Thu Feb 09 2012
Departments
International Issues

America won't lift sanctions unless Suu Kyi is freed for election
by Richard S. Ehrlich
November 15, 2009

BANGKOK, Thailand -- Burma must free Aung San Suu Kyi from house arrest and allow her to participate in a nationwide election, otherwise the vote will not be credible and U.S. economic sanctions will not be lifted, a U.S. State Department official warned on Thursday (November 5) after meeting her in Rangoon.

After "listening" to Mrs. Suu Kyi during a meeting on Wednesday (November 4), however, U.S. State Department Deputy Assistant Secretary Scot Marciel was unwilling, or unable, to reveal what she said.

"It was a private conversation," a testy, tight-lipped Mr. Marciel said.

He also dodged questions about demands by some to put Burma's military regime leaders on trial for alleged crimes against humanity and war crimes committed during their bloody crackdowns against pro-democracy demonstrations and military campaigns against ethnic guerrillas.

When asked if he favored such prosecutions against the regime, Mr. Marciel continued walking toward his waiting car and replied: "I think I have officially finished answering questions."

No breakthrough or major diplomatic success was achieved during the visit to Burma by Mr. Marciel and U.S. State Department Assistant Secretary Kurt Campbell on Tuesday and Wednesday (November 3 and 4).

In addition to Mrs. Suu Kyi, the two American diplomats met Burmese Prime Minister Gen. Thein Sein, opposition politicians, minority ethnic leaders, and others.

But they had no idea why they were not able to meet Burma's all-powerful dictator, Senior Gen. Than Shwe.

At an hour-long forum for diplomats, non-governmental organizations and journalists in Bangkok, Mr. Marciel referred to "past failures of diplomatic efforts" and said:

"Look, various countries have taken various approaches to Burma. None of them have succeeded. So I think we all should be very humble and not assume that we have the answers until we actually produce some results."

He was also unsure about how the U.S. diplomatic initiative was perceived by the Burmese junta.

"As to whether they ignored us, I think time will tell," he said.

"What we want to see is broad progress. Certainly releasing Aung San Suu Kyi and other political prisoners, we think, is critical to that.

"But the release of Aung San Suu Kyi -- as much as that would be very important and very positive -- does not solve all the problems," the State Department official said.

The regime earlier announced plans to hold an election, possibly in 2010, but barred Mrs. Suu Kyi from running as a candidate or leading the country.

In the previous 1990 election, her National League for Democracy (NLD) party won a landslide victory, but the military ignored the results.

The junta has kept Mrs. Suu Kyi under house arrest for 14 of the past 20 years, and sentenced her to an additional 18 months in August for illegally sheltering a zealous American visitor, John Yettaw, for two nights at her villa in Rangoon.

"I think an election without Aung San Suu Kyi and the NLD would be very hard to see as credible," Mr. Marciel said.

U.S. trade, investment and banking sanctions against Burma are "still, in our view, a useful tool, and they remain part of what we are trying to use as a policy instrument.

"We do not think it is appropriate, or wise, to lift sanctions now...but we certainly would be willing to lift sanctions if there is progress.

"The purpose of the sanctions is not for the satisfaction of having them, but to try and achieve an end."

Washington has helped cripple Burma's economy through years of economic sanctions, designed to emphasize America's demand for democracy.

Burma is the biggest country in mainland Southeast Asia and also known as Myanmar.

California-based Chevron Corp. is the only major U.S. country exempted from the sanctions, and Chevron's profits from its Yadana natural gas pipeline from Burma into Thailand are shared with Burma's military regime, along with France's Total and the Petroleum Authority of Thailand.

The Americans' trip coincided with an announcement by Beijing's government-owned China National Petroleum Corp (CNPC) on Tuesday (November 3) that it started laying a 771-km oil pipeline across Burma to reach the Indian Ocean.

China is Burma's strongest military partner and biggest foreign investor.

The Chinese pipeline would reportedly enable a faster flow of up to 84 million barrels annually of Middle East oil into China.

Critics of America's hard-line approach against Burma have pointed to the gains made by China and other sanction-busting nations in exploiting the impoverished, resource-rich country.

U.S.-led international sanctions have meant that countries which chose to ignore the boycotts have been able to do business in Burma without American and European competition -- a lucrative bottom line which is increasingly important to some Americans during the current U.S. recession.

---
Richard S Ehrlich is a Bangkok-based journalist who has reported news from Asia since 1978. He is co-author of "Hello My Big Big Honey!", a non-fiction book of investigative journalism. His web page is http://www.asia-correspondent.110mb.com (Copyright 2009 Richard S Ehrlich)


Recent International Issues Articles

On Gaza drivers, rumors and Egypt’s steel wall
  December 31, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

It's the system, stupid: The Ragnarok of globalized corporate capitalism and the rise of the planetarian paradigm
  December 30, 2009
  James Heddle

Palestine/Israel: A single state, with liberty and justice for all
  December 30, 2009
  Susan Abulhawa with Ramzy Baroud

Obama's rejection speech
  December 11, 2009
  David Swanson

Peace movement objects to Peace Prize
  December 10, 2009
  Michael McPhearson and Josh Brollier

Afghanistan: What Obama and the US Media Aren't Telling Us
  December 4, 2009
  Evan Davis

Columbus Free Press editors Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman speak out against sending more US troops to Afghanistan
  December 2, 2009
  Tom Over

Afghanistan: Our 177th Colony
  December 1, 2009
  David Swanson

The Meaning Of The Gift-Giving Season, According To Rev. Billy Of The Church Of Life After Shopping
  November 28, 2009
  Tom Over

A paradigm shift in Singapore: yet Apec offers no clear answers
  November 25, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

Dissidents make noise -- oops, news
  November 24, 2009
  Saul Landau

Thai military wants U.S. satellites to hunt Islamist rebels
  November 20, 2009
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Globalization unchecked: How alien media is suffocating real culture
  November 18, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

Death to no one
  November 15, 2009
  Bitta Mostofi

America won't lift sanctions unless Suu Kyi is freed for election
  November 15, 2009
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Admiral Mullen announces Afghanistan strategy: prepare to nonviolently resist
  November 15, 2009
  Jeff Leys, Co-Coordinator of Voices for Creative Nonviolence

America Appeals to Extradite Russia's Alleged "Merchant of Death"
  October 23, 2009
  Richard S. Ehrlich

War, negation and Muslim identity revisited
  October 22, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

Obama’s test: democracy or chaos in Latin America
  October 12, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

The G-20 Announces the New World Order
  October 1, 2009
  Michael Collins

Crucial questions on Afghanistan war
  September 2, 2009
  Free Press Editorial

The scapegoat's apology
  August 28, 2009
  Robert C. Koehler

Fighting for the right to walk
  August 27, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

The heart of the future
  July 18, 2009
  Robert C. Koehler

Italy to declare independence from US military
  July 8, 2009
  David Swanson

Israel attacks justice boat: kidnaps human rights workers, confiscates medicine, toys and olive trees
  June 30, 2009
  Greta Berlin

North Korea: "sanity" at the brink
  June 27, 2009
  Michael Parenti

A boy and an artificial leg: a Gaza story
  June 11, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

Is anyone speechless?
  June 8, 2009
  Iqbal Jassat

Burma's Aung San Suu Kyi is on trial because an American had "A Vision"
  June 1, 2009
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Support U.N. Economic Crisis World Conference
  May 22, 2009
  Ramsey Clark, winner of the 2008 U.N. Human Rights Award

Gaza disowned: the Pope, Israel and "reconciliation"
  May 20, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

Applying the lessons of Nuremburg to the USA in 2009
  May 19, 2009
  Paul Lehto, Juris Doctor

Vets Speak Out! Interview with Rick Reyes
  May 17, 2009
  Joan Brunwasser, OpEdNews

Goliath's vulnerability is the truth
  May 16, 2009
  Robert C. Koehler

Harvest of suicides
  May 11, 2009
  Vandana Shiva

The Hague's International Criminal Court will not put Bush on trial
  May 10, 2009
  Richard S. Ehrlich

War without context: Fatah, Hamas and flawed language
  May 8, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

CAIR's humanitarian mission to Iran
  May 6, 2009
  Mahmoud El-Yousseph

Sixth Nobel Nomination for Leonard Peltier
  May 5, 2009
  Leonard Peltier Defense Offense Committee

The international criminal court and a rogue empire
  April 27, 2009
  David Swanson

Wall of fear
  April 25, 2009
  Robert C. Koehler

The big strike
  April 25, 2009
  Dick Meister

Somali piracy or Somali patriotism?
  April 20, 2009
  Steven R. Linnabary

Israel investigated, but will it repent?
  April 10, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

Intifada: A third chapter
  March 21, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

American protester critically injured by soldiers in Ni'ilin
  March 16, 2009
  AATW

Engaging Hamas: Will history repeat itself?
  February 28, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

A new Afghanistan nightmare
  February 23, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

A new Afghanistan nightmare
  February 21, 2009
  Ramzy Baroud

Under siege again, but Gaza will not die
  February 12, 2009
  Ann Wright, AfterDowningStreet

The moral dead zone
  January 20, 2009
  Robert C. Koehler

Children of Gaza, run to the angels
  January 12, 2009
  Suzanne Baroud

Let Gaza live
  January 12, 2009
  Cynthia McKinney

Gaza: Plan of Attack
  January 1, 2009
  Jim Miles




Read International Issues Articles by Year:
2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000



FREE PRESS EMAIL UPDATE


Donate to The Free Press The Free Press Store

FOLLOW US ON
twitter
facebook


SEARCH THE FREEPRESS




1021 E. Broad St. Columbus, OH 43205 | 614.253.2571 | truth@freepress.org
All content © 1970-2012 The Columbus Free Press
Disclaimer