Departments
A new manifest destiny
by Robert C. Koehler
February 1, 2007
Half a million people marching against the war seem to be cursed to have their numbers reported as "tens of thousands" in the mainstream media for reasons that strike me as similar to the reeling U.S. auto industry's ongoing reliance on monster SUV sales (and didn't Ford make headlines by hemorrhaging almost $13 billion last year?).
That is, the human race has slipped, developmentally, from the grasp of the institutions that attempt to contain and define it. What a muddle. We're flowing instinctively toward survival - toward a sustainable, global society, as free of war and dehumanized enemies as it is of reliance on fossil fuels - but those in power can't bear it, can't understand it, and keep selling us the past.
How else do you explain the sort of zombie life George Bush's war on terror enjoys in the corridors of official thought - where, for instance, the insanity of "troop surge" is given polite, respectful deference - well after its lifeblood of public support has bled into the sand?
If the United States were the sort of democracy it affects to be, the war would be over - except for reparations, international peacekeeping and impeachment. Instead, the end is just beginning, dimly recognized and commented upon: Hmm, the November elections may have indicated voter anger . . .
And here and there a loose cannon goes off, with the congressional howls of outrage as likely to be Republican as Democrat.
Baghdad "is not ours to secure. We have never understood that!" cried Sen. Chuck Hagel (R-Neb.) in a GQ interview. ". . . 'Win or lose in Iraq.' Wait a minute! There is no win or loss for us. The Iraqis will determine how this turns out. We can help them with our blood and our treasure and our standing, but in the end they have to deal with the sectarian problems. That is what's consuming that country. It's not al-Qaida. It's not the terrorists. That's not the main problem over there. It's a civil war!"
What's missing is a coherent, sustaining vision of who we are, something that ignites our passion and self-interest, which politicians could serve up in their stump speeches: a new manifest destiny, you might say, one that isn't based on greed and conquest and is, at its core, irrational. Without it we're vulnerable to the politics of fear and platitude (Pearl Harbor! Iwo Jima!) and the covert agenda of the defense establishment. We need this before the next George Bush comes along.
Right now, this vision is the void at the center of our geopolitical thought. For instance, Edward Luttwak, a senior fellow at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, in Washington, D.C., writing in the February Harper's about the futility of our counterinsurgency efforts in Iraq, notes:
"Perfectly ordinary regular armed forces, with no counterinsurgency doctrine or training whatsoever, have in the past regularly defeated insurgents, by using a number of well-proven methods. It is enough to consider these methods to see why the armed forces of the United States or any other democratic country cannot possibly use them."
The politics of occupation are simple and brutal, he points out, citing the examples of the Roman and Ottoman empires, among others. They ruled vast territories for centuries by out-terrorizing any rebellion that showed its face. The emissaries of empire leaned on local civilian leaders to surrender the rebels on pain of death and had no compunction against wholesale slaughter of recalcitrant populations, if necessary.
Indeed, "A massacre once in a while remained an effective warning for decades," Luttwak writes, and, quoting Tacitus, recalls the opinion a chieftain in the British Isles had of Rome: "They make a wasteland and call it peace."
But I take issue with Luttwak's contention that, "By contrast, the capacity of American armed forces to inflict collective punishments does not extend much beyond curfews and other such restrictions" - as though our problem in Iraq is that we're wimps!
History will judge the American occupation far more harshly than that. From the shock-and-awe bombing campaign to widespread torture to rampant war crimes (investigated only if there's publicity) to the leveling of Fallujah, we've more than shown our willingness to make a wasteland and call it . . . democracy.
The problem is, the tactics of the Romans and the Turks (and the Nazis) no longer work quite so well. While, as the Bush presidency abundantly demonstrates, modern, First World democracies have a ruthless, barbarian strain that is very much capable of expressing itself, the general population can't tolerate it. Today's militarists, to their chagrin, must align themselves with the PR industry and wage war with a smiley-face. The fickle public may still relish victory, but it doesn't like blood.
The past and the future are at a standoff. The old interests have plenty of weapons and a big noise machine for spreading their message, but sooner or later their lies, like their SUVs, will run out of gas. A new manifest destiny is just around the corner; the greatest uncertainty is who will define it.
---
Robert Koehler, an award-winning, Chicago-based journalist, is an editor at Tribune Media Services and nationally syndicated writer. You can respond to this column at bkoehler@tribune.com or visit his Web site at commonwonders.com.
© 2007 Tribune Media Services, Inc.
|
 |
Recent International Issues Articles
Thai voters defy coup leaders December 24, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
Bush Administration trains members of Indonesian terrorist groups December 20, 2007 John M. Miller
Thailand divides on election December 20, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
Italians block construction of U.S. Base December 19, 2007 David Swanson
What is after Annapolis December 17, 2007 Ahmad Al-Akhras, Ph.D.
Fear of Chavez is fear of democracy December 4, 2007 Greg Palast
Same old, same old – Israel wins again December 2, 2007 Jim Miles
Thailand's anxious election November 29, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
Nukes' seventh decade November 23, 2007 David Swanson
The devalued currency of truth November 22, 2007 Robert C. Koehler
The assassination of Hugo Chavez November 15, 2007 Greg Palast
China's hedge strategy November 7, 2007 Qing Wang
Banned from Canada for war protest October 31, 2007 Ann Wright, retired US Army Colonel and former US diplomat, AfterDowningStreet.org
Torture claim is filed against Rumsfeld in France October 29, 2007 Doreen Carvajal
U.S. will tip its hand before attacking Iran October 19, 2007 David Swanson
Canada refuses entry to CODEPINK cofounder Medea Benjamin and retired Colonel Ann Wright October 7, 2007 Medea Benjamin
Tiananmen Square, Burmese style October 5, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
Forgetting Gandhi on International Non-violence day October 1, 2007 Pablo Ouziel
Airplane hijacker's flight for Burma's freedom September 30, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
Burma's bloggers September 28, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
World War III September 5, 2007 David Swanson
“Free trade” policy craze is crazy, like healthcare September 1, 2007 Stephen Crockett
Profit of doom: of vampires, parasites, and the demise of capitalism August 27, 2007 Jason Miller
Former enemies find new way forward August 23, 2007 Mike Ferner
Thailand constitution August 13, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
People's peace delegation to Iran reports back August 1, 2007 David Swanson
British Ambassador July 26, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
Civil society lost in media sound bites July 23, 2007 Pablo Ouziel
Homeland conspiracy July 18, 2007 Robert C. Koehler
Gender savagery in Guatemala July 15, 2007 Michael Parenti and Lucia Muñoz
Khmer Rouge trial July 12, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
The Palestinian left: a lost opportunity for relevance July 10, 2007 Ramzy Baroud
Northern Light: Tony Sutton of ColdType interviewed by Jason Miller June 21, 2007 Jason Miller
Sudan’s reported acceptance of peacekeepers for Darfur must be followed by immediate deployment June 15, 2007 Diana Duarte
U.S. terror Laos June 8, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
Conyers challenges Bush for G8 action on vultures, Palast reports from London on BBC Newsnight June 7, 2007 Greg Palast
Executioner June 4, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
Recent attacks in Darfur demonstrate why UN protection force must be deployed May 13, 2007 Diana Duarte
Bombing mystery April 5, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
Jesus Wouldn't Bomb Anyone: Why are we waging war on the poor and oppressed? April 5, 2007 Jason Miller
Coup six months March 19, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
Bangkok bombs March 17, 2007 Richard S. Ehrlich
Four years ago today March 16, 2007 Starhawk
Iran in Congress's sights March 7, 2007 David Swanson
How the world can stop Bush February 18, 2007 Paul Craig Roberts
A pox upon Mr. Armstrong’s wonderful world: of illusory democracies, rogue states, and accelerating humanity’s demise February 18, 2007 Jason Miller
Sorry about that February 18, 2007 Robert C. Koehler
The Mecca agreement: what should we expect? February 18, 2007 Ramzy Baroud
The great eight February 18, 2007 Marion Schneider
Overblown threat and Islamophobia February 11, 2007 Abukar Arman
Military explosions shake sections of Vieques February 11, 2007 Peace No War
A new manifest destiny February 1, 2007 Robert C. Koehler
The making of another Iraq January 30, 2007 Abukar Arman
Bush's four anti-terror successes all fictional January 27, 2007 David Swanson
Global food supply near the breaking point January 26, 2007 Stephen Leahy
Oil and foreign policy after Bush January 21, 2007 Stephen Crockett
If Beal Street Could Talk – Part 1 January 15, 2007 David Swanson
International delegation travels to Guantanamo, Cuba to protest infamous US prison January 3, 2007 Alejandro Beltran
Read International Issues Articles by Year: 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |