michael Avery
"Libby attorneys identify CIA officials in Plame leak"
March 19, 2006
Jason Leopold
"True to its history, FBI is still violating civil liberties"
March 19, 2006
Gene C. Gerard
"On the executive branch and war powers, continued"
March 19, 2006
populistamerica.com
"Obstruction trial may jog Libby's memory"
March 18, 2006
Jason Leopold
"A powerful new voting block emerges: The anti-war movement becoming a political force that cannot be ignored"
March 18, 2006
Kevin Zeese
"Beating a dead horse"
March 17, 2006
Blair Bobier
"Did Bush make mistakes in good faith?"
March 14, 2006
David Swanson
"Hungering for justice at my first congressional testimony"
March 14, 2006
Mike Ferner
"You know it’s hard out here being pimped: Thoughts Hustlin’ and Flowin’ in my mind"
March 14, 2006
Ernie McCray
"Chicago pro-immigrant, anti-HR4437 rally"
March 12, 2006
Free Press staff
"CIA leak path: Cheney, Libby, Woodward"
March 8, 2006
Jason Leopold
"Detroit's other Super Bowl "
March 8, 2006
Brian McKenna
"Carnival Post-Katrina"
March 8, 2006
Dave Lewis
"Port insecurities"
March 8, 2006
James Mehrle
"In the spirit of Lysistrata"
March 8, 2006
Lucinda Marshall
"Details emerge in latest round of plame emails ‘found’ by the White House"
March 3, 2006
Jason Leopold
"15 arrested at White House torture protest"
March 3, 2006
Mike Ferner
"Bush and Gandhi"
March 3, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"NY Times bungles coverage of AP video which proves Bush lied about breached levees"
March 3, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"White House ‘discovers’ 250 emails related to Plame leak"
February 26, 2006
Jason Leopold
"Time to disband Homeland security and renew democracy"
February 26, 2006
Stephen Crockett
"Huge march planned for eve of Katrina evictions"
February 26, 2006
David Swanson
"Bush violated the law on port sale"
February 24, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"Check your conscience at the door: we're building an empire "
February 21, 2006
Jason Miller
"NSC, Cheney aides conspired to out CIA operative"
February 21, 2006
Jason Leopold
"Bush, Republicans, and Judas Priest: Breaking the law, breaking the law"
February 19, 2006
August Keso
"For whom does the Secret Service's bell toll?"
February 19, 2006
Robert Lockwood Mills
"Guns don't shoot people--Vice Presidents do"
February 19, 2006
Daniel Patrick Welch
"Impeachment could be the Democrats' best get-out-the-vote message"
February 19, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"DINO stands for "Democrats In Name Only""
February 19, 2006
Josh Mitteldorf
"Founding Fathers, baseball, apple pie, and impeachment"
February 19, 2006
David Swanson
"Road to peace goes through Santa Cruz"
February 19, 2006
David Swanson
"Pogo was right"
February 19, 2006
Lucinda Marshall
"The Republican talk radio “big lie”"
February 19, 2006
Stephen Crockett
"Gonzales withholding Plame emails"
February 17, 2006
Jason Leopold
"The Nader effect"
February 16, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"The most incredible thing about Cheney's shooting"
February 14, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"The polite majority"
February 14, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"Debating impeachment among Democrats"
February 14, 2006
David Swanson
"Removing Attorney General Gonzales"
February 14, 2006
Stephen Crockett
"What really happened back at the ranch"
February 14, 2006
Richard Hayes Phillips
"The Bush pattern of deception continues"
February 13, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"Cheney spearheaded effort to discredit Wilson"
February 11, 2006
Jason Leopold
"Give peace a vote"
February 9, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"What every Jew should know about new House Majority Leader John Boehner"
February 6, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"New discoveries about the Lucasville uprising"
February 6, 2006
Attorney Staughton Lynd
"Brown calls President's '07 budget "morally reprehensible""
February 6, 2006
Ben Wikler
"U.S. detention camps for political subversives"
February 5, 2006
Paul Joseph Watson
"Bring regime change home"
February 5, 2006
David Swanson
"Evolution is intelligently designed: Social Darwinism, silver spoons, and our emperor’s call to arms to sustain the rich"
February 5, 2006
Jason Miller
"Cindy Sheehan terrorizes Bush and his trained clapping seals at the State of Disunion speech"
February 3, 2006
Special by Ben Hooked, Historical Science Fictionists from the Planet Alpha-Omega 1,2,3
""Fixed" intelligence from Feith's "Gestapo Office" the CIA and the Bush administration's impeachable lies about Iraq's prewar links to al Qaeda"
February 3, 2006
Walter C. Uhler
"Enron: The Bush Administration's first scandal"
February 2, 2006
Jason Leopold
"What an idiot!"
