Thu Feb 09 2012
Departments
International Issues

Leon Panetta is lying about Iran's nuclear 'weapons'
by Terry Lodge
June 30, 2010

Leon Panetta is resorting to lies to justify war against Iran. This statement in particular is misleading on several levels:

"Central Intelligence Agency Director Leon Panetta told ABC's 'This Week' television program that the agency thinks Iran has enough low-enriched uranium now for two weapons, but that Tehran would have to further enrich the material first."

Notice, folks, I am NOT a magician, have nothing up my sleeves, have no espionage credentials, nothing except Wikipedia.

But I know this: that without highly-enriched uranium (i.e., 85% or greater U-235 content), it is not possible to have a nuclear weapon capable of missile delivery.

Remember "Fat Man" and "Little Boy," the Nagasaki and Hiroshima nuclear bombs? Fat Man weighed 10,200 lbs. - over 5 tons - and was so large that modifications had to be made to the largest bomber of the day in order to deliver it.

The same was true of Little Boy - which weighed 8,800 lbs. (4.4 tons).

Ballistic missiles cannot deliver so heavy a bomb, so the uranium has to be highly enriched to make a much smaller package - something that weighs only a few hundred pounds instead of these huge weights. I assure you that there will never, ever be a plane allowed to load in Iran, much less leave the runway, with a 5 ton nuclear weapon on it in our satellite- and drone-rich world. The Iranian air force is antiquated and useless for delivery of nuclear weapons.

For Leon Panetta to say Iran has enough low-enriched uranium for two weapons means that Iran has perhaps 100 to 200 lbs. of uranium that is at least 80% U-238 and only 20% U-235 (more likely, 95% U-238 and only 5% U-235). That's a very long way from 15% U-238 and 85% U-235, i.e., weapons-grade uranium.

Panetta therefore is merely stating that Iran has nuclear fuel that is low-enriched and usable only in an electric power reactor, that Iran has power plant fuel with far too low U-235 content to be weapons-usable. And since he is talking about a couple of hundred pounds of uranium at the most, it appears that Iran doesn't have enough uranium even to fuel a moderate-sized electric power reactor. Iran is not only "two years" away from nuclear weapons, it is years away from having enough low-enriched uranium for a nuclear power plant and more years away from having nuclear weapons if it chose to go that route. That is consistent with the National Intelligence Estimate for 2010, which concluded that Iran does not appear to have an active nuclear weapons program.

The magic here is that by leaving out critical details, Panetta gives the impression that Iran's Non-Proliferation Treaty-compliant nuclear program, which is monitored by international inspectors, is on a track to highly-enriching its nuclear plant fuel for bombs. This is cynical manipulation of public ignorance on a major issue. Leon Panetta needs to be fired and retired for lying to the American public.

And think about this: there's a frightening possibility that Israel will start a war over Iran's "virtual" nuclear program - a program that exists only in the fantasies of warmongers within the Obama administration such as Panetta. Don't get me started on Hillary Clinton.




Recent International Issues Articles

Support Wikileaks
  December 25, 2010
  Pete Johnson for Linda Schade

Argentina, Brazil, and Uruguay recognize Palestine within 1967 green line armistice boundary
  December 23, 2010
  Jim Miles

U.S. Embassy suggests
  December 17, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Insisting on their humanity: 'The Plight of the Palestinians'
  December 17, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

What's Behind the War on WikiLeaks
  December 13, 2010
  Ray McGovern

FBI, DEA, & Homeland Security investigate Russian crime in Thailand
  December 8, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Lebanon at stake: Turkey must reveal its cards
  December 2, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

The invisible government
  December 2, 2010
  Robert C. Koehler

Wikileaks: Russian bribes "Infected" bout's extradition case to U.S.
  December 2, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Cambodia's festival stampede kills 378
  November 27, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Iran-Nuke NIE Stopped Bush on War
  November 24, 2010
  Ray McGovern

American predicts Burma's Aung San Suu Kyi will be assassinated
  November 22, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

A follow up on my fifth grade essay: education at gunpoint
  November 21, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Foreign Affairs - remaking the Middle East
  November 14, 2010
  Jim Miles

Burma's Aung San Suu Kyi gains freedom & challenges regime
  November 14, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Canada stands by Israel...
  November 9, 2010
  Jim Miles

Bush Boasts of Waterboard Order
  November 8, 2010
  Ray McGovern

Deadly bombs make Bangkok unsafe
  November 7, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Conned by Democracy: The Middle East's Stagnant "Change"
  November 4, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Rule of law is alive and well outside the United States
  October 18, 2010
  David Swanson

Deadly bombs make Bangkok unsafe
  October 11, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

What we’ve done to others
  October 2, 2010
  Saul Landau and Nelson Valdes

Confessions of Roger Noriega: Muscular diplomacy or law breaking?
  September 26, 2010
  Saul Landau and Nelson Valdes

Sex change operations in Thailand
  September 26, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Petraeus Cons Obama on Afghan War
  September 25, 2010
   By Ray McGovern

Regarding US Muslims: A misguided debate
  September 21, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

The photo before the storm: peace talks already failed
  September 10, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Behind the Israeli wall: A lesson in reality
  September 2, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Viktor Bout avoids an immediate boot to America
  September 1, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

35 years after war, America influences Vietnam
  August 31, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Viktor Bout avoids an immediate boot to America
  August 26, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Rebranding Iraq: Playing with numbers and human lives
  August 26, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

"Lord of War" Viktor Bout's extradition to New York
  August 21, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Bourj el-Barajneh: Searching for meaning in a refugee camp
  August 12, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

A Cuban adventure with Lee Lockwood
  August 12, 2010
  Saul Landau

Buddhist "Body Snatchers" collect Bangkok's dead and dying
  August 9, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Whose Hands? Whose Blood? Killing Civilians in Afghanistan and Iraq
  August 8, 2010
  Tom Engelhardt

Smoke on a bridge: Lebanon awaits a verdict
  August 7, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud – Beirut, Lebanon

Elderly Thai kickboxers' brains suffer after fights
  August 5, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Why Muslims should rethink Palestine
  July 31, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Afghan War Leaks Expose Costly, Deceitful March of Folly
  July 26, 2010
  Ray McGovern

Thailand's government faces possible collapse from trial
  July 19, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Thailand's Red Shirts struggle to survive crackdown
  July 8, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Cluster bombs and civilian lives: efficient killing, profits and human rights
  July 8, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Millennium goals revisited: noble ideas, and feel-good moments
  July 1, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Leon Panetta is lying about Iran's nuclear 'weapons'
  June 30, 2010
  Terry Lodge

Complaint against Dr. James Elmer Mitchell
  June 21, 2010
  Pete Johnson

Middle East is changing, and Ankara knows it
  June 17, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Obama was created by our failure to impeach Bush
  June 17, 2010
  David Swanson

The Old Gaza boy and the sea
  June 13, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

David's slingshot
  June 6, 2010
  Robert C. Koehler

Has Israel declared war on the international community?
  June 2, 2010
  Pablo Ouziel

Israel and Harman in Tandem: From high seas to airwaves
  June 1, 2010
  Norman Solomon

The common culture of Turkey, the United States, and Iran
  May 30, 2010
  David Swanson

Bangkok burns after the Army crushes the Reds' barricades
  May 19, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Reds' weapon of choice: Burning barricades
  May 16, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Yemen’s sorrowful options: ‘revolt, migrate or die’
  May 13, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Dark Green
  May 13, 2010
  Robert C. Koehler

"Seh Daeng" denies leading a death squad to protect the reds
  May 11, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Soul of a citizen: beyond the Impossibly perfect standard
  May 8, 2010
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Two faces appear behind Bangkok's bamboo barricades
  May 2, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Dispatch from China: Number 15 has left the building
  April 15, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Country Joe's
  April 13, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Indispensable IslamOnline must not fail
  April 10, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

State of emergency to bleach Thailand's reds
  April 8, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Is murder the new torture?
  April 7, 2010
  David Swanson

Defacto state
  April 1, 2010
  Jim Miles

The lobby vs. America: on Netanyahu’s lies and the spineless politicians
  April 1, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

A bomber jacket doesn’t cover the blood
  March 30, 2010
  Norman Solomon

Activism is change, not academic squabbles and bickering
  March 18, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Meeting our makers: face to face with sweatshop workers who make what we buy
  March 17, 2010
  Tom Over

Alternative reading of the Al-Mabhouh murder
  March 11, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

U.S. surveillance blimp fights harsh criticism
  March 11, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

Flexible Afghanistan war objectives: and the agony grinds on
  March 4, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Perpetual fraud
  March 3, 2010
  Jim Miles

U.S. & Thai military targeted by anti-coup reds
  February 21, 2010
  Richard S. Ehrlich

The useless logic of round numbers: war is criminal any day
  February 17, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Ireland: The arrest of Pat O'Donnell
  February 17, 2010
  David Rovics

Haiti: the spectacle
  January 22, 2010
  Robert C. Koehler

An odyssey for justice
  January 15, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Urgent - Help Survivors in Haiti
  January 13, 2010
  Mary Ellen McNish, American Friends Service Committee




Read International Issues Articles by Year:
2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000



FREE PRESS EMAIL UPDATE


Donate to The Free Press The Free Press Store

FOLLOW US ON
twitter
facebook


SEARCH THE FREEPRESS




1021 E. Broad St. Columbus, OH 43205 | 614.253.2571 | truth@freepress.org
All content © 1970-2012 The Columbus Free Press
Disclaimer