The Free Press: Speaking Truth to Power Thu Aug 21 2008
Departments
National Issues

The Devil in the Details: Carter-Baker, California, and the Integrity of American Elections
by Warren Stewart, Director of Legislative Issues and Policy, VoteTrustUSA
September 22, 2005

Most of the very correct objections to the Carter-Baker report appearing in the days since its release have focused on the deeply objectionable Voter ID recommendations. Less attention has been paid to the watershed significance of the Commission’s call to congress to establish a nationwide requirement for a voter verified paper record (VVPR) of every vote and the subtle, but devastating, flaws in the details of that recommendation.

It is critical that their language specifically recommending that it be left up to the states to determine if the voter verified record is the “ballot of record,” is not used as a blueprint for legislation that would result in a meaningless and expensive placebo. The Commission’s recognized that “regular audits of voting machines are also needed to double-check the accuracy of the machines’ vote totals”, but then recommends only that officials “publicly test all types of voting machines before, during, and after Election Day and allow public observation of zero machine counts at the start of Election Day and the machine certification process.” Such testing is not an audit in which hand counts of voter verified ballots are compared to machine counts.

Two adamantly paperless DRE states, Maryland and Georgia, have been making noises recently about accepting the importance of VVPR, which is to be commended, but if the status of the VVPR is left up to states the results could be yet another windfall for the vendors, with millions of dollars spent to provide and, in some cases, develop printers for their machines, while the VVPR is simply tossed in the trash.

In California right now there is pressure on the Governor to veto recently passed legislation (SB 370) that requires the VVPR be used in the state’s minimal (1%) random audit. California’s audit requirement was established in response to concerns about punch card machines, long before the advent of paperless electronic machines, and its implementation has been haphazard at best. The current legislation is merely meant to clarify and update the original intent of the audit. Not surprisingly, it passed unanimously in the State Senate and by a wide margin in the Assembly, but all will be lost if the Schwarzenegger vetoes since the legislature is now out of session.

If Congress uses the Commission’s recommendations as justification for weakening the language of existing legislation like Rep. Rush Holt’s Voter Confidence and Increased Accessibility Act (HR 550), or to introduce a new bill that requires a VVPR but leaves it to the states to determine its status, the situation in California could be repeated in states across the country. Rather than Congress providing the entire nation with some assurance about the accuracy and security of voting systems, it would be left to State Election Administrators and Governors to mitigate that assurance.

Fortunately many states have passed excellent legislation not only creating a requirement that voting systems produce or require the use of a VVPR, but also establishing that the VVPR will be used in audits and recounts and that, in the case of inconsistencies with machine counts, the VVPR will be correctly considered the true and correct record of the voter’s vote. However, most states do not have such clear language in their election laws, and Federal legislation on the issue should be strong and unambiguous.

The Commission’s acknowledgement of the fundamental necessity of vote verification by the voters and not the machines marks the end of one battle and the beginning of another. Until now, VVPR opponents argued that VVPR was impractical or that it was a bad idea. Now even fierce opponents like Georgia Secretary of State Cathy Cox have come around to accept the importance of providing a means of verifying the accuracy of electronic voting machines. The next battle will be making sure that the VVPR is actually used in meaningful audits and in recounts – that it serve the purpose for which it was intended: restoring some degree of confidence in the integrity of the election process in America.


Email this article to a friend




1240 Bryden Road Columbus, Ohio 43209 Ph/Fx 614.253.2571 Email truth@freepress.org
  

Don't forget to check out articles from 2007 and 2008

National Issues

"Rumsfeld admits to "ghosting" detainee"
  December 30, 2005
  David Swanson

"A man without a country"
  December 28, 2005
  David Swanson

"Impeach the Liar-in-Chief"
  December 26, 2005
  Stephen Crockett and Al Lawrence

"Bush wiretaps threaten national security"
  December 25, 2005
  Stephen Crockett

"Which Christmas is the 'War Against Christmas' against? "
  December 25, 2005
  Robert Lockwood Mills

"Rainbow PUSH Wall Street Project plans economic summit in New York City"
  December 22, 2005
  Rainbow PUSH

"Fear of the devil"
  December 22, 2005
  Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services

"It's time to impeach Bush for these blatant violations of the law"
  December 22, 2005
  Andy Ostroy

"December 3 in the USA: a partial report"
  December 22, 2005
  Ted Glick

"Bush spews more irresponsible rhetoric as senate Extends Patriot Act for Six Months"
  December 22, 2005
  Andy Ostroy

"The Constitution in Crisis report"
  December 22, 2005
  Edward Chu

"Privatize Me...Corporatize Me.... Blackwaterize Me..."
  December 20, 2005
  Jason Miller

"USA Patriot Act defeated: Libertarians celebrate victory"
  December 19, 2005
  Libertarian Party of Ohio

"The solution we aren't considering"
  December 19, 2005
  David Swanson

"Panic attack"
  December 15, 2005
  Robert C. Koehler, Tribune Media Services

"Eugene McCarthy, prophet with honor"
  December 12, 2005
  Robert Lockwood Mills

"The iron fist of Jesus"
  December 12, 2005
  Jason Miller

"Progressive primary challenge to Hilary aunched"
  December 6, 2005
  David Swanson

"An invitation to a tea party"
  December 6, 2005
  Lucinda Marshall

"Precarious lives"
  December 3, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

"Criminal trial related to California energy crisis may start soon"
  December 3, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Hey board members, leave our kids alone!"
  December 3, 2005
  Jason Miller

"A Congressman for impeachment"
  November 30, 2005
  David Swanson

"Friday night Congress: what was that?"
  November 23, 2005
  David Swanson

"Teach our children well"
  November 20, 2005
  Todd Huffman, M.D.

"Greenhouse School secures major art donation"
  November 18, 2005
  Dan Welch

"Parental guidance suggested"
  November 16, 2005
  Mike Ferner

"Our mothers (and Thomas Paine) warned us about people like the disciples of Strauss"
  November 13, 2005
  Jason Miller

"Despite his demeanor, Rove's still a Target"
  November 13, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Armistice Day 2005"
  November 11, 2005
  Stephen Edward Seadler

"The Bush-Cheney ethics refresher course"
  November 7, 2005
  David Swanson

"Vice President lied as White House sought to defuse leak inquiry"
  November 7, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"53% of Americans support impeachment; ImpeachPAC announced!"
  November 5, 2005
  David Swanson

"I can't wait"
  November 3, 2005
  David Swanson

"Nothing to Lose"
  November 2, 2005
  Daniel Patrick Welch

"The real Rosa Parks"
  October 31, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

"How has it come to this?"
  October 30, 2005
  Jim Oberg

"Bush's wheels falling off"
  October 30, 2005
  Reverend Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.

"Miers, White House surrender to ultraconservatives"
  October 27, 2005
  Josh Glasstetter

"Prosecutor secures indictment in CIA outing case, lawyers say"
  October 27, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Hard conversations about the big easy"
  October 24, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

"Coalition of 75 groups demand end to Pentagon's youth database"
  October 19, 2005
  Mike Ferner

"Vice President's role in outing of CIA agent under examination, sources close to prosecutor say"
  October 19, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Hard questions about the big easy"
  October 19, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

"Times reporter entangled in leak case had unusual relationship with military, Iraqi group"
  October 19, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Try and catch the wind"
  October 17, 2005
  Daniel Patrick Welch

"More from the stormfront gulf central"
  October 16, 2005
  David Lewis

"A deep look at corruption culture"
  October 16, 2005
  Stephen Crockett and Al  Lawrence

"Dems Go After Bennett, Salem Radio Network, FCC"
  October 9, 2005
  David Swanson

"Bill Bennett’s comments emerge from an ideology that is classic white supremacy, Rev. Jesse Jackson says"
  October 5, 2005
  Rev. Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.

"Why the nomination of Harriet has to be looked at below the radar"
  October 5, 2005
  Cynthia L. Butler, an Attorney licensed in PA, NJ, DC, CA

"In support of weakness on national security"
  October 3, 2005
  David Swanson

"Bill Frist, The Former 2008 Presidential Candidate"
  September 27, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Winds of change blow through DC, Bush flees"
  September 26, 2005
  Bob Fitrakis

"More New Orleans stories"
  September 25, 2005
  David Lewis

"From the stormfront: experiencing Rita in New Orleans"
  September 25, 2005
  David Lewis

"The GOP’s fiscal policies turned a natural disaster into a man-made catastrophe"
  September 23, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"The Devil in the Details: Carter-Baker, California, and the Integrity of American Elections"
  September 22, 2005
  Warren Stewart, Director of Legislative Issues and Policy, VoteTrustUSA

"Hurricane Katrina-Our Experiences"
  September 21, 2005
  Larry Bradshaw, Lorrie Beth Slonsky

"A Fraction of Democracy"
  September 20, 2005
  Greg Coleridge

"Bring back New Orleans: the politics of disaster"
  September 20, 2005
  David Lewis, Photos by Aaron Geiser

"Rev. Jackson Recommends a 21st Century Marshall Plan That Reinvests in the Gulf Coast"
  September 20, 2005
  Rev. Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.

"Division of funeral corp. charged with desecrating corpses hired to collect deceased victims of hurricane Katrina"
  September 19, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"FEMA Chief Brown paid millions in false claims to help Bush win Fla. votes"
  September 15, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Indefinite Detention"
  September 9, 2005
  Daniel Sturm

"Seems like more people died than prospered under Pres Bush’s leadership"
  September 8, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Politics, timing and the so-called terrorist Nuradin Abdi: the mall bomber who wasn't"
  September 7, 2005
  Bob Fitrakis

"Paul Allen's other yacht"
  September 4, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

"Katrina: A tragedy made worse"
  September 4, 2005
  Rev. Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.

"The President’s priorities: state of marriage took precedence over state of Louisiana"
  September 3, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Notes from inside New Orleans"
  September 3, 2005
  Jordan Flaherty

"Rev. Jackson Makes Second Rescue Mission into New Orleans"
  September 2, 2005
  Rainbow/PUSH Coalition

"Bush Strafes New Orleans, Where's Huey Long?"
  September 2, 2005
  Greg Palast

"911 in New Orleans"
  September 2, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

"Global Warming and Widespread Blackouts Are Just as Deadly as Terrorism"
  September 1, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"The mothers are coming!"
  August 30, 2005
  Sheila Samples

"Update from Leonard Peltier"
  August 16, 2005
  Leonard Peltier

"Leonard has been transferred to USP Lewisburg"
  August 16, 2005
  Michael Eckhardt

"Against Discouragement"
  August 15, 2005
  Howard Zinn

"Open Letter to Cindy Sheehan, Crawford, Texas"
  August 11, 2005
  Ralph Nader

"Regarding the 40th Anniversary of the Voting Rights Act of 1965"
  August 4, 2005
  Sabrina Williams

"Lawyers, guns and money: Just put down that lawsuit, pardner, and no one gets hurt"
  August 1, 2005
  Greg Palast

"Forgotten Victims of America’s Plutocracy"
  August 1, 2005
  Jason Miller

"Spine, spine everywhere a spine"
  July 29, 2005
  Rady Ananda

"Speaking truth to Roberts"
  July 28, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

"Business as usual with Judge Roberts; straight corporate, with Pepto-Bismol chaser"
  July 21, 2005
  Alexander Cockburn and Jeffrey St Clair

"The Record of Judge John Roberts"
  July 20, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

"The Enemy of Our Enemy May Still Be the Enemy of Democracy"
  July 13, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

"Mr. Rove and the Access of Evil: Tell Us Your "Source," Judy"
  July 13, 2005
  Greg Palast

"The Economy Turned the Corner and Is Headed in the Wrong Direction"
  July 8, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

"July 4th Declaration of Impeachment"
  July 4, 2005
  Mike Ferner, Veterans for Peace

"They Died for Their Country"
  July 1, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

"Energy adviser who solicited Enron to help write national energy policy to be named Chair of FERC"
  July 1, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Big Food Strikes Back; Ag industry aims to strip local control of food supplies"
  June 26, 2005
  Britt Bailey and Brian Tokar

"The fantastical world of Studley McMuffin"
  June 25, 2005
  Sheila Samples

"Counter-Recruitment: Preventing the Military from Getting More Youth for their Wars: An Interview with Counter-Recruitment Activist Clint Coppernoll"
  June 25, 2005
  Kevin Zeese

"A matter of education..."
  June 23, 2005
  Sheila Samples

"Violations of Civil Liberties are an American Tradition"
  June 17, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

"Rumsfeld: Beyond the Point of No Return"
  June 13, 2005
  Gerald Rellick

"Peltier hearing to address Lakota Nation soverignty"
  June 11, 2005
  Russ Redner and Barry Bachrach

"Extraordinarily rancid justices"
  June 10, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

"Former Army Sec, Enron VP, Thomas White Wants Gov't Funding For New Energy Project"
  June 8, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Imposing minority views"
  June 8, 2005
  Stephen Crockett

"When is Someone Going to Toss Rumsfeld into a Cage?"
  June 8, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Republicans: The Anti-Christian, Christian Party"
  June 8, 2005
  Stephen Crockett

"Watergate Proves That Even Presidents Will Break Laws To Achieve Goals"
  June 1, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Oral Histories of the 1970 Kent State Shootings "
  May 22, 2005
  Candi Clevenger, Communications Manager, OhioLINK

"Blurb: End the filibuster -- in 2015"
  May 20, 2005
  Paul Loeb

"The Beginning Of The End Of The Age Of Reason"
  May 16, 2005
  Todd Huffman, M.D.

"Nuking Democracy"
  May 14, 2005
  Paul Loeb

"Conscientious Objection on Trial: The Court Martial of Keith Benderman"
  May 10, 2005
  Kevin B. Zeese

"Barnum on Steroids"
  May 9, 2005
  Jason Miller

"Mother’s Day Without Mom"
  May 7, 2005
  Phil Tajitsu Nash

"An Open Letter to Howard Dean"
  May 5, 2005
  Dennis J. Kucinich

"Appeals Court Nominee Janice Rogers Brown Merits the Filibuster"
  May 3, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

"Activists Spur Historic Call to Exit Iraq"
  April 24, 2005
  William Rivers Pitt

"John Bolton & the Battle for Reality"
  April 24, 2005
  Robert Parry

"Videos expose false arrests at 2004 Republican Convention protests in New York"
  April 24, 2005
  Peter Daniels

"Wal-Mart's Free Market Fallacy"
  April 24, 2005
  Jonathan Tasini

"Howard Dean Becomes Leader of the Other Pro-War Party; Dean on Iraq: “We're There and We Can't Get Out”"
  April 24, 2005
  Kevin Zeese

"You have to pick your team"
  April 20, 2005
  Sonya Vetra Tinsley, as told to Paul Rogat Loeb

"What They Should Fight For"
  April 20, 2005
  David Swanson

"Vigilante Republicans"
  April 13, 2005
  Steven Rosenfeld

"Congresswoman Cynthia Mckinney Urges Reform of Voting Process at Historic Conference"
  April 12, 2005
  Anna Thompson

"Abortion and Schiavo -- The stories we tell"
  April 5, 2005
  Paul Rogat Loeb

"How and Why We're Working to Block the Bankruptcy Bill"
  April 1, 2005
  David Swanson

"Statement on the Passing of Terri Schiavo"
  March 31, 2005
  Reverend Jesse L. Jackson, Sr.

"Veterans for peace call for Congressional action to impeach George W. Bush and Richard Cheney"
  March 30, 2005
  Veterans For Peace

"Zealot and Proud of It"
  March 27, 2005
  Jason Miller

"Non Volunteers, Non-Recruiters, And A Non War "
  March 19, 2005
  Eric Straatsma

"Meet Your New FCC Chairman: Kevin Martin"
  March 17, 2005
  David Bailey

"E.P.A. Nominee Supports Testing of Chemicals on Human Subjects"
  March 11, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

"A luncheon break with Michael Jackson"
  March 11, 2005
  Robert Lockwood Mills

"Gannongate and Asian Pacific America"
  March 9, 2005
  Phil Tajitsu Nash

"I'd rather not say good-bye, Dan"
  March 9, 2005
  Greg Palast

"Free Trade and Frivolous Lawsuits"
  March 7, 2005
  Cyril Mychalejko

"Experiencing Hunter, Experiencing Death: A Eulogy"
  February 28, 2005
  Tom Luffman

"The inevitability trap"
  February 18, 2005
  K.C. Golden

"Bush’s Judicial Nominations are Hardly Mainstream"
  February 17, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

"Senators Clinton and Boxer, Representative Tubbs Jones and others unveil major election reform bill"
  February 17, 2005
  Offices of Sen. Clinton and Rep. Tubb Jones

"The difference between bi-partisanship and non-partisanship"
  February 15, 2005
  Robert Lockwood Mills

"Bush & the Rise of 'Managed-Democracy'"
  February 13, 2005
  Robert Parry

"Yesterday's Gallup Poll Showing Bush Approval At 57% Had 9% More Republicans Than Democrats"
  February 12, 2005
  Steve Soto

"J20 Through my eyes"
  February 11, 2005
  Ryan Mishler

"Bush's Budget: The War on Working People Continues"
  February 11, 2005
  International Action Center staff

"Bush’s Budget is at Odds With His Rhetoric"
  February 11, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

"Direct Action For Peace?"
  February 7, 2005
  Bill Scheurer

"State of the Union speech falls short, says Rev. Jesse Jackson"
  February 3, 2005
  Rev. Jesse Jackson, Rainbow/PUSH Coalition

"The Black Perspective"
  February 3, 2005
  Judith Powell

"Save American Democracy: Curb Corporate Power"
  January 29, 2005
  Stephen Crockett

"Who's Paying for all this Freedom?"
  January 29, 2005
  Darryl Cramer

"Yes, there is a crisis in Social Security"
  January 29, 2005
  Richard Hayes Phillips, Ph.D.

"Agitation Time"
  January 25, 2005
  Ted Glick

"The 10 Worst Corporations of 2004"
  January 25, 2005
  Russell Mokhiber and Robert Weissman

"They Doth Protest Too Little"
  January 24, 2005
  Chris Colin

"Thousands take to the streets to oppose the inauguration of George W. Bush"
  January 24, 2005
  troopsoutnow.org

"A Warm Oasis in a Snow Storm; The Progressive Democrat Summit in Washington"
  January 24, 2005
  Cynthia L. Butler, Esq.

"The Politics of SpongeBob"
  January 23, 2005
  Gene C. Gerard

"Mis-Defining Terrorism"
  January 20, 2005
  John Janney

"Marines stretching movement"
  January 19, 2005
  Mike Ferner

"Bush’s Mythical Mandate and Social Security Piratization"
  January 19, 2005
   Stephen Crockett and Al Lawrence

"Happy Birthday Martin Luther King, Jr. "
  January 16, 2005
  Chuck Zlatkin

"Bush’s Choice for Energy Secretary Was One of Texas’ Top Five Worst Polluters"
  January 16, 2005
  Jason Leopold

"Bush, God, Fox, and the International Criminal Court"
  January 13, 2005
  David Swanson

"The real reason Bush wants to privatize Social Security"
  January 12, 2005
  Robert Lockwood Mills

"CBS' cowardice and conflicts behind purge"
  January 11, 2005
  Greg Palast

"Bring them home -- Sooner rather than later"
  January 1, 2005
  Sheila Samples

Related Journal articles:

"The third wave of victims of Katrina/Rita"
  November 15, 2005

"An inside look at the not so Big Easy"
  November 15, 2005

"While Bush rested: The emergence of the new global terrorism and the meaning of Hurricane Katrina "
  November 15, 2005

"Keeping his eyes on the prize"
  September 8, 2005

"Four Years On"
  September 8, 2005

"Sheehan uses the "f" word as Bush flips us off"
  September 8, 2005

"WAL-MART - The high cost of low price"
  July 20, 2005

"The timebomb is not Social Security in 2048, it’s global warming in 2015"
  March 21, 2005




Read Articles by Year:
2007 2006 2005 2004
2003 2002 2001 2000




All content © 1970-2008
The Columbus Free Press
Disclaimer