February 2, 2006
Daniel Patrick Welch
"Being a national activist"
February 2, 2006
David Swanson
"Responses to State of the Union Address"
February 2, 2006
Institute for Public Accuracy
"The State of the Union: Blah, blah, blah (Yawn)"
February 1, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"Bush & Cheney Are The Great "Protectors?" Give Us a F***king Break"
January 31, 2006
The Ostroy Report
"Rev. Jesse Jackson mourns Coretta Scott King"
January 31, 2006
Rainbow/PUSH Coalition
"What we didn't hear tonight"
January 30, 2006
Governor Howard Dean, M.D.
"Eggs Roll, Eyes Roll"
January 27, 2006
John Ireland
"Unfathomed dangers in Patriot Act reauthorization"
January 26, 2006
Paul Craig Roberts
"Halliburton's Sleeze"
January 26, 2006
Nancy Khoury
"Relevant Saint"
January 26, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"Alito and Roberts: Evasion Confirmed"
January 24, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"Open letter to members of the US Senate Judiciary Committee"
January 20, 2006
Program on Corporations, Law and Democracy (POCLAD)
"How Dick Cheney used the NSA for domestic spying pre-9/11"
January 20, 2006
Jason Leopold
"The war on dissent gets creepy"
January 20, 2006
Mike Ferner
"The polite majority"
January 19, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"NASA ready for the worst, response will be prompt if Atlas 5 explodes"
January 18, 2006
Todd Halvorson, Florida Today
"Woolsey's way to peace"
January 18, 2006
David Swanson
"Bush and Republicans vs. rule of law"
January 16, 2006
Stephen Crockett
"Dr. King: Drum Major for Justice"
January 16, 2006
Rev. Jesse Jackson
"Filibuster Bush, impeach Alito"
January 15, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"Filibuster evasion"
January 15, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"Poll: Americans support impeaching Bush for wiretapping"
January 15, 2006
Bob Fertik
"Birth of awareness"
January 12, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"Anti-war group has documents proving NSA spied on them"
January 12, 2006
Kevin Zeese
"Pants on Fire: The Liars of the Bush Administration will take the world down in flames if we let them"
January 12, 2006
Daniel Patrick Welch
"Fitzgerald maintains focus on Rove but attorney says 'Architect' not a target"
January 11, 2006
Jason Leopold
"It's been a long trek since Nov. 2, 2004 -- now getting shorter"
January 11, 2006
Robert Lockwood Mills
"Man of the Year: Patrick Fitzgerald"
January 10, 2006
Gerald Rellick
"Another unqualified Bush appointment"
January 10, 2006
Gene C. Gerard
"A peace movement demanding the rule of law"
January 10, 2006
David Swanson
"On Martin Luther King Day: giving ourselves to the struggle"
January 7, 2006
Todd Huffman, M.D.
"Forum with Congressmen Moran and Murtha packs hall, 500 turned away"
January 7, 2006
David Swanson
"Primal smirk"
January 4, 2006
Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services
"A new year’s message from Ramsey Clark"
January 4, 2006
Ramsey Clark
"Extraordinary circumstances indeed"
January 3, 2006
Paul Rogat Loeb
"ImpeachPAC forms Citizens Impeachment Commission"
January 2, 2006
ImpeachPAC
"Go to the light!"
January 1, 2006
Sheila Samples
"Can Cheney save Bush's presidency?"
January 1, 2006
David Swanson
Read Articles by Year:
2007 2006 2005 2004
2003 2002 2001 2000
All content © 1970-2008
The Columbus Free Press
Disclaimer