Departments
Obama on the Backs of the Poor
by Ray McGovern
August 6, 2011
What are we to make of the Obama-brokered deal on debt and spending? It was certainly what the Germans call eine schwere Geburt (a difficult birth); it was one of the few times I would have favored abortion.
I am reminded of a sermon that Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. gave during the turbulent 1950s, in which he peered into the future and issued a prescient warning:
“A nation or a civilization that continues to produce soft-minded men purchases its own spiritual death on an installment plan.”
In promoting and then signing the so-called “deficit reduction” legislation, President Barack Obama has definitively confirmed that he stands in the ranks of those spiritual-death-dealing, “soft-minded” men about whom Dr. King warned so ominously.
In my view, even dyed-in-the-wool Obama supporters will now have to let the scales fall from their eyes. The new one-sided “compromise” so clearly promotes the interests of the wealthy over those of the poor that, in Biblical terms, it can readily be seen as a Goddamned deal.
I want to share some thoughts with those among us — believers and non-believers alike — who shudder at the prospect of our children and children’s children inheriting a country far different from the one promised by the American Dream, a nation approaching “’spiritual death.”
If you are not greatly concerned with the growing disparity between the rich and poor in this country, take another minute to ponder another warning from Dr. King in the same sermon:
“Passively to accept an unjust system is to cooperate with that system, and thereby to become a participant in its evil.”
It is a bitter pill – and a great disappointment – that the President has turned his back on those about whom the Hebrew and Christian scriptures express the deepest concern, the anawim. This frequently used Biblical word denotes not just those on the margins, but the despised, hated, poor, often said in Scripture to include the widows, the orphans, the strangers.
My atheist friends regularly remind me to widen my perspective. The scriptural mandate to care for the widows, the orphans and the strangers springs from the highest of human instincts, and neither requires nor presupposes a faith perspective.
In modern American history, it also has been shown that having a vibrant middle class is good for business, while a society of a few rich and many poor is prone to destructive boom-and-bust cycles.
A huge majority of economists concede that America has been sliding into a land of haves and have-nots for the past several decades and that the “deal” Obama signed into law on Tuesday will do little, if anything, to improve the lives of our fellow citizens deprived of work, shelter, medical care and other necessities.
In sum, Obama – again put in a corner by Republicans who appeared ready to force the United States into default if they didn’t get their way – reneged on a promise not to let the burden for coping with the economic/fiscal mess fall primarily on the backs of the poor.
The immediate deficit-cutting plan excludes any additional tax revenues from the rich, a line in the sand drawn by Republicans who were determined to protect even an extravagant tax loophole for corporate jet owners and special tax breaks for oil companies recording record profits.
And Republican leaders have made clear that they will be equally adamant against any new tax revenue from the recommendations of a special congressional committee, meaning that the United States will soon face another budget crisis in which the Republicans will demand even deeper spending cuts.
Demons and Scripture
Scripture contains a lot of stories about demons. These texts were always a stretch for me, until I found myself investigating my country’s use of kidnapping, torture and black-site prisons — not to mention targeted assassinations. No longer could I make light of the demonic.
Lessons from the various indignities visited on many of my friends in inner-city Washington have served as confirmation. Ex-offenders are especially prominent among the anawim of our nation’s capital.
If we are to follow Dr. King’s mandate to avoid participation in unjust systems and practices inevitably exacerbated by the legislation signed by the President on Tuesday, we need to decide how to react. Ideally, we will choose to move forward in a wide, justice-and-peace oriented community.
From what is known of Jeremiah Wright, Obama’s pastor in Chicago, and the United Church of Christ’s reputation for faithfulness to Hebrew as well as Christian scripture, it is a safe bet that the social gospel was preached again and again in the hearing of an attentive Obama.
There is no way he could have escaped the insight that the ancient Hebrew concept of social justice was something that many in the U.S. power elite today would decry as an un-American activity.
This Hebrew concept of justice, which Jesus strongly embraced, challenges modern America and its economic inequality at almost every turn.
Take, for example, the Biblical concept of the Jubilee Year, which mandated widespread redistribution of wealth every 50 years. (See what I mean about “un-American?”)
I think we can assume that, if Obama were paying attention, he would have assimilated the starkly countercultural Hebrew concept of the Jubilee Year — an inspiration that rejected the idea of accumulated wealth and the outsized power that goes with it.
The Bible was dead serious about the redistribution of wealth. The Jewish sense was that, over time, the community would inevitably see immoderate wealth and immoderate poverty co-existing.
In other words, it was a given — for a whole bunch of very human reasons — that there would be mal-distribution of wealth, and the concept of Jubilee was to squash it all back down, essentially requiring everyone to return to the same starting point every 50 years as a matter of law.
Granted, it was a primitive idea for a simple economy, but the Jubilee spirit was the spirit of the God of the Hebrews who insisted time and again through the Biblical writers and prophets “there shall be no poor among you.” And for that to happen, there had to be periodic sharing of wealth.
It would be perhaps too much to expect that President Obama would have broached something along these lines to House Speaker John Boehner.
Still, would it have been too much a stretch to expect some mutual concern – from Republicans and Democrats alike – over the growing disparity between rich and poor in this country?
Boehner is fond of advertising that he is a Catholic. Me too.
The House speaker is a little younger than I am, but I would be surprised if he had not learned that the first thing Jesus of Nazareth said in his inaugural speech was that he had come to “bring good news to the poor.” There was only bad news for the poor from the debt-limit “compromise.”
Chastened by the Right
In Obama’s public appearances, there have been a few times when he showed some sensitivity to the problem of an extreme accumulation of wealth at the top.
Remember campaigner Obama’s brief chat with Joe (the Plumber) Wurzelbacher in Toledo, Ohio, on Oct. 12, 2008.
“My attitude is that if the economy’s good for folks from the bottom up, it’s gonna be good for everybody,” Obama said. “I think when you spread the wealth around, it’s good for everybody.”
The Republicans and the right-wing news media pounced on the comment, accusing Obama of running for “redistributionist in chief.”
Fox News played up the following snide statement from a spokesman for John McCain: “If Barack Obama’s goal as President is to ‘spread the wealth around,’ perhaps his unconditional meetings with Hugo Chavez, Raul Castro, and Kim Jong-Il aren’t so crazy — if nothing else, they can advise an Obama administration on economic policy.”
A chastened Obama quickly learned his lesson. Since the “Joe the Plumber” incident, Obama has avoided any clear suggestion that he sees a benefit in a more equitable sharing of wealth.
On Feb. 7, 2011, the President volunteered to undergo a TV grilling by Fox’s Bill O’Reilly prior to the Super Bowl and was prepared for O’Reilly’s when-did-you-stop-beating-your-wife-type question on the topic:
“Do you deny that you’re a man who wants to redistribute wealth?” asked O’Reilly.
“Absolutely. Absolutely,” Obama responded.
O’Reilly himself is an interesting case study. A graduate of Catholic grammar and high schools on Long Island, he in 1971 earned a B.A. in history from Marist College, which was founded by the Catholic order of Marist Brothers in Poughkeepsie, New York. He then taught briefly in a Catholic high school.
There is no indication that anywhere along the line anyone told him of the Jubilee Year concept, or even that Jesus of Nazareth said he would be, and his followers should be, “good news for the poor. “
Fox has been very good news for O’Reilly; Wikipedia records his annual salary at $20,000,000.
Given how Obama facilitated “resolving” the manufactured crisis over raising the debt ceiling and other fiscal measures, he seems determined to prove his declaration to O’Reilly.
Backs of the Poor
At a Town Hall meeting at Facebook headquarters in Palo Alto, California, on April 20, the President inadvertently (and ironically) gave a hint regarding how easy it would be to do what he actually ended up doing – even while criticizing Republican attitude of neglect of the poor.
Here’s what Obama said to applause from the well-heeled folks at Facebook: “Nothing is easier than solving a problem on the backs of people who are poor, for people who are powerless and don’t have lobbyists or don’t have clout.”
Then, to avoid an unprecedented default on the payment of U.S. debts, Obama ultimately opted for this “easier” course of action, exempting the wealthy and corporations from pitching in to solve the debt problem and bowing to Republican demands that everything come from spending cuts.
The outcome of the debt-ceiling battle has left many disillusioned Democrats and progressives now certain that it’s foolhardy to expect Obama to behave any differently, even though he continues to promise a vigorous debate on the proper role of government in American society but then never delivers.
That means the next course of action for Americans who want a different outcome may be to knock on the doors of rectories, synagogues and mosques to see if there’s anyone home and if anyone cares about what is happening to those on the margins.
Ask if these religious leaders are aware of what happened in Germany during the Thirties, when Catholic and Lutheran church leaders could not find their voice, and ended up acting as a force of stability for a fascist regime. See if it’s possible to wake anyone up in the religious institutions tied to the Establishment.
Inform other citizens that 58 cents of every dollar in federal “discretionary spending” now go to the Pentagon. It might be worth noting that the Soviet Union – America’s “great enemy” – imploded 20 years ago. Despite the lack of a threat from a major power, the U.S. military spending equals that of all the other countries of the world put together.
It’s also worth recalling President Dwight Eisenhower’s famous warning about “the military-industrial complex” and the words of Gen. Douglas MacArthur ten years earlier. (Neither of these military men was exactly a “dove.”)
On May 15, 1951, MacArthur said: “It is part of the general pattern of misguided policy that our country is now geared to an arms economy which was bred in an artificially induced psychosis of war hysteria and nurtured upon an incessant propaganda of fear.”
Since the Obama administration and Congress cannot be counted on to pursue traditional American justice (not to mention Biblical Jubilee justice) toward the poor – and since American religious institutions mostly are riding shotgun for this inequitable system – we might do well to heed the admonitions of popular theologian Annie Dillard; Cesar Chavez, co-founder of the United Farm Workers; and Mario Savio of the Berkeley Free Speech Movement of the 60s:
Dillard: “There is only us; there never has been any other.”
Chavez: “There are already enough of us. But without action, nothing is going to happen.”
Savio: “ There comes a time when the operation of the machine becomes so odious, makes you so sick at heart, that you can’t take part, you can’t even passively take part; and you’ve got to put your bodies upon the gears and upon the wheels, upon all the apparatus, and you’ve got to make it stop.”
Some Americans plan to express their repudiation of the dysfunctional political system with a U.S. version of “Tahrir Square” beginning Oct. 6, the tenth anniversary of the U.S. attack on Afghanistan. (See:http://october2011.org/statement [5].)
published with permission, original at Consortium News
|
 |
Recent National Issues Articles
Extraordinary interview: In love with tortured man -- Indefinite imprisonment, torture, terror inside California prisons through eyes of woman of courage December 29, 2011 Deborah Dupre, Human Rights Examiner
Stop picking on the poor plutocrats December 29, 2011 David Swanson
Don’t mute Newt December 27, 2011 Joel S. Hirschhorn
My declaration of war on Christmas December 24, 2011 Greg Palast
Pvt. Manning and Imperative of Truth December 23, 2011 Ray McGovern
The Real Christmas Story December 21, 2011 Rev. Jesse Jackson, Sr.
The trial of Bradley Manning — Rule of law or rule of intimidation, retaliation & retribution December 20, 2011 Ann Wright
Are Americans in line for Gitmo? December 5, 2011 Ray McGovern
Project Bugsplat December 1, 2011 Robert C. Koehler
Eliminate tax subsidies for big oil companies ? November 23, 2011 Tom Over
The last whistleblowers November 22, 2011 David Swanson
Lesson of White House Strafing: Limit Guns Now November 22, 2011 Rev. Jesse Jackson, Sr.
The bravest man I ever met November 21, 2011 by the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., Pageant magazine June 1965
I'm thankful for Occupy November 20, 2011 David Swanson
Occupy Crackdown: PCJF and NLG Demand Records of Federal Involvemen November 17, 2011 Partnership for Civil Justice Fund
Mass day of action on 2-month anniversary of Occupy Wall Street November 16, 2011 Occupy Wall Street PR Team
Seven arrested at demonstration at US Bank in downtown Columbus, Ohio November 15, 2011 Tom Over
Move to Amend gaining momentum November 14, 2011 Albert A. Gabel
Listen to the song: Occupy Wall Street November 13, 2011 Dave Rovics
From Occupy Wall Street to Occupy the Neighborhoods November 10, 2011 Paul Rogat Loeb
Occupy movement demands home mortgages correction November 10, 2011 David Swanson
Will the 1% steal Ohio's labor rights referendum? November 6, 2011 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Democracy key to fixing economic and eco crises, says Van Jones during visit to Columbus November 3, 2011 Tom Over
Former Tea Partier reaches out to Occupy Movement October 28, 2011 Tom Over
Official VFP statement regarding police assaults in Oakland October 26, 2011 Veterans For Peace
Numbers justify Occupy Movement October 26, 2011 Joel S. Hirschhorn
Occupy our chambers of commerce October 25, 2011 Tom Over
Arab Spring revolutionaries meet with Occupy activists in DC October 23, 2011 Tom Over
The abandoned class: Will Occupy Wall Street hold together long enough to cut to the deep chase? October 22, 2011 Robert C. Koehler
Jim Hightower tells Occupistas : just being out here is a big part of the battle October 22, 2011 Tom Over
Occupy The Hood October 21, 2011 Tom Over
Let's protest big banks at their Columbus branches October 20, 2011 Tom Over
Obama vs. jobs; Hope vs. reality October 19, 2011 David Swanson
Be a part of history. Help Occupy Columbus. October 17, 2011 Tom Over
Ohio Right of Life: Informed consent v. informed consent -- it's all situational October 16, 2011 Marley Greiner
Dr. Cornel West and 14 others arrested protesting corporate power at U.S. Supreme Court October 16, 2011 October2011
Occupy Columbus continues with gatherings at Ohio Statehouse and so-called Columbus Commons October 15, 2011 Tom Over
Class warrior from Wisconsin says building a movement requires courage, solidarity, and long-term organization October 13, 2011 Tom Over
Occupied -- What now? October 13, 2011 David Swanson, War Is A Crime.org
Former CIA analyst Ray McGovern : the movement is building October 13, 2011 Tom Over
Hey DC--You Look So Sexy ! October 12, 2011 Tom Over
To build a mass movement we got to care more and be uncomfortable, says flaming fundamentalist October 11, 2011 Tom Over
Columbus Free Press photos : Occupation in Freedom Plaza, D.C. October 11, 2011 Tom Over
Mass movement appears to be getting started, says David Swanson October 10, 2011 Tom Over
Our overripe moment October 8, 2011 Robert C. Koehler
We Are The 99 Percent October 7, 2011 Tom Over
The Progressive Humanifesto October 2, 2011 Christopher Bifani
Declaration of the Occupation of New York City October 2, 2011 NYCGA
A judge grants dubious probation September 30, 2011 Saul Landau and Nelson Valdés
The old integrity September 28, 2011 Robert C. Koehler
You've convinced me...Now go out and make me do it. September 20, 2011 Tom Over
Fracking (if done right) is a way to combat Global Warming, says Congressman Tim Ryan September 15, 2011 Tom Over
The NFL will remember 9/11 in all the wrong ways September 7, 2011 Dave Zirin
I just found 29 million jobs September 4, 2011 David Swanson
9/11 and the Orwellian redefinition of "Conspiracy Theory" August 31, 2011 Paul Craig Roberts
An upcoming Charlottesville conference highlights the importance of whistleblowers when addressing the corruption present in military contracting August 31, 2011 David Swanson
How do we build a movement to defeat right-wing extremism? August 27, 2011 Tom Over
How the budget cutting Is going to go down August 25, 2011 David Swanson, RootsAction.org
Did Tenet Hide Key 9/11 Info? August 19, 2011 Ray McGovern
Equal and opposite lunacy August 11, 2011 Robert C. Koehler
Obama on the Backs of the Poor August 6, 2011 Ray McGovern
Budget deal Is a “Huge Mistake” August 2, 2011 Norman Solomon
If you declare bankruptcy, will everything be OK in a few days, weeks? July 28, 2011 Michael Collins, “Scoop” Independent Media
Balance the budget on the backs of billionaires July 20, 2011 David Swanson, RootsAction.org
Move the budget debate to one of those democracies we're bombing into place July 18, 2011 David Swanson
The "There's Plenty of Money Act of 2012" July 9, 2011 David Swanson
King George III won: Happy Fourth of July! July 4, 2011 David Swanson
Fight Back Radio Show with Wayne Madsen July 2, 2011 Free Press Staff
In Memoriam: Gil Scot Heron May 29, 2011 Evan Davis
Libertarians say restore freedom, repeal Patriot Act May 28, 2011 Libertarian Party
Perfecting the art of civil protest May 6, 2011 Don E Wirtshafter, J.D.
Down the rabbit hole with democracy and three urgent pleas April 28, 2011 Sheila Parks, Ed.D.
The cure for plutocracy: Strike! April 27, 2011 David Swanson
White House website lying about your taxes April 24, 2011 David Swanson
Did you just call me a Socialist? April 18, 2011 David Swanson
Local and national political leader Norman Solomon officially launches his run for Congress in the North Bay April 17, 2011 Norman Solomon for Congress
Stand Up for Women's Health Rally April 13, 2011 Sarah Jones
Manning Marable and me April 3, 2011 Bob Fitrakis
In a Heartbeat: Ruling Class keeps the Bush tax cuts then attacks the middle class. March 21, 2011 Pete Johnson
Michigan fascism old news in DC March 10, 2011 David Swanson
The Green Bay Packers and the union backers March 9, 2011 H. Steven Moffic, M.D.
Go to Wisconsin, President Obama March 3, 2011 Paul Rogat Loeb
The Push of Conscience and Secretary Clinton February 27, 2011 Ray McGovern
Fighting the 5 fascisms in Wisconsin & Ohio February 21, 2011 Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman
Fight yields victory, points the way! February 12, 2011 Bruce Bostick
Ohio Republicans would execute Medicare recipients February 11, 2011 "Thomas Paine"
NFL---The untold story! February 9, 2011 Bruce Bostick
Decades in the making: The U.S. police state February 2, 2011 David Swanson
Profiles of the Targeted: FBI Raided My Home, Wanted to Know About "My Indoctrination" January 27, 2011 Kevin Gosztola
An extremist for love: Martin Luther King, Jr. Day: Then and now January 23, 2011 Marianne Williamson
A Time for Action -- Not Servility January 20, 2011 Jeff Cohen and Norman Solomon
Following, not just commemorating, Dr. King – in Words. Deeds. Action… January 17, 2011 Rev. Jesse Jackson
Bradley Manning and the rule of law January 15, 2011 Kevin Zeese
The Tuscon shooting: We must place blame where it belongs January 10, 2011 Andy Ostroy
Welcome to 2011: The american dream lives -- while you're asleep January 9, 2011 Saul Landau
Repeal, replace, ... ridiculous January 4, 2011 Andy Ostroy
Read National Issues Articles by Year: 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |