DEPARTMENTS
ANTI-WAR
DEATH PENALTY
ELECTIONS
ENVIRONMENT
GLBT ISSUES
HEMP
INTERNATIONAL
NATIONAL
REVIEWS
|
Departments International Issues Beyond the two-state solution Portions of France not yet under Chinese control shelter refugees by the millions. French citizens captured in their homes are held as "prisoners of war" and freed to become refugees in distant parts of France. China changes the name of its occupied areas from France to Chance. The remaining parts of the country are just referred to by their local (Chinese) names, as if they were part of no nation at all and yet somehow Chinese in the end. For years, the Chancian government continues to expand and to assault the French people. With more and more immigrants from China, Chance becomes an apartheid nation with lesser rights for any French within it. In 2067, Chance launches a major assault, seizing control of much of what's left of France. The newly seized areas come to be called "the occupied territories," in contrast to the already occupied territories, which are called simply Chance. As the years pass, Chancian children are born and raised in Chance who had nothing to do with the original invasion. In fact, they are never even told about it. At most they are taught that Chance was founded in 2048 when the French voluntarily left and the true border of the Chancian nation was drawn on a map with a purple line. That purple line is also called "the line of 2067," even though it was drawn in 2048. Outside of that purple line are the occupied territories and the few towns and villages left to the French. Liberals in Chance propose giving "the occupied territories" back to the French and restoring the Purple Line, while conservatives propose eliminating the last French descendant from Europe. Those are the extremes of the political debate in Chance. Everything within the Purple Line is universally agreed upon as properly Chancian. The agreement runs so deep that the question is never raised at all. The original sin in Chancian history is dated to 2067 when the Chancian democracy strayed outside its natural borders and violated the rights of others for the first time. But, of course, Chancian families are raised through the years outside as well as inside the Purple Line, a line that had never been agreed to in any way by the French, a line that would deny many of them the right to return to their homes. The French want reparations and restoration. They date the catastrophe of their nation to 2048. The Chancians are willing to talk about undoing anything they've done since 2067, including through the creation of a French nation. The French nation would include several geographically separated bits of territory in northern and southern parts of the former France. It would remain subject to the rule of Chance on major questions. And the new France would have to agree to the rightful existence of Chance inside the Purple Line -- or the Purple Line plus a little. So, a lengthy and seemingly endless process is created called the Peace Process. The French show up wanting to talk about 2048. The Chancians show up willing to talk only about 2067. The two sides never hear each other. There is never any peace. The Chancians announce at the end of each failed meeting that they "have no partner" with which to negotiate peace. Hostilities and a permanent state of emergency prevail, with French people within Chance and Chance's "occupied territories" deprived of basic rights, imprisoned, tortured, and assaulted. The other nations of Europe join with the French in resenting the behavior of Chance. The nations of Asia, however, celebrate Chance as "the only democracy in Europe." *** There are several differences between this story and the story of Israel and Palestine. Some of the differences are trivial: The dates are 1948 and 1967, not 2048 and 2067. The line is green rather than purple. Some of the differences are significant: The Jewish culture always had ties to Israel. The religious element allows for an intermediary class of citizens consisting of Arab Jews. Et cetera. But morally, the differences seem only to obscure what matters. The state of Israel was created through ethnic cleansing. It was created as a state to privilege one religious group, something that states should not do. But two wrongs cannot make a right. Evicting Israelis from their homes, inside or outside the Green Line, is not a solution. Yehouda Shenhav's new book, "Beyond the Two State Solution: A Jewish Political Essay" tells the story above, but straightforwardly, without the analogy. The language of the Green Line, Shenhav writes, is "a language through which Israel is described as a liberal democracy, while the Arabs (and Mizrachi and religious Jews to boot) are described as inferior and undemocratic. This is the language of someone who came to the Middle East for a short while, not to integrate but to exist here as a guest. The position it expresses is not only immoral with regard to the Palestinians, but also potentially disastrous for the Jews. It commits them to life in a ghetto with a limited idea of democracy based on racial laws and a perpetual state of emergency." Shenhav wants to restore awareness of 1948, but not to try to reconstruct the world of 1948. He does not propose eliminating Israel. He does not propose uniting the people of Israel and Palestine into a single nation. He does propose allowing Palestinians to return to their homes in a manner least disturbing to Israelis already living in those villages or buildings, including with compensation paid to residents evicted by an agreement with returning refugees. He proposes a bilingual society, with a fragmented political federation. He expects this to be very difficult, while preferable to any other approach. And he rightly sees the first step as recovering honesty with regards to not-so-distant history. --------------------------- David Swanson's books include "War Is A Lie." He blogs at David Swanson and War is a Crime and works as Campaign Coordinator for the online activist organization . He hosts Talk Nation Radio. Follow him on Twitter: @davidcnswanson and FaceBook. |
|
Recent International Issues Articles Ten of my favorite things about 2012 Universal Declaration of Human Responsibilities Pile of Skulls Internal Security Act clamped on Bangkok to stifle coup demand Brand Names and Mass Graves Internal Security Act clamped on Bangkok to stifle coup demand Panetta expects Taliban won't turn Petraeus's adultery into propaganda Obama following his grandfather to Burma Two Members of Pussy Riot Sent to Russian Penal Colonies New demands for an immediate coup in Thailand China mourns Sihanouk's death & continues advancing in Cambodia Empire and its Consequences 13 Murders on the Mekong River International Peace Day from Kabul, Afghanistan The Innocence of U.S. Foreign Policy Funding teachers doesn't get embassies attacked Love, Hate and Indifference: singer/songwriter/activist David Rovics The Hidden Agenda of Green Party VP Candidate Cheri Honkala A Black, Green and White Talk with Shamako Noble of Hip Hop Congress New American judge may help bring five more Khmer Rouge to trial Julian Assange, International Intrigue and What’s Going On With Ecuador Yes We Camp Beyond Money Love is the key ingredient for successful social movements, not religion, per se. 1,500 fake "Bomb Detectors" fail to stop explosions in Thailand SPECIAL REPORT -- EXPOSING U.S. AGENTS OF LOW-INTENSITY WARFARE IN AFRICA: The Neocons vs. the ‘Arab Spring’: Back on the Warpath Iran and everything else Beyond the two-state solution Thailand's robots can save your life or kill you, but not yet love you War and Climate Change Flesh-eating fish are feeding on tourists' feet Veterans For Peace supports U.N. committee in questioning U.S. recruitment, killing of children Seeking a Visa for Dr. Wee Teck Young NASA's atmosphere probe is grounded by Thailand's squabbling For Love or Money Julian Assange's Artful Dodge Turkish court indicts Senior Israeli Military Officials in murders on Gaza flotilla: On the Second Anniversary of the Gaza Freedom Flotilla Aung San Suu Kyi leaves Burma after 24 years No one hears the poor Millions of Illegal Methamphetamines Made From Medicine in Thailand's Hospitals FBI seizes server from progressive internet service provider Thaksin wants to avoid assassination and prison in Thailand Via campesina and allies call for global solidarity in fight against land grabs Proud to wear a forbidden burqa in France A message of peace and friendship from Iran Aung San Suu Kyi stoops to conquer Burma Universal Declaration of Human Responsibilities Why Israel attacked Gaza: Bibi stirring trouble Columbus Activists Look South to help build Global Justice Movement Alcohol & politics: A volatile mix in Thailand Activists Call for Kroger's Support of Migrant Farm Worker Rights Large coalition asks for Obama's Nobel Peace Prize to be rescinded Iranians allegedly posted "Baked Clay" signs to attack Bangkok Alleged Iranian bombers cavorted with Thai women in beach resort Cold war in warm waters: US-China's dangerous contest for Asia-Pacific Three alleged Iranian bomb-makers arrested after bungling the plot Happy savages Food Sovereignty Activist Calls for Alliances between Progressives and ' Radicals ' Alleged Iranian bomb-maker blows off his own leg Obama's Super-Bowl Fumble on Iran A Banquet Feasts on Yingluck's Troubles in Thailand Thai government promotes Red Shirt leader & pro-Mugabe supporter Terror suspect says ammonia in his "Cool Packs" not for bombs Alleged terrorist reveals stockpile of bomb-making chemicals in Bangkok Church of the Dude, inspired by The Big Lebowski, sets up in Thailand A tale of 2 countries Aljazeera coverage: The revolution will be televised, and also manipulated Read International Issues Articles by Year: |
FREE PRESS EMAIL UPDATE
Donate to the Free Press Election Protection Fund to help us investigate and monitor election fraud in this year's election.
FOLLOW US ON
twitter
facebook
SEARCH THE FREEPRESS
1021 E. Broad St. Columbus, OH 43205 | 614.253.2571 | truth@freepress.org
All content © 1970-2012 The Columbus Free Press
Disclaimer