Departments
If media were any good
by David Swanson
July 22, 2009
A week ago, I published a report on 1,200 photos of U.S. torture that I have examined but the public at large has not seen. I talked about the photos on a few progressive radio shows. I received calls from some advocacy groups that have been trying for years to get hold of these photos. But I received not one single inquiry from the corporate media. Even most good blogs ignored this story despite a handful of prominent blogs promoting it. This started me thinking and fantasizing: what would the world look like if we had major media outlets that were worth more than a warm bucket of spit?
Imagine if the media monopolies were busted, a diversity of private outlets were free to compete, and public media were developed, including free substantive air time for election campaigns. Imagine media outlets with democratic accountability. Imagine media outlets that judged a story important if the majority of the public said so, and not if those in power said so.
The majority of the public favors single-payer healthcare. Corporate media outlets are crammed with endless, often pointless, stories about healthcare that never mention single-payer. On Friday a House committee passed an amendment to allow states to create single-payer healthcare systems, and have you heard about that from a single corporate media outlet? Another amendment now up for a vote would create single-payer at the national level. Heard that one mentioned? Our existing media outlets (whose lead blogs follow more than bloggers admit to themselves) decide what's important based on the preferences of a small number of powerful people. And the fact that these preferences almost always differ wildly from majority opinion does not lead to any rethinking of the acceptability of this approach in a democratic republic.
The same treatment is accorded other people around the world by the U.S. media. Over in Iraq (remember that place?) an important deadline is approaching in the treaty that Bush and Maliki made, and which Bush misleadingly called a status of forces agreement in order to not call it a treaty. The U.S. Senate never consented to this treaty, was never asked to, and never demanded the right. But the Iraqi Parliament, which represented a public whose media -- even in the midst of a living hell -- better informed it of the treaty's terms than ours did, approved the treaty. But the parliament approved the treaty only on the condition that the Iraqi people be able to vote it up or down in a vote to be held no later than July 2009. Heard anything about this lately? Check your calendar, and then check your newspaper. What gives? If you could bring slaughtered native Americans back to life they could tell you the violations of their treaties were not heavily covered in the white man's press. The June deadline to withdraw from Iraqi cities was met in part by redrawing boundaries. Can you imagine the outrage if a foreign force did such a thing while occupying the United States? Some actions are deemed outrageous and others unworthy of extensive discussion. Some articles are written with that obnoxious air of "objectivity" while other articles are not written.
A democratic communications system that worked for the people rather than those in power, advertisers, and corporate partners would identify politicians by party and state but also by amount of money accepted from the corporations relevant to the issue under consideration. All the endless articles and chatter about healthcare would look different with the dollar figures inserted. A democratic media outlet would forego fluff and filler to engage in useful functions such as tracking whether elected officials fulfill their campaign promises, something I've done here and the St Petersburg Times has done here.
Democratic (small d) media would be very different from Democratic or Republican or Bipartisan media. It would treat laws as mandatory, not subject to the whims of those in power. It would treat enforcement of laws against those in power as more important than their enforcement against everyone else. Such media would not cover resistance to a war without noting that the war was (if it was) illegal. Such media would not cover the prosecution of low-level soldiers for crimes they were ordered to commit, without investigating their superiors and asking why they had not been prosecuted. Such media would not quote nonsensical statements by those in power about possibly investigating whether crimes had been committed without noting (when it existed) the publicly available evidence that in fact crimes had almost certainly been committed. And if a former vice president appeared on a democratic show and brazenly confessed to felonies, the producers would invite the attorney general to view the tape on the air and respond to it.
---
David Swanson is the author of the upcoming book "Daybreak: Undoing the Imperial Presidency and Forming a More Perfect Union" by Seven Stories Press. You can pre-order it and find out when tour will be in your town: http://davidswanson.org/book. Arrange to review it on your blog and Seven Stories will get you a free copy. Contact crystal at sevenstories dot com.
|
 |
Recent National Issues Articles
McCain could have meant Less War December 31, 2009 David Swanson
Healthcare mandate vs. the Constitution December 24, 2009 David Swanson
A healthy economy December 24, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Apostle of our inner genius December 17, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Wars or jobs: decide now December 14, 2009 David Swanson
Are Americans Too Broken for the Truth to Set Us Free? December 13, 2009 Bruce E. Levine
The school-to-prison pipeline December 11, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Kucinich circulating privileged resolutions to end wars in Afghanistan and Pakistan December 10, 2009 David Swanson
National security state still killing John F Kennedy December 7, 2009 Pete Johnson
Richard Viguerie calls GOP litmus tests "Well intentioned," but urges replacement of Republican establishment leaders December 3, 2009 Bob Sturm
Craziest Obavietghanistan speech moments December 2, 2009 David Swanson
New civil resistance coalition formed to end the war December 1, 2009 Cindy Sheehan
Anti-Americans November 24, 2009 Christopher Bifani
Why can't we do to DC what we did to Seattle? November 19, 2009 David Swanson
They should get a union November 17, 2009 David Swanson
KSM and MSM November 17, 2009 David Swanson
The two percent robustness November 15, 2009 David Swanson
Between hate speech and adoration November 15, 2009 David Swanson
Pelosi arrested us for asking for healthcare November 15, 2009 Dan Hodges, Chair, Health Care for All-California
Over 2,200 veterans died in 2008 due to lack of health insurance November 15, 2009 Physicians for a National Health Program
Isolated incident November 15, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Come together right now November 15, 2009 David Swanson
Joel Peresman of the Rock Hall Foundation says the time has come today November 4, 2009 Harvey Wasserman
Between hate speech and adoration November 2, 2009 David Swanson
Preview of Ramzy Baroud's 'My Father was a Freedom Fighter' October 29, 2009 Stephen Lendman
Why I am risking arrest for Medicare for all October 29, 2009 Margaret Flowers, M.D., Congressional Fellow, Physicians for a National Health Program
Single-eye vision October 29, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Did Obama/McCain choice matter? October 28, 2009 David Swanson
No one else will stop the killing -- Veteran's group to members: Multiply resistance by any peaceful means available October 27, 2009 Mike Ferner
Accepting the prize October 26, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Glen Ford speaks in Columbus October 26, 2009 Free Press
Heavy Traffic October 23, 2009 Terence Robertson
Who SHOULD Decide About War? October 14, 2009 By David Swanson
Starting Another Year of War in Afghanistan October 14, 2009 Norman Solomon
Congress must pass single-payer health care now! September 30, 2009 Cynthia McKinney
U.S. Drug War Priorities in Need of Re-Evaluation September 16, 2009 Mary Jane Borden
Senator Kennedy visits then Cleveland City Councilman August 26, 2009 Representative Dennis Kucinich
Govt-funded reporter urged lynching of Black Congresswoman August 24, 2009 David Swanson
HEALTH CARE WANTED: DEAD OR ALIVE August 20, 2009 Congressman Dennis Kucinich
Oligarchy rules the health care debate August 20, 2009 Pete Johnson
Six months of immunity August 7, 2009 David Swanson
Grand theft auto: how Stevie the Rat bankrupted GM August 7, 2009 Greg Palast
The perfect storm July 29, 2009 Don Ruben
The Joint Public-Option Single-Payer United Front July 29, 2009 David Swanson
Breaking sarcasm: Holder Joins Conyers in Demanding Action July 26, 2009 David Swanson
If media were any good July 22, 2009 David Swanson
I've Seen 1,200 Torture Photos July 22, 2009 david swanson
California should pay its people in pot July 9, 2009 “Thomas Paine”
How to trap a torture judge July 8, 2009 Cynthia Papermaster and Susan Harman, ImpeachBybee.org
A Campaign Proposal for Progressives* Two Ways to Pay As You Go July 8, 2009 David Swanson
Declaration of Indictment July 7, 2009 David Swanson
Remove the filibuster from the Senate rules July 7, 2009 David Swanson
The Emperor's seven signing statements July 6, 2009 David Swanson
Letter to Obama from a dying friend July 4, 2009 Robert Ellis Gordon and Paul Rogat Loeb
Honor our hemp-raising patriot heroes July 3, 2009 “Thomas Paine”
Breaking: Minnesota Supreme Court unanimously finds Franken winner June 30, 2009 Brad Blog
Why demand to prosecute torture will grow June 28, 2009 David Swanson
The Iron Triangle June 26, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
The rise of single-payer health care June 25, 2009 David Swanson
Trading press events for votes: What should press do? June 24, 2009 David Swanson
U.S. government threatens to prosecute waterboarding June 22, 2009 David Swanson
Gutting the health care plan: the scorpion and the Congress June 22, 2009 Paul Rogat Loeb
Darth Vader Cheney and the next attack June 17, 2009 Pete Johnson
Justice for the privileged June 11, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
The Omnibus CYA Act of 2009 June 11, 2009 David Swanson
We don't need the General Motors Corporation June 8, 2009 Mike Ferner
New report casts exclusion of single payer option as a question of democracy and human rights May 27, 2009 Cathy Albisa
Peace rising May 27, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Democratic Socialists? Dems Not Half That Good May 25, 2009 Bob Fitrakis
Give workers what they need! May 24, 2009 Dick Meister
Priorities May 21, 2009 David Swanson
Never Again May 21, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
George & the Water Board May 18, 2009 David Swanson
76 members of Congress oppose staying in Afghanistan forever May 18, 2009 David Swanson
Holder's plans as clear as Gonzales' memory May 17, 2009 David Swanson
Why isn't Obama turning to the Credit Unions? May 12, 2009 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Connell's sister now doubts plane crash was accident May 10, 2009 Ralph Lopez
Renters caught in squeeze face eviction May 9, 2009 Gary Baumgarten
Interview with Dr. Margaret Flowers, arrested Tuesday on Capitol Hill, part two May 9, 2009 Joan Brunwasser
Why we risked arrest for single-payer health care May 9, 2009 Margaret Flowers, M.D.
Not outraged about torture? May 8, 2009 Pete Johnson, Free Press staff
Take your torture photos to church day May 8, 2009 David Swanson
The hounds of heaven May 7, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Pay to play politics is unacceptable for health care reform May 7, 2009 Kevin Zeese
It's national Nancy Off the Table Day May 7, 2009 David Swanson
President Obama's war budget: analyzing the numbers May 6, 2009 Jeff Leys, Voices for Creative Nonviolence
Give everyone healthcare by shutting down insurance companies May 5, 2009 David Swanson
Torture and treason May 2, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
The wrong torture question May 1, 2009 David Swanson
The prosecution of George W. Bush and Dick Cheney April 26, 2009 Free Press staff
The prosecution of torturers April 23, 2009 Free Press Editorial
Rule of law vetoed by President Obama April 23, 2009 Joel S. Hirschhorn
Take heart and have courage April 22, 2009 David Swanson
Karl Rove still not arrested April 20, 2009 nation.of.gandhis
Hard times for African-American workers April 18, 2009 Dick Meister
Forced patriotism April 16, 2009 Gary Baumgarten
Geo-insanity's latest mutation April 13, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Changing the rules of the blame game April 12, 2009 Bill Moyers and Michael Winship
War casualties at home April 10, 2009 Gary Baumgarten
Capitalism's self-inflicted apocalypse April 7, 2009 Michael Parenti interviewed by Jason Miller
MoveOn is not new to supporting war April 3, 2009 David Swanson
Is this the best we can do? April 2, 2009 Dan DeWalt, Charlotte Dennett, John Nirenberg and Martha Hennessy
Happy Birthday, Cesar Chavez! March 31, 2009 David Swanson
Capitalist Incarnate: My interview with a vampire March 29, 2009 Jason Miller
Baseball: More than a man's game March 28, 2009 Dick Meister
Let's truly honor Cesar Chavez March 22, 2009 Dick Meister
A modest proposal March 19, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Breaking: Peace activists arrested at Pentagon March 17, 2009 David Swanson
Government stands in the way of financial security of small farmers: NAIS program is source of deep concern March 16, 2009 Mark Huntress
A New Deal for American Workers March 14, 2009 Dick Meister
Bill Moyers Journal: Interview with Simon Johnson March 9, 2009 Bill Moyers
Join a union, get fired March 7, 2009 Dick Meister
Oregon Plumbers Local Endorses HR 676 March 7, 2009 Kay Tillow
Appoint a special prosecutor March 4, 2009 David Swanson
Kids for cash February 24, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Washington & Lafayette get stoned & talk marriage February 22, 2009 "Thomas Paine"
An RX for nurses -- and us, too February 22, 2009 Dick Meister
Jobs may decline, unions won't February 20, 2009 Dick Meister
Cross of irony February 19, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Coffee entrepreneur brewing trouble for George W. Bush February 19, 2009 Stephen Pizzo
Perriello, peace and justice February 18, 2009 David Swanson
What President Obama should say February 17, 2009 Free Press Editorial
Truth and healing February 12, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
The problem with truth, reconciliation, and commissions February 10, 2009 David Swanson
Sit down! Sit down! February 10, 2009 Dick Meister
Abandoning torture, but what about war? February 8, 2009 David Swanson
... No intelligent life down here February 8, 2009 Christopher Bifani
Keeping the Bush era viable February 7, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Bolsheviks in Seattle? February 2, 2009 Dick Meister
New letter from Leonard Peltier: A hero’s welcome February 2, 2009 Leonard Peltier
Holding Rove in inherent contempt January 27, 2009 David Swanson
Missing the train on the recovery package January 24, 2009 Deron Lovaas and Paul Loeb
President Obama must free Leonard Peltier January 23, 2009 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Dangerous executive orders January 23, 2009 David Swanson
Childish things January 22, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
A New Day January 21, 2009 Malcolm J.
The shirt off my mother's back January 20, 2009 Gabrielle Burton
Not to remain silent January 20, 2009 Jim Miles
Be the peace January 7, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
For the health of all: Camp Hope January 5, 2009 Mike Ferner
Bill Richardson - Kissinger-American January 5, 2009 Greg Palast, excerpted from Armed Madhouse
The future of civilization January 1, 2009 Robert C. Koehler
Camp hope holds Obama to "Change" pledge January 1, 2009 Mike Ferner
Read National Issues Articles by Year: 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |