The Free Press -- Independent News Media

Fri Mar 19 2010

Departments
National Issues

Trading press events for votes: What should press do?
by David Swanson
June 24, 2009

On Tuesday my local newspaper reported on an event here in town on Monday. House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer had come down to Charlottesville and spoken publicly with local Congressman Tom Perriello, generating a story and big color photo on page 1 of the Charlottesville Daily Progress. The headline was "In UVa visit, Democrats call deficit reckless."

The newspaper reported on Congressman Perriello warning that he could not vote for healthcare without a way to pay for it. There was no mention of the fact that the previous week, the day before Hoyer introduced his bill to fight deficits, both of these gentlemen had voted to spend another $97 billion on wars and to loan $100 billion to European bankers through the International Monetary Fund (IMF). Nobody in Washington had even hinted at where any of that money would come from, and apparently Hoyer and Perriello didn't care.

The article did include a quote from a Republican blaming Democrats for deficits. But that's doubly bad reporting. Republicans have pushed deficits up far more than Democrats, and just getting a haphazard (and inaccurate) quote from "the other side" misses the relevant context of the war supplemental vote. Here's the patently false quote from Congressman Eric Cantor:

"We've amassed more debt over the last five months than this country has amassed in the last 200 years."

Also on Tuesday in Charlottesville, two top environmental officials from the White House, Van Jones and Nancy Sutley, staged a press conference with Congressman Perriello. Oddly, there was no particular news to announce at the press conference. Predictably, all the media outlets were there to trumpet the story anyway.

Awfully nice of Hoyer, Jones, and Sutley to make the trip down from Washington, wouldn't you say? Three big shots in two days, with -- for all I know -- more to come. (I'm predicting an event in the southern part of the district with a top military official, but that's just my prediction.)

The local media in Virginia's Fifth District reports on these press events as ordinary press events, which is a far more serious problem than just the shoddy reporting style.

It had been widely reported in Washington last week that the House Democratic leadership and the White House were offering all variety of favors and threats to Congress members to win their votes for the war/IMF bill. This fact was not mentioned in any of the local reporting on the PR stunts.

Perriello claims to have opposed the IMF section of the war supplemental bill despite voting for the bill as a whole. Why, then, did he vote for it rather than joining all the Republicans in the House in voting against it (five of them changed their votes to Yes once the bill had passed)? Among the Democrats, 32 voted No, and 39 would have been needed to defeat the legislation. Why was Perriello willing to set himself up for the television ads that will likely air a year from now accusing him of giving $100 billion to foreigners and possibly terrorists (a crazy accusation, but not one the Daily Progress can be expected to fact check)? Was it just the $1 million the Democratic party in Washington gave his campaign in advertsing at the last minute to elect him by a fraction of a percentage point (and the promise of providing that funding again)? Or were there other things traded?

I don't know what, if any, favors Perriello was offered for his vote. I support cutting deficits and creating green jobs. But isn't it the job of the press to at least ASK whether our representative in Congress is representing us or the leaders of a political party? And if deals go down in Washington in which press events are traded for votes, should members of the press play along?

If you were a reporter and suspected that the PR stunt you were "reporting" on was very likely part of a deal to win a vote for war and bank bailouts, would you mention that circumstance? Would you perhaps refuse to cover the "event" at all? Would you choose to cover the deficit and green jobs events but report separately on the vote-whipping and partisan corruption? Or would you simply sit back and allow yourself to be played like a cheap ukelele?

---
David Swanson is the author of the upcoming book "Daybreak: Undoing the Imperial Presidency and Forming a More Perfect Union" by Seven Stories Press. You can pre-order it and find out when tour will be in your town: http://davidswanson.org/book

Email this article to a friend

Don't forget to check out articles from 2009 and 2010

National Issues

"McCain could have meant Less War"
December 31, 2009
David Swanson

"Healthcare mandate vs. the Constitution"
December 24, 2009
David Swanson

"A healthy economy"
December 24, 2009
Robert C. Koehler

"Apostle of our inner genius"
December 17, 2009
Robert C. Koehler

"Wars or jobs: decide now"
December 14, 2009
David Swanson

"Are Americans Too Broken for the Truth to Set Us Free?"
December 13, 2009
Bruce E. Levine

"The school-to-prison pipeline"
December 11, 2009
Robert C. Koehler

"Kucinich circulating privileged resolutions to end wars in Afghanistan and Pakistan"
December 10, 2009
David Swanson

"National security state still killing John F Kennedy"
December 7, 2009
Pete Johnson

"Richard Viguerie calls GOP litmus tests "Well intentioned," but urges replacement of Republican establishment leaders"
December 3, 2009
Bob Sturm

"Craziest Obavietghanistan speech moments "
December 2, 2009
David Swanson

"New civil resistance coalition formed to end the war"
December 1, 2009
Cindy Sheehan

"Anti-Americans"
November 24, 2009
Christopher Bifani

"Why can't we do to DC what we did to Seattle? "
November 19, 2009
David Swanson

"They should get a union"
November 17, 2009
David Swanson

"KSM and MSM"
November 17, 2009
David Swanson

"The two percent robustness"
November 15, 2009
David Swanson

"Between hate speech and adoration"
November 15, 2009
David Swanson

"Pelosi arrested us for asking for healthcare"
November 15, 2009
Dan Hodges, Chair, Health Care for All-California

"Over 2,200 veterans died in 2008 due to lack of health insurance "
November 15, 2009
Physicians for a National Health Program

"Isolated incident"
November 15, 2009
Robert C. Koehler

"Come together right now"
November 15, 2009
David Swanson

"Joel Peresman of the Rock Hall Foundation says the time has come today "
November 4, 2009
Harvey Wasserman

"Between hate speech and adoration"
November 2, 2009
David Swanson

"Preview of Ramzy Baroud's 'My Father was a Freedom Fighter'"
October 29, 2009
Stephen Lendman

"Why I am risking arrest for Medicare for all "
October 29, 2009
Margaret Flowers, M.D., Congressional Fellow, Physicians for a National Health Program

"Single-eye vision"
October 29, 2009
Robert C. Koehler

"Did Obama/McCain choice matter?"
October 28, 2009
David Swanson

"No one else will stop the killing -- Veteran's group to members: Multiply resistance by any peaceful means available "
October 27, 2009
Mike Ferner

"Accepting the prize"
October 26, 2009
Robert C. Koehler

"Glen Ford speaks in Columbus"
October 26, 2009
Free Press

"Heavy Traffic"
October 23, 2009
Terence Robertson

"Who SHOULD Decide About War?"
October 14, 2009
By David Swanson

"Starting Another Year of War in Afghanistan"
October 14, 2009
Norman Solomon

"Congress must pass single-payer health care now! "
September 30, 2009
Cynthia McKinney

"U.S. Drug War Priorities in Need of Re-Evaluation"
September 16, 2009
Mary Jane Borden

"Senator Kennedy visits then Cleveland City Councilman"
August 26, 2009
Representative Dennis Kucinich

"Govt-funded reporter urged lynching of Black Congresswoman"
August 24, 2009
David Swanson