Departments
The Innocence of U.S. Foreign Policy
by Robert C. Koehler
September 20, 2012
The Saturday headline in the Wall Street Journal was: “Anti-U.S. Mobs on Rampage.” The next day, a NATO airstrike killed eight women collecting firewood in the mountains of eastern Afghanistan, an event that garnered virtually zero mainstream U.S. headlines.
Somewhere in the gap between these two phenomena — the overheated news about our violent, irrational enemies in the Middle East and the silence surrounding our war and occupation of the region — lies American politics, values, the presidential race, the national identity. Beyond that gap lies the truth about who we are, and only when we have access to it does the future turn into creative possibility and peace become possible.
The conventional wisdom we’re fed in the mainstream media takes into account only the fear — the hysteria — implicit in the Wall Street Journal headline. The story, by Jay Solomon and Carol E. Lee, goes on to tell us:
“The regional furor, coming just three days after an attack on the U.S. Consulate in Benghazi, Libya, that killed the U.S. ambassador and three other workers, underscored Washington’s diminished ability to influence a region where a number of governments newly elected during the so-called Arab Spring have minimal control over their restive populations.
“In many cases,” the story continues, “the political leaders and security forces within these new governments have proved unwilling, or incapable, of challenging the protesters and radical Islamist groups that have gained greater license to take to the streets.”
In other words, the Middle East is archaic, volatile, “restive,” a region full of religious fanatics easily manipulated by cynical leaders. Almost anything — an idiotic 13-minute film clip on YouTube for “Innocence of Muslims,” for instance — can set off their murderous fury. The new governments that replaced the old autocracies can’t control such people. And now, tragically, several Americans are dead.
As the story progresses, the thesis slowly hardens into fact. Finally, ka-boom:
“Republican nominee Mitt Romney, for one, has seized on the unrest to charge that the White House didn’t understand the forces being unleashed by the rebellions that have gripped the region since last year, and should have been much more aggressive to try and fashion regimes that were secular and pro-West in their orientation.”
And that’s how it works. Suddenly the “might makes right” position, however puerile and irrational — that U.S. foreign policy is all about forcibly shaping the world around its interests, that military intimidation only has consequences when it is not quickly and relentlessly employed — comes off as reasonable and logical. It may be debatable in a given circumstance, but it remains the option of choice in a dangerous world, where civilizations constantly clash, insurgents lurk and primitive, “tribal” fanatics hate us for our freedoms.
Thus Richard Cohen, writing in the Washington Post a few days ago, belittles the Obama administration for “leading from behind” because it was less aggressive last year than France in taking military action to remove Gaddafi from power in Libya. And now look where this naïve belief in diplomacy has gotten us:
“The notion that the United States can lead from behind,” Cohen writes, “is pitiful, the sorry concoction of an Obama administration that mistakes dulcet passivity for a foreign policy.”
Hoist the flag, praise the Lord, pass the ammo. This is American hysteria at its finest. Only unrelenting militarism can stop the rampaging mobs out there beyond our borders; dulcet passivity just won’t do it. And if you feel pushed and offended by this attitude, Barack Obama becomes the voice of reason in a troubled world, the good guy doing the best he can. Except . . . there’s that silence again.
As Peter Hart wrote recently in an article for FAIR: “Part of the corporate media’s job is to make sure real political grievances are mostly kept out of the discussion. It’s a lot easier to talk about angry mobs and their peculiar religion than it is to acknowledge that maybe some of the anger has little to do with religion at all.”
Whereas Arab violence generates adrenalin-pumping headlines and is mostly reported outside any serious context — e.g., the U.S. devastation of Iraq, Guantanamo, Abu Ghraib, the Koran burnings, the ongoing drone assassinations — the violence that emerges from U.S. policy is softened with so much context it’s often a struggle to figure out if anything happened at all.
For instance, the NATO airstrike last weekend that killed eight Afghan women and injured eight more, including young girls, was headlined thus in the New York Times: “Karzai Denounces Coalition Over Airstrikes.” The focus of the story, as Hart points out, is the tension the deaths caused “between Mr. Karzai and his American benefactors.” Meanwhile, “the killings of Afghan women are a secondary news event.”
The story of the deaths concludes: “Coalition forces were apparently unaware that village women sometimes go into the woods in the early hours of the morning to fetch wood for cooking fires they need to have going by breakfast time.”
This is the innocence of U.S. foreign policy. I feel far more horror — more fear about the future — in its pseudo-apology for the high-tech deaths of eight women than I do in the angry protests of aggrieved Arabs.
Robert Koehler is an award-winning, Chicago-based journalist and nationally syndicated writer. His new book, Courage Grows Strong at the Wound (Xenos Press) is now available. Contact him at koehlercw@gmail.com, visit his website at commonwonders.com or listen to him at Voices of Peace radio.
Original at Common Wonders
|
 |
Recent International Issues Articles
Ten of my favorite things about 2012 December 28, 2012 Medea Benjamin
Universal Declaration of Human Responsibilities December 10, 2012 David Swanson
Pile of Skulls December 7, 2012 Robert C. Koehler
Internal Security Act clamped on Bangkok to stifle coup demand December 4, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Brand Names and Mass Graves November 30, 2012 Robert C. Koehler
Internal Security Act clamped on Bangkok to stifle coup demand November 30, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Panetta expects Taliban won't turn Petraeus's adultery into propaganda November 26, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Obama following his grandfather to Burma November 19, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Two Members of Pussy Riot Sent to Russian Penal Colonies November 9, 2012 Hacker/Activist News
New demands for an immediate coup in Thailand November 1, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
China mourns Sihanouk's death & continues advancing in Cambodia October 17, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Empire and its Consequences October 12, 2012 Robert C. Koehler
13 Murders on the Mekong River September 28, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
International Peace Day from Kabul, Afghanistan September 24, 2012 Johnny Barber
The Innocence of U.S. Foreign Policy September 20, 2012 Robert C. Koehler
Funding teachers doesn't get embassies attacked September 17, 2012 David Swanson
Love, Hate and Indifference: singer/songwriter/activist David Rovics September 14, 2012 Tom Over
The Hidden Agenda of Green Party VP Candidate Cheri Honkala September 14, 2012 Tom Over
A Black, Green and White Talk with Shamako Noble of Hip Hop Congress September 14, 2012 Tom Over
New American judge may help bring five more Khmer Rouge to trial September 10, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Julian Assange, International Intrigue and What’s Going On With Ecuador September 3, 2012 Sergio Di Cori Modigliani
Yes We Camp August 30, 2012 Tom Over
Beyond Money August 23, 2012 Robert C. Koehler
Love is the key ingredient for successful social movements, not religion, per se. August 20, 2012 Tom Over
1,500 fake "Bomb Detectors" fail to stop explosions in Thailand August 17, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
SPECIAL REPORT -- EXPOSING U.S. AGENTS OF LOW-INTENSITY WARFARE IN AFRICA: The August 15, 2012 keith harmon snow, Conscious Being Alliance
Neocons vs. the ‘Arab Spring’: Back on the Warpath August 10, 2012 Ramzy Baroud
Iran and everything else August 7, 2012 Michael Parenti
Beyond the two-state solution August 6, 2012 David Swanson
Thailand's robots can save your life or kill you, but not yet love you July 22, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
War and Climate Change July 13, 2012 Robert C Koehler
Flesh-eating fish are feeding on tourists' feet July 12, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Veterans For Peace supports U.N. committee in questioning U.S. recruitment, killing of children July 11, 2012
Seeking a Visa for Dr. Wee Teck Young July 5, 2012 Kathy Kelly
NASA's atmosphere probe is grounded by Thailand's squabbling June 29, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
For Love or Money June 29, 2012 By Robert C. Koehler
Julian Assange's Artful Dodge June 22, 2012 Ray McGovern
Turkish court indicts Senior Israeli Military Officials in murders on Gaza flotilla: On the Second Anniversary of the Gaza Freedom Flotilla June 5, 2012 Ann Wright
Aung San Suu Kyi leaves Burma after 24 years June 2, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
No one hears the poor May 28, 2012 Kathy Kelly
Millions of Illegal Methamphetamines Made From Medicine in Thailand's Hospitals May 23, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
FBI seizes server from progressive internet service provider May 15, 2012 Jamie McClelland, May First/People Link
Thaksin wants to avoid assassination and prison in Thailand April 30, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Via campesina and allies call for global solidarity in fight against land grabs April 26, 2012 Tom Over
Proud to wear a forbidden burqa in France April 19, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
A message of peace and friendship from Iran April 10, 2012 David Swanson
Aung San Suu Kyi stoops to conquer Burma March 30, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Universal Declaration of Human Responsibilities March 19, 2012 David Swanson
Why Israel attacked Gaza: Bibi stirring trouble March 16, 2012 Ramzy Baroud
Columbus Activists Look South to help build Global Justice Movement March 14, 2012 Tom Over
Alcohol & politics: A volatile mix in Thailand March 11, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Activists Call for Kroger's Support of Migrant Farm Worker Rights March 9, 2012 Tom Over
Large coalition asks for Obama's Nobel Peace Prize to be rescinded March 2, 2012 War is a Crime
Iranians allegedly posted "Baked Clay" signs to attack Bangkok February 26, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Alleged Iranian bombers cavorted with Thai women in beach resort February 24, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Cold war in warm waters: US-China's dangerous contest for Asia-Pacific February 23, 2012 Ramzy Baroud
Three alleged Iranian bomb-makers arrested after bungling the plot February 20, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Happy savages February 20, 2012 Robert C. Koehler
Food Sovereignty Activist Calls for Alliances between Progressives and ' Radicals ' February 15, 2012 Tom Over
Alleged Iranian bomb-maker blows off his own leg February 15, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Obama's Super-Bowl Fumble on Iran February 8, 2012 Ray McGovern
A Banquet Feasts on Yingluck's Troubles in Thailand February 7, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Thai government promotes Red Shirt leader & pro-Mugabe supporter January 28, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Terror suspect says ammonia in his "Cool Packs" not for bombs January 23, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Alleged terrorist reveals stockpile of bomb-making chemicals in Bangkok January 21, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
Church of the Dude, inspired by The Big Lebowski, sets up in Thailand January 18, 2012 Richard S. Ehrlich
A tale of 2 countries January 12, 2012 Saul Landau and Nelson P. Valdés
Aljazeera coverage: The revolution will be televised, and also manipulated January 12, 2012 Ramzy Baroud
Read International Issues Articles by Year: 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